A redacted report the State Department quietly posted online in late October sheds additional light on the Department’s failure to comply with the law with regard to U.S. security assistance to Israel. The report from the State Department Office of the Inspector General (OIG) concerns the implementation of the Leahy law, the statute that bars the United States from providing assistance to foreign security force units that have committed gross violations of human rights. The OIG report specifically addresses the law’s requirements for countries that receive assistance that cannot be traced to specific units — known as non-traceable assistance (NTA). When U.S. assistance cannot be traced, it prevents vetting of recipient units, and triggers a mandatory requirement, introduced in 2021, that the State Department provide a list of units that are prohibited from receiving U.S. assistance to the recipient governments and receive assurances from them that no U.S. assistance will go to those units. As of April 2025, Israel was one of four NTA countries (in addition to Egypt, Jordan, and Ukraine). As of September 2025, Israel was the only one of the four to which the Department has not furnished a list of ineligible units. 

The OIG report demonstrates that the Department has created an unlawful de facto exemption to the law for Israel. The Department has apparently done so by failing to adjudicate hundreds of credible allegations of gross violations of human rights by Israeli security forces. Instead, it has allowed reports of these abuses to pile up without action. As a former senior member of the Department’s Near Eastern Affairs Bureau wrote earlier this year, the Leahy law has been “effectively suspended in Israel’s case.” The OIG report provides further public evidence of that damning conclusion.

Israel Backlog Will Take Over 12.5 Years to Adjudicate

The report’s most remarkable finding is that, as of September 2025, the State Department had a backlog of unadjudicated alleged gross violations of human rights by Israeli security force units that, at the present rate (at the time the report was issued), will take over 12.5 years to adjudicate.

The report included three recommendations for the Department pertinent to Israel: to reduce the time required to adjudicate Israeli cases; to finalize guidance for the Israel Leahy Vetting Forum (ILVF); and to clarify the requirements governing the gap between determination of a gross violation of human rights and the determination of remediation, which is when the State Department decides corrective steps have been taken so that the unit is once again eligible for assistance. In a letter dated Sept. 16, 2025, the Department concurred with all three recommendations and undertook to complete the first by March 2026, and the other two by January 2026.

Based on the Department’s concurrence and assertions, OIG determined all three recommendations had been “resolved.” However, there has been no indication since September 2025 that the Department actually followed through on any of them. If the past is prologue, there is reason for doubt.

The report stated that there were 30 units in countries receiving NTA that committed gross violations of human rights and 25 of them were ineligible for assistance. The identities of the 30 units are redacted. However, the five unit difference is presumably due to five earlier cases where the State Department made dubious determinations that Israeli units had committed gross violations of human rights but were remediated and therefore eligible for U.S. assistance (none of these cases concerned the current war in Gaza). In these cases, the Department claimed Israel had taken “effective steps to bring the responsible members of the security forces unit to justice.” 

The most flagrant of these remediations was for the notorious Netzah Yehuda Battalion, where the Department deemed that mere administrative measures, and no criminal prosecutions, were sufficient to remediate a unit responsible for the death of an American citizen. A September 2025 State Department report to Congress stated that 24 other NTA ineligibilities were for Egypt, Jordan, and Ukraine. 

So at most, the Department has found one Israeli unit ineligible in five years of Leahy vetting. The more likely number is zero (especially since the Department’s September 2025 report to Congress lists 24 units, none of which is Israeli). Either way, the numbers show clear evidence of the Department’s bad faith in Leahy enforcement for Israel.

The high-profile Netzah Yehuda case is likely the Leahy violation that generated the OIG recommendation that the Department follow the law and hold units ineligible for assistance pending remediation. Remediation most often does not happen, and when it does, is a lengthy process. In the Netzah Yehuda case, in an apparent first, the Department continued eligibility for the unit pending the (woefully inadequate) “remediation.” However, the remediation process assumes there is credible information of a gross violation of human rights to remediate. Under the law, this triggers immediate ineligibility. Yet Netzah Yehuda, a unit that killed an American citizen, remained eligible for months while the Department and Israel dithered over remediation.

Without mentioning Netzah Yehuda, the OIG report nevertheless recognized that this practice “increases the risk that security assistance may be provided to ineligible units during the lengthy remediation process.” Because remediation is rare for any country, and practically non-existent for Israel, this enforcement gap invites Israel – or any country – to claim remediation for a unit is ongoing, and for the Department to continue eligibility ad infinitum.

Legally Irrelevant, Specious Arguments Against Leahy Enforcement

The Department has never officially explained its failure to enforce Leahy with regard to Israel, except to say that investigations are ongoing or cases are being reviewed. The twelve and a half year backlog suggests these claims are false. The real reason appears to be that, behind the scenes, opponents of applying the law to Israel at the State Department and on the National Security Council have advanced specious, legally irrelevant policy arguments. 

The Leahy law does not exempt units based on policy arguments. Yet during the Biden administration, Secretary of State Antony Blinken reportedly refused to implement Leahy with regard to Israel due to speculation that it would jeopardize unrelated ceasefire negotiations. The argument was far-fetched in 2024, and is obsolete now that Israel has signed the October 2025 Gaza peace plan. 

When he was a senator, Secretary of State Marco Rubio opposed holding Netzah Yehuda (the unit that killed an American citizen) Leahy-ineligible, on the grounds that it was an effort “to appease Israel’s enemies” and that it would “stigmatize the entire IDF and encourage Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Iranian regime.” 

