France arrived at Murrayfield as Grand Slam chasers, as tournament favourites, as the most complete team in European rugby. They left having conceded 50 points on a night that felt, at its worst, like watching a locksmith hand a burglar his own keys.
Antoine Dupont said as much, and he said it without flinching.
“We absorbed every collision and couldn’t get ourselves out of it,” he told Planet Rugby. “Obviously as half-backs, me at nine, that’s my responsibility too. I had no physical problems during the match. I made two errors that cost us dearly.”
He paused before adding what amounted to a quiet indictment of the evening’s shape. “The performance wasn’t there. But talking about individual performances won’t advance the debate. We’ll need to think collectively about not finding ourselves in that situation again.”
Roaring Murrayfield
The errors Dupont referenced came at moments when France were still within touching distance. Each one bled momentum. Scotland, playing with the liberated ferocity of a side that had spent three rounds waiting for this particular fixture, needed no second invitation and in a flash, they had Murrayfield roaring, they had France rattled, and when French discipline cracked, as Dupont acknowledged it did, the Scots were merciless.
Toulouse flanker François Cros, one of the few that emerged with reputation semi-intact, was characteristically honest: “We went through the motions,” he said. “We were beaten in the contest, in the mindset, in the attitude. It wasn’t what we owed ourselves on a match of this importance. We must have got our approach slightly wrong, even if the reaction at the end was commendable. But we didn’t come here to concede 50 points. Our 40 are incidental and lucky. A decoy, really, because Scotland had eased off by then.”
He was asked about overconfidence, about whether the Grand Slam noise had seeped into the dressing room before the work was done. “I don’t know,” he said, and the pause before it was telling. “But it makes you think. Maybe we saw ourselves in a slightly too flattering light, maybe we were thinking about other things before thinking about competing today.”
The turning point, in his view, was the beginning of the second half. France trailed 19-15 at the interval, which was uncomfortable but not alarming. What followed was. Two yellow cards, a defence that invited rather than resisted, and Scotland given the time and space to do precisely what Scotland do when the handbrake is off.
“We conceded points quickly, let them run and pull clear,” Cros said. “We lacked character and reaction after a first half that was already not great. But we were still in it.
“Antoine was stifled. A bit like the team as a whole. When you’re being dominated, it’s naturally harder for him. But we shouldn’t point fingers at anyone and everyone has their share of responsibility.”
What France produced still contained passages of the instinctive, high-tempo brilliance that has made this team the most watchable in the championship. They scored 40 points not as scraps or consolations but from genuine attacking intent, from that offloading game and positional fluidity that no other side in this tournament has come close to replicating. But the gap between intent and outcome was where France’s evening fell apart.
Thomas Ramos had been wary enough during the week to leave a door open.
“I did an interview where I said it’s impossible to talk about a Grand Slam until we’ve come to play in Scotland,” he reflected afterwards. “Well, there’s the proof,” he said, in typical Ramos style, with something between resignation and dark amusement.
But the full-back was not prepared to let the evening become a wake, and that told you something important about where this France squad are in their thinking. The tournament remained theirs to win.
England focus
“We want to win this second consecutive tournament,” he said. “It’s been a very long time since France won two in a row and we don’t want to let that go to another nation. Yes, we’re a bit deflated given the score, but we’ll switch very quickly to the England match to prepare it as best we can.”
Cros framed the week ahead with characteristic bluntness, saying: “The Grand Slam is gone but we are still in a position to win this tournament. We’ll have no excuses next Saturday. It’s up to us to prepare well and go and find something beautiful.”
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
France regroup whilst England await. The Six Nations title remains in French hands to surrender or retain. Dupont will want to put his errors right, Cros will want the scoreline never raised again and Ramos will want the trophy.
Scotland gave them a night that stung. France had better hope the pain is the kind that teaches rather than the kind that lingers, because England will have watched every minute of this and drawn their own conclusions.
READ MORE: France star cited for alleged eye-gouging incident which left Nigel Owens ‘disappointed’