Zack Kligler, an organizer with Providence for Palestine, said the group is not aware of any countries other than Israel that would currently qualify.
Get Rhode Map
A weekday briefing from veteran Rhode Island reporters, focused on the things that matter most in the Ocean State.
“We believe that the people of Providence want to see an end to genocide in Gaza and other acts of apartheid and genocide that corporations are profiting from, and our politicians haven’t acted on that yet,” Kligler said. “In November, voters will have a chance to directly have a voice in how our city funds are invested.”
If approved by voters, the proposal would not only bar the city from investing directly in countries committing human rights violations, but would also require it to divest from entities that are “complicit” in the foreign country’s actions. That could mean a long list of companies from Google to Chevron to Boeing, according to groups that advocate for divestment measures around the country.
The ballot question is likely to inflame tensions in Rhode Island’s deep-blue capital city, where Democrats are divided over the conflict in the Middle East. The issue has split city leaders repeatedly since the war in Gaza began, including when City Council leaders raised a Palestinian flag over City Hall last year.
It also raises questions about how to untangle the city’s interests in a potentially wide range of companies that are part of the $650 million pension fund.
“It would be impossible,” said City Treasurer Shomari Husband, a council-appointee and certified public accountant who would be tasked under the ordinance with reviewing Providence’s investment portfolio and identifying holdings to be sold.
“I do like the idea of them saying, ‘we’re not comfortable with the city dollars being used to fund an atrocity,’ and deciding to exert that leverage,” Husband said.
But he said the proposal is overly broad, and could impact a wide variety of index funds in which the city’s pension fund is invested.
“That would impossible to monitor continuously, because some of these funds are constantly rebalancing, buying equities,” Husband said. If the measure passes, he said, “It will definitely be a daunting task for me.”
City Council President Rachel Miller has already said she supports the ballot question, while Mayor Brett Smiley opposes it.
The council had considered a more narrow divestment proposal specific to Israeli government bonds in 2024, but it never made it out of committee.
Smiley said the city’s legal department has determined the ordinance is “unenforceable” and could potentially violate a law that bars the state from doing business with entities engaged in boycotts or divestments, signed by former Governor Gina Raimondo in 2016.
City Solicitor Jeff Dana said the ordinance would also violate the Providence Home Rule Charter, which gives the city’s Board of Investment Commissioners the power to decide where to invest city funds.
“This proposal will be unproductive, burdensome to our election officials and will harm the finances of our city and our already underfunded pension system,” Smiley said in a statement. “I urge voters to vote no.”
Miller, in a letter to the organizers earlier this year, declined to have the council take up the matter, but said she would vote yes in November.
“Gaza has been decimated by bombs funded by American taxpayers, while settler violence in the West Bank escalates with little to no accountability,” Miller said. “Whether with Israel, Sudan, or anywhere else, Providence should not be investing public funds in governments committing war crimes.”
Divesting funds as a political statement is not unique to Israel. It was widely used in the 1980s during a pressure campaign against apartheid in South Africa.
Israeli divestment initiatives have not been widely adopted, but have taken hold in some other cities, including Portland, Maine and Medford, Mass. Medford’s divestment measure, which passed in a veto override last year, now faces a pending legal challenge in federal court.
Kligler said the group kept their proposal open-ended, rather than naming Israel directly, so that it could potentially be used against other countries in the future.
He did not have a list of which companies would be subject to divestment under the proposal, but challenged the idea that it would be difficult to implement.
“This is definitely precedented, and other cities have pursued very similar measures without putting their investments at significant risk,” Kligler said.
Providence doesn’t directly own any Israeli government bonds right now, though it has investments in a Vanguard index fund that contains dozens of foreign government bonds, including roughly $119,000 in Israeli bonds, spokesperson Josh Estrella said.
The Jewish Alliance of Rhode Island opposes the ballot question, arguing it “does nothing to advance meaningful peace, security, or coexistence for Israelis and Palestinians.”
“Providence’s investment decisions should be driven by what’s best for Providence residents — not by divisive political tests that make our community more polarized and less united,” said Steven Baker, the group’s president and CEO, in a statement.
The Alliance has sent out communications to members urging them to oppose the ordinance, calling it an “assault on the identity and belonging of the many Jews — who hold diverse views but largely affirm Israel’s right to exist — and for whom Israel is part of their Jewish identity.”
“The notion that this ordinance singles out the Jewish community is absurd,” Kligler countered. “The campaign behind this ordinance has been led by many Jewish organizers, including myself, for whom organizing for Palestinian liberation and for justice for all people, is a core part of our Jewish values.”
Kligler said the Providence for Palestine Coalition submitted 10,000 signatures, far above the requirement to get 5 percent of the city’s qualified voters, or 5,549 signatures.
The city’s board of canvassers has been working to verify each signature, and as of this week the group crossed the threshold to qualify for the ballot with 5,837 verified signatures.
A little-known provision in the city charter requires the City Council to put the question on the ballot as long as citizens submit the required number of signatures in time.
The deadline for ballot questions is next week, so the City Council plans to return from summer recess to take a procedural vote Thursday night to send the ordinance to the Secretary of State’s office.
“In a moment when our elections are under attack by the Trump Administration, I am disappointed that this effort is consuming resources that should be spent protecting the integrity of our elections,” Smiley said.
The general election is on Nov. 3.
Steph Machado can be reached at steph.machado@globe.com. Follow her @StephMachado.