Retired Ireland and Leinster hooker Bernard Jackman has revisited his final season as a player, which featured 24 concussions and a retirement row with Michael Cheika.
The front-rower had become adept at keeping his concussions private, developing coping mechanisms that would see him rock up to training on Monday morning despite getting sparked in the head on the Saturday.
It was while writing an in-season autobiography on that 2009/10 campaign when Jackman realised how much a part concussion was actually having in his life, and he went to speak to Cheika after Leinster had qualified from their Heineken Cup pool to tell him that he was retiring at the end of the season.
At that time, Cheika had no issue with Jackman’s plan to stop playing after Leinster’s campaign in Europe ended. However, two days after the province was beaten by Toulouse in the semi-finals in May 2010, Jackman’s request to no longer give everything to the squad with a Celtic League title still to play for resulted in the Australian banishing the Irishman from the club’s premises in Dublin.
“I kept ignoring it and dealing with it…”
More of that incident later, but let’s first report on Jackman’s relief that 15 years after he hung up his boots, there are no ill effects from the multiple concussions he suffered. Appearing on The Business End with fellow retired front-rowers, the ex-London Irish duo of Liam Mooney and Justin Fitzpatrick, he recalled how rugby was very naïve about concussion at the time.
“You never had anyone out back then for concussion; it was just part and parcel,” said Jackman. “You could get sparked on a Saturday and rock up Monday and go again unless you admitted to it. I didn’t see it as a reason to stop.
“The problem with concussion for me was when I got my first or second concussion, it was a big deal, frightened me a little bit, but then I became very used to it.
“I knew that if I got a concussion mid-game, I could stay on the ground and say I needed to change a contact lens or I always had a cut on my cauliflower ear that I could open up and have a bit of blood, go into a blood bin for a couple of minutes.
“I knew if I could buy time, I would be able to get my bearings enough that I could play on… I didn’t want to miss a match, didn’t want to be taken off early because of concussion and lose the confidence of the coach, so I kept ignoring it and dealing with it.
“I am so lucky that I haven’t had the long-term effects that so many of my former teammates or opponents have had. I had a brain scan a year ago as part of a study through Rugby Players Ireland, and thankfully everything is as it should be for a man of my age [49] regardless of the concussion that I had.”
Looking back on his concussion habit in his final season, he explained: “I think I had 24 concussions that year. These aren’t getting knocked out and stretchered off, but they were concussions.
“It could be just in a tackle drill against a bag would actually leave me dizzy and get a migraine straight away and maybe stumble for a second. It was only when I read back the transcript that I realised how significant it was.
“I left it in because I wanted the book to be honest. And when I went promoting the book that is what everyone zoomed in on. I was really shocked that people didn’t realise the masculinity and the bravado meant we didn’t take it seriously at the time as players.
“Some of my former teammates weren’t happy with me for sharing it, but thankfully now you see a game where concussion is very much on the mind of players, coaches, mentors, parents, supporters, medics. We have moved on a long way, and we needed to.
“What I wanted to do was highlight that at the end of my career we were still a little bit loose in that (concussion) aspect, and I wanted to accept my own part in that. I think I am reasonably intelligent, but what I did wasn’t intelligent; it wasn’t bright or smart, but I was so focused.
“I knew my career was heading towards the end, and I wanted to milk every last moment of that. I didn’t want to walk away from the game because of an injury I would have always felt I could have kept playing (with) if that makes sense, whereas if I blew out my knee, it’s taken away from me.
“So, by not declaring those concussions to the medics and by keeping it secret, I felt I was doing the right thing selfishly to prolong my career. That’s honestly where I am. I’m not proud of it, but I also think if I didn’t have that mindset I mightn’t have lasted as long as I did either. I have just been very lucky that up to now there has been no long-term damage.”
Switching to his story about Cheika forcibly telling him, “I’ll decide when you retire”, Jackman admitted he now understands why the coach reacted the way he did, even though he was angered by the Australian at the time.
They have worked on pitch-side media broadcasts since then and were both were at the 10-year reunion in 2019 to celebrate Leinster’s first European Cup win in 2009, so no bad blood has lingered. But their bust-up was difficult when it happened, and Jackman putting it in his autobiography only exacerbated the aggravation.
“I wouldn’t have been overly popular for putting that in the book, but that’s what happened. I am completely at peace now. At the time, I was really angry,” said Jackman, explaining that he would keep training in the gym and do the non-contact part of the rugby session but would only play in the Celtic League play-offs if someone got sick or was injured.
“He said, ‘No, that’s not how it works here. I decide.’ I was effectively kicked out of the building for about 24 hours. Some of the senior players went to speak to him and I was allowed to come back in, but it ruined my last few weeks.
“That’s on me. I could have just said nothing and finished the season. At the time, I was angry with him, and that’s why it comes out on the book. But when I think back about it and reflect, that attitude from him is what helped Leinster change.
“We needed someone who only went north and was ruthless and relentless because we weren’t that way as a squad when he took over (in 2005)… Because of what Michael Cheika did and how he led, I had one of the greatest days of my life, which was being part of the first Leinster team to win the European Cup.
Wallabies legend’s ‘very clear’ verdict on ref ‘inconsistencies’ as he issues a plea to World Rugby
“In hindsight, I totally forgive him because he was doing everything in his power that morning to try and make sure in three weeks, Leinster had another trophy. Every decision he made, when I look back on it, was consistent with that. So why would I expect him to be inconsistent?
“At the time, I was angry. With time, I realised I much prefer someone like him who didn’t one day say time keeping was important and the next day couldn’t give a s*** about it. Literally what he wanted was people who were on the bus, committed to the very end and would go deep for Leinster…
“At the time, I would say I was probably right to be angry and disappointed, but now I can see why he felt that I was the one who was being selfish.”
The passage of time has mended relations. “He understands where I was coming from, and I understand where he was coming from, and we have moved on. To be able to do that is important as well, to argue your side of the coin. You mightn’t be able to agree, but you go, we have both had a good discussion here… we’ll just get on with it.”
READ MORE: Rugby players threaten to strike for next match after skipping training on Tuesday