In the first place, the notion that this would stigmatize the entire IDF is an obvious misstatement of the Leahy law, which cuts off U.S. assistance only to the unit responsible for the gross violation of human rights – and continues assistance to rights-respecting units. 

In addition, applying Leahy to Israel would have no effect on overall U.S. security assistance to Israel. U.S. assistance was 10 percent of Israel’s 2025 defense budget. Israel is free to move its own funds to Leahy-ineligible units as the United States moves U.S. assistance to rights-respecting units. 

And the assertion that implementing Leahy would help Israel’s enemies is simply wrong. The opposite is true: Israel’s enemies draw support from the very gross violations of human rights that the Leahy law attempts to address. Meanwhile, the United States’ failure to address Israeli human rights violations deepens American diplomatic isolation and undermines U.S. influence worldwide. 

In the wake of Israeli elections, the current uncertainty about the Israeli government will spawn the-time-is-not-right arguments against implementing Leahy with regard to Israel. This exact Leahy/Israel argument was a hardy perennial when I served in the Department (notably, proponents never explained when the time would be “right”). On the contrary, now is a golden opportunity to signal to all parties that the United States expects Israel to rein in and punish its security forces if they commit gross violations of human rights. 

Crossing the Red Line, Akbar Sahid Ahmed’s deeply researched new book on the Biden administration’s handling of Gaza, suggests another fundamentally flawed argument against implementing Leahy enforcement against Israeli units: a misreading, perhaps deliberate, of the law. According to Ahmed, Deputy National Security Adviser Jon Finer and other White House officials viewed “reaching legal conclusions” with regard to Israel as discretionary, considering it “an option, not a responsibility.” The Department of Justice advanced this very type of argument as recently as May 2026 – claiming “the discretionary nature of the Leahy Law process” – in defending a lawsuit that seeks to compel the State Department to implement the Leahy law with regard to Israel (pp. 9-10). 

This is legal sophistry. Yes, decisions on ineligibility of individual units belong to the secretary of state. However, the requirement to provide a list of ineligible units to countries such as Israel that receive non-traceable assistance is mandatory: “the Secretary shall provide a list of ineligible units” (emphasis added) to all NTA countries. 

Dishonest Evasion of the Law; No Shortage of Valid Leahy Cases

The OIG report indicates that the Department has dishonestly evaded this mandatory requirement by simply not adjudicating Israeli units. Instead, according to the OIG report, the Department has let allegations against Israeli units pile up, creating an enormous backlog. And in over a year since the report, more allegations have indeed piled up.

As it stands now, the Department would have the world believe that only five Israeli security force units have ever committed a gross violation of human rights, none in Gaza, and all have been remediated. This defies reason, and surely defies the law.

Amid the hundreds of unadjudicated allegations, there is no shortage of reports that satisfy the Leahy “credible information” standard, which does not require proof beyond a reasonable doubt, nor clear and convincing evidence, nor even evidence that would be admissible in court. For years, the State Department’s own annual Human Rights Reports have conceded, albeit generally without naming individual units, that there were “credible reports” that Israeli security forces had committed gross violations of human rights.

One obvious case for State Department action would be the unanimous recommendation of every relevant State Department bureau, and the U.S. Embassy in Jerusalem, that units associated with torture at Israel’s notorious Sde Teiman military prison be found ineligible. That recommendation reportedly sat on Blinken’s desk for weeks until he left office. Since then, the only thing that has changed in that case is the Israeli government’s March 2026 decision to dismiss charges against five alleged Sde Teiman perpetrators of torture despite overwhelming medical and video evidence of guilt. This case is a prime example of how failure to apply Leahy law to Israel fosters impunity and perpetuates gross violations of human rights by Israeli security forces.

Failure to Implement NTA Requirements Across the Globe

In addition to the Department’s failures on Israel, the report’s conclusions demonstrate an appalling failure to implement the law’s NTA provisions worldwide.

The Department conducts an annual survey to determine which countries are receiving NTA and are therefore subject to the requirement to identify ineligible units and receive assurances no U.S. assistance will go to them. As of September 2025, the Department had identified four countries – Egypt, Israel, Jordan, and Ukraine – as NTA recipients. 

However, the report found that:

On average, 48 percent of all overseas missions did not respond to annual requirements to certify if a country was receiving NTA; 
The Department had not developed or distributed comprehensive guidance and training to help staff implement NTA requirements;
Some staff were unaware of what NTA was or what its requirements were, contributing to some overseas missions not implementing NTA requirements. 

This widespread ignorance about the law’s requirements creates significant risk that there are additional countries receiving NTA that have not implemented the law’s provisions and that units in those countries that have committed gross violations of human rights remain eligible for assistance. It also demonstrates the low priority the Department gives to the Leahy law.

 A Strong Argument for Action

The State Department has created an unlawful de facto Leahy exception for Israel. Scores of Israeli units that have likely committed gross violations of human rights, including units that have killed American citizens, remain eligible for U.S. assistance. 

For years, the United States has been reduced to trying to convince Israel to prevent and punish these types of violations, and then has stood by helplessly while Israel refuses. The result has been to reinforce Israeli impunity, even when its forces kill American citizens.

Most State Department officers care deeply about human rights and the rule of law. The OIG report furnishes them with new arguments to move the Department’s leaders to finally take action. 

FEATURED IMAGE: Office lights are illuminated in the U.S. Department of State headquarters building at dusk on July 11, 2025, in Washington, DC. (Photo by J. David Ake/Getty Images)