Home Affairs Select Committee chair Dame Karen Bradley MP said the ban followed a risk assessment by the force to Birmingham City Council’s safety advisory group.
She asked how WMP assessed the disorder in Amsterdam, what options were considered for policing Thursday’s match, and whether a “bubble” was considered for away-fans.
The letter also queries with the force as to whether it thought Maccabi fans were likely to be victims of antisemitism, and “to what extent did resource constraints mean that WMP felt they were unable to police the fixture effectively” if they were allowed to attend.
Dame Karen also asked whether campaigning about the fixture, including a petition by the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, affected the police assessment.
She queried whether the force was able to consider additional options following the offer of government support.
WMP was asked to provide a copy of the risk assessment and to state whether it will review its footballing operation.
The BBC has also asked to see the risk assessment made.