The case was described as the first class action against Victoria Police specifically concerning the use of OC spray in a public protests, and advocates expect the ruling to set a major precedent for public order policing tactics in the state.
Harris said the case raised “very difficult questions” given the “dynamic and occasionally chaotic crowd environment” faced by police and found that police actions limited Brown’s rights to freedom of movement and peaceful assembly.
Loading
However, she warned the case wouldn’t necessarily set a new standard.
“The evidence will not set a precedent for every other case,” she said. “It is important to appreciate that these conclusions are necessarily limited in their effect to the use of OC aerosols as relevant to the plaintiff’s circumstances in the circumstances of this particular proceeding.”
Police issued a statement after the judgment saying: “The public should have confidence our members are highly trained and there are strict rules surrounding the use of OC spray.
“It provides police with a vital tool to safely resolve situations of violence or serious physical confrontation. As this trial forms part of a class action with further matters before the court it would be inappropriate to comment further.”
Kelly said the ruling was a “vindication” for those affected and noted that when OC spray was first introduced in 1995, the then police minister promised Parliament it would not be provided for public demonstrations.
“Victoria Police have usurped that promise in the years since, and now use it on sickeningly regular times against entire crowds of people who are often doing nothing more than simply standing holding their ground,” Kelly said.
The trial focused heavily on whether the actions of police officers, primarily from the Public Order Response Team (PORT), were an “unreasonable, unlawful and disproportionate use of force” in breach of the Crimes Act and the Victorian Charter of Human Rights.
The State of Victoria admitted that two officers deployed OC foam against the plaintiff, but defended the claim on the basis of lawful justification, primarily self-defence or to assist in a lawful arrest.
The police union had previously defended the actions of its officers as justified, proportionate and lawful. It has been approached for comment.
A spokesman for Police Minister Anthony Carbines said, “all Victorians should expect the highest standards of integrity from our police officers”.
“Operational decisions such as the deployment of OC spray are made by Victoria Police, independent of government.”
Legal costs will be determined in February 2026.