California prosecutors and victims’ advocates have sued the state’s governor, Gavin Newsom, to stop him from commuting the death sentences of all 548 people facing execution in the state.
The district attorneys from 30 of California’s 58 counties filed the lawsuit on Monday, challenging the Democratic governor’s mass clemency action announced earlier this month, which would be the largest clearing of any death row in modern US history. Other state prosecutors have supported Newsom’s announcement and are due to speak in favor of the commutations in a press briefing on Tuesday.
The 30 opposing prosecutors, along with victims’ relatives and advocacy groups, argued in a petition filed with the California supreme court that Newsom has abused his executive power and failed to properly give notice to district attorneys and victims’ families. Newsom has argued that his clemency authority allows him to issue a blanket commutation for everyone condemned to death in the state, allowing them to instead be sentenced to life without the possibility of parole.
Newsom, considered a probable presidential candidate in 2028, made the announcement as his gubernatorial term was coming to an end, arguing he had a moral imperative to stand against state-sanctioned killings and noting that California has the largest death row in the western hemisphere.
Newsom previously issued a moratorium on executions and dismantled the state’s infamous death row chamber in the San Quentin prison, allowing people with death sentences to leave their solitary cells and integrate with the general population.
The opposing petition is backed by district attorneys from some of the state’s largest jurisdictions, including Los Angeles, San Diego, Riverside and Sacramento. The lawsuit argues that the governor was required to give victims and DAs an opportunity to provide input before granting them clemency.
“Governor Newsom decided his personal views should override all those who actually participated in the process, followed and applied the law. He did none of that, as he freely admits. That alone is an abuse of power that must not stand,” the petition said.
The governor has argued he is only required to give that notice when he is ruling on a commutation application filed by a prisoner, not when he is acting of his own initiative to grant clemency en masse.
Under California’s constitution, the state’s supreme court also has to approve commutations for people convicted of multiple felonies, and Newsom has already sent a letter to the court asking for clemency approval for the 382 people with death sentences who fall in that category.
skip past newsletter promotionFree newsletter |Around 2-3 times a day
Sign up to Breaking News US
Get the most important news as it breaks

after newsletter promotion
Newsom’s commutations have sharply divided victims’ advocates and prosecutors. The district attorneys of Santa Clara and Contra Costa counties issued statements on Monday in support of Newsom’s commutations, arguing the death penalty was outdated, ineffective and costly.
Family members of some victims have also come out in support of commutations, including the sisters of Polly Klaas, a 12-year-old killed in 1993 in a high-profile case that helped push tough-on-crime laws nationwide. The man who killed their sister is one of the death row prisoners granted a commutation.
“Nothing will undo our loss, and we don’t ask anyone to pretend otherwise. What we are asking is that California stop treating survivors’ pain as permission for state killing – and start choosing a public safety approach that supports healing and prevents harm,” the sisters wrote in the Guardian on Tuesday.
Polly’s father, Marc, has opposed the commutations and is part of the petition filed on Monday.
One former California prisons director who oversaw four executions came out in support of Newsom’s announcement earlier this month, noting the risks of executing innocent people, with at least eight people on California’s death row exonerated over the last four decades.