The Greatest MMA Fight That Never Happened: Fedor Emelianenko vs. Brock Lesnar, 2009–2010
It remains the white whale of mixed martial arts, the superfight that haunted message boards, press conferences, and Dana White’s dreams for the better part of two years: Fedor Emelianenko, the stoic Russian emperor who ruled PRIDE with an iron sambo grip, against Brock Lesnar, the WWE-converted freight train who had just bulldozed his way to the UFC heavyweight title.
In the summer of 2009, the stars seemed aligned in a way they almost never are in this sport.
Fedor, 32 years old and riding a 27-fight unbeaten streak, had just finished his Affliction trilogy obligation with a 75-second demolition of Andrei Arlovski and a first-round TKO of Tim Sylvia the year prior. His management (M-1 Global) was openly shopping for the biggest possible fight, and the UFC’s heavyweight division had a new king: Lesnar, who had survived Frank Mir’s kneebar at UFC 100 that July to unify the belts in front of 1.6 million pay-per-view buyers.
Dana White wanted it badly. So badly that he flew to Russia, sat across a table from Vadim Finkelstein, and reportedly offered Fedor a six-fight, $30 million deal—the richest contract in MMA history at the time. White later claimed the only thing standing in the way was M-1’s demand for co-promotion rights, something the UFC would never grant.
Fedor’s side told a different story: they wanted the same revenue percentage on PPV that Lesnar was getting (rumored to be 10 points on the buy rate), plus the right to compete in combat sambo tournaments during the contract. The UFC said no. Negotiations collapsed. Fedor signed with Strikeforce instead.
What we got instead was the cruelest consolation prize imaginable.
Fedor fought Brett Rogers on CBS (and won), then got caught in a Werdum triangle that ended the myth of his invincibility. Lesnar defended his title once more against Shane Carwin, then diverticulitis nearly killed him, and by the time he returned, Alistair Overeem was waiting with a liver kick that sent him into retirement.
The window slammed shut forever.
Why it would have been the greatest
Style clash from hell: Lesnar’s Division I wrestling pedigree and 285 pounds of explosive muscle against Fedor’s otherworldly reaction time, cast-iron chin, and vicious ground-and-pound from top position. It was Cain Velasquez vs. Junior dos Santos on steroids, but with the added layer of one man being the most feared heavyweight on the planet and the other being the scariest athlete ever to cross over from pro wrestling.
Cultural collision: The quiet, almost monastic Russian icon—the last emperor of PRIDE—against the brash, roaring American monster who once told a Canadian crowd, “I’m gonna drink a Coors Light, that’s a Coors Light, because Bud Light won’t pay me nothing.”
It was East vs. West, old guard vs. new money, humility vs. spectacle.
Historical stakes: A win for Fedor would have cemented him as the undisputed greatest heavyweight ever, full stop. A win for Lesnar would have been the single biggest mainstream crossover moment in MMA history—bigger than UFC 100 itself.
Instead, we debate hypotheticals fifteen years later.
Dana White still brings it up when he’s angry, usually after a couple of drinks. Fedor, now 49 and long retired, simply shrugs in interviews: “It didn’t happen. Life goes on.”
But every hardcore fan over 30 knows the truth: on some cold night in 2009 or 2010, in a sold-out arena with five million people ordering the pay-per-view, we were robbed of the one fight that could have transcended the sport.
And we’ll never stop wondering what would have happened when the Last Emperor finally met the Beast Incarnate.
MyMMANews.com – We cover everything from MMA, BJJ, Bare Knuckle, Wrestling, Boxing, Kickboxing, and Judo
News, Opinions, Videos, Radio Shows, Photos and more.
Continue Reading