Nolan Wells
Sister of Girl He Allegedly Stayed Behind With at Horn Island Speaks Out
Published
July 24, 2026
9:28 AM PDT
|
Updated
July 24, 2026
11:34 AM PDT

Nolan Wells‘ friends say he hung back on Horn Island with a girl when they left in their boat … but the girl is apparently telling a different story.
19-year-old Katie McCormack spent time with Nolan on the island before his disappearance and death, according to the Daily Mail … and Nolan’s friend, Warren Hudson, says their group was frantically rushing off the island as their vessel took on water … claiming Nolan refused to leave Katie and join them on their journey back to the Mississippi mainland.

Thing is … Katie’s sister, Gracie, told the Daily Mail … “Katie had a conversation and assumed that Nolan was getting ready to get on the boat he came out on.”
Play video content

Katie’s sister added … “Katie assumed the ‘friends’ telling him to get on the boat wouldn’t have left him.”
As you know, 18-year-old Nolan never made it home from Horn Island … and his body was found July 6 in its shallow waters … near where he was last seen alive.
Investigators are still trying to piece together what led up to Nolan’s death … and his family commissioned an independent autopsy.
Preliminary findings revealed he may have suffered a head injury … but there’s no official cause or manner of death yet.