President Trump, in a head spinning move, has imposed new conditions on the proposal for a Saudi Nuclear deal. First, Saudi Arabia must sign the Abraham Accords and establish diplomatic relations with Israel. Second, uranium enrichment, a long sought goal by Saudi Arabia, was now off the table.

The White House press office labeled these terms as “deal breakers and added that if Saudi Arabia does not agree to accept this new condition, “the deal is off.”

Neutron Bytes’ view is that Trump has, at least for now, removed the football from his own kickoff. Future negotiations with Saudi Arabia may yet move the deal ahead. The fat lady hasn’t yet sung her song on this deal.

Two days after announcing that the Trump Administration would submit for congressional approval a 123 Agreement with Saudi Arabia that would allow that country to enrich uranium and buy U.S. nuclear reactors, the President spun heads with new conditions for the deal. He said that the Saudi nuclear deal is now conditioned on Saudi Arabia normalizing diplomatic relations with Israel.

In a post on his social media platform, the President said the “deal is totally subject to Saudi Arabia joining the Abraham Accords. This multilateral agreement has previously been the basis for normalizing diplomatic relations between Israel and other Arab states including the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain. 

When asked about the new requirement, White House spokesperson Karoline Leavitt is reported to have said the requirement “is a final deal breaker” and that the president has discussed the need for the Saudi government to sign on to the Abraham Accords “ on numerous occasions.”

She added that if Saudi Arabia does not agree to accept this new condition, “the deal is off.”

The announcement came as a complete surprise to U.S. and Saudi officials who negotiated the terms of the draft 123 Agreement as the issue had not come up during their talks and is not part of the signed agreement.

History of the Abraham Accords and the Saudi Nuclear Deal

In March 2023 Saudi Arabia approached the U.S. for “security guarantees” relative to Iran and for assistance with its civilian nuclear energy program.

The Saudi government also asked for help in normalizing relations with Israel. Saudi Arabia is reported to have told the Biden administration it is planning to restore diplomatic relations with Iran based on negotiations reported to have been brokered by China.

These actions can be seen as part of a larger effort across multiple vectors to blunt Iran’s nuclear drive as evidenced by IAEA reports that Iran has enriched U235 to 84% which is in weapons’ grade range. For this reason, normalization of relations with Israel, and a request to the US for help with the Saudi nuclear energy program, were seen as being part of the same playbook.

At the time the Saudi request was seen as a non-starter because of the Saudi government’s repeated insistence that it has the right to enrich uranium for use in its plan for deploying two commercial nuclear reactors. The plan is complicated by repeated statements from top level Saudi government officials that if Iran proceeds to develop a nuclear weapon, Saudi Arabia will do so as well.

A stalemate on the Saudi nuclear deal resulted which lasted until last week when the Trump administration announced it would sign, subject to approval by Congress, a 123 agreement that would allow Saudi Arabia to enrich uranium.

The reason the Saudi government dropped its initiative for diplomatic recognition of Israel is the adamant resistance from Benjamin Netanyahu’s Israeli government to the creation of a Palestinian state. Israeli PM Netanyahu responded to Trump’s unexpected announcement about the Abraham Accords being a “deal breaker” for the Saudi nuclear deal by saying he supported it.

Wait, There’s More

Trump also reversed the terms of the draft 123 agreement saying that now the deal would not allow Saudi Arabia to enrich uranium.  According to Trump’s social media post, he wrote, “There will be no enrichment of material.”  He did not explain the reason for the change in his post on his social media platform. 

The draft agreement with Saudi Arabia contains a provision that export of U.S. nuclear reactors, and the issue of uranium enrichment, would be subject to pending the completion of a two-year study of the issues.

Trump added that the U.S. is “not opposed to civil nuclear facilites.” In other words, Trump imposed new conditions on the 123 Agreement which included opening the door to U.S. exports of civilian commercial nuclear reactors, but slammed it shut on Saudi ambitions to get the deal with approval of uranium enrichment.

What Does this Mean for the Saudi Nuclear Deal?

Trump’s surprise moves to reframe the 123 Agreement put two deal breakers in front of  Saudi acceptance as things stand now. The Saudi government will not agree to diplomatic recognition of Israel unless Israel agrees to create a Palestinian state. The Saudi government has made uranium enrichment the centerpiece of any nuclear deal with the U.S. It has said repeatedly that if it does not get the enrichment piece, it will open the door to China to provide it with nuclear reactors.

The questions about the new conditions Trump imposed on the nuclear deal are what is he trying to do and why now? Here are three scenarios by expert observers, who due to their positions outside of government, are not identified.

According to one observer of the situation, the motive is that by tying a U.S.-Saudi nuclear agreement to normalization with Israel, he has shifted the burden of compromise. In this scenario, it appears he’s making it clear that if Saudi Arabia wants access to U.S. civilian nuclear technology and cooperation, it must also deliver a major strategic concession in return. Trump has long seen getting Saudi Arabia to open diplomatic relations with Israel as a signature achievement for his presidency.

Another observer says that “spiking the nuclear deal with unacceptable conditions is a gift to Chinese PM Xi who can now expect his phone to ring with a call from Saudi Arabia to sell China’s Hualong One (1,000 MW PWR) reactors.” Xi is expected to visit the U.S. in September. This scenario seems far fetched in terms of Trump’s intentions, but if the Saudis walk away from a U.S. nuclear deal, while they might not get enrichment, they most certainly can buy nuclear reactors from China as well as the fuel to run them. China, as member of the nuclear club, is not interested in seeing a new member. Also, China, as a major buyer of oil and gas from Iran, is not interested in taking actions to put Saudi Arabia on a path to develop a nuclear weapons program. For these reasons, it is unlikely that China would support Saudi Arabia’s desire for an enrichment program.

A third observer said that Trump “spiked the deal due to blowback from Congress on the nonproliferation issues and also from South Korea” which was short listed by Saudi Arabia to sell its 1400 MW PWs to that country. According to this perspective, South Korea was also “infuriated” by the double standard of refusing to allow it to enrich uranium under its 123 Agreement with the U.S. while allowing Saudi Arabia to go ahead. South Korea, which is a key U.S. ally in Southeast Asia, has for years sought to change its 123 agreement with the U.S. to allow uranium enrichment and reprocessing of spent nuclear fuel.  The U.S. has consistently denied these requests.

At the end of the trail of people unhappy with Trump’s imposition of new requirements for the Saudi nuclear deal is Westinghouse. The company was not invited to bid on the Saudi nuclear tender released for two new PWRs. The new U.S. 123 announcement firmly positioned Westinghouse to offer its AP1000 PWRs to Saudi Arabia. This opportunity has now gone away in a puff of social media smoke at least for now.

One thing to consider and that is Trump’s mercurial nature.  He has been known to suddenly reverse lines he’s drawn in the sand over policy matters especially in the realm of international relations.  Trump has two more years in the White House so these current “deal breakers” may be modified or reversed or accepted if by some slim chance Saudi Arabia agrees to Trump’s condition for diplomatic recognition of Israel regardless of the current opposition to a Palestinian stage by PM Netanyahu.

Two years is a long time in the world of DC politics. The old terms in basketball and in opera still apply. It is not over until the fat lady sings.

# # #

Discover more from Neutron Bytes

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

About djysrv
~ About this blog and disclaimers for NeutronBytes ~
~ https://neutronbytes.com/2014/08/31/welcome-post/
~ Dan Yurman, Editor and Publisher

** Contact Me **
~ neutronbytes@gmail.com ~
~ Text me via SIGNAL djysrv.03 ~
~ https://www.linkedin.com/in/danyurman/ ~

~ I am NOT active on Facebook Reddit, Substack, Snapchat, or Instagram. Attempt no landings there. ~
~ The Twitter (X) account is not in use due to the turmoil on that platform. ~

~ Notices of new posts can be received signing up for the blog email list. ~
~ Follow posts as they as published on BlueSky ~ https://bsky.app/profile/neutronbytes.bsky.social ~
~ For a listing of sources of nuclear energy news, see this page on this blog. ~ https://neutronbytes.com/nuclear-reading-list/

** Header Image Credit:
http://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap110904.html ~

** Emails sent by readers about blog posts are considered to be comments for publication unless otherwise noted.

** The content of this blog is protected by copyright laws of the U.S. “Fair use” provisions apply. The RSS feed is for personal use only unless otherwise explicitly granted.

** Please credit Neutron Bytes if you cite its content. **

** Consulting Services **

I can help you grow your business. Do you need Strategic Planning? Project Management? Click here for my capability statement. https://bit.ly/40E6nNT

There is no advertising on this blog. Please support Neutron Bytes. Click here. https://buymeacoffee.com/neutronbytes

DISCLAIMER

This blog does not provide “advice” of any kind be it legal, financial, or engineering analysis. You are solely responsible for any use you make of information posted on this blog for the obvious reason that it makes no claim to having professional expertise of any kind in these areas. The views here are solely those of the author as protected free speech.

# # #