Loading

Carrasco, who also lives on Punt Road, believes if residents had a choice between having their property acquired or high-density homes built next door, most would choose the latter.

“The alternative is to destroy dozens of heritage and historical homes for what will become just a wider car park,” he said.

Drop Punt estimates some 100,000 square metres of floorspace could open up if six-storey apartment blocks are built on affected land.

“If you want to use the land that you’ve already got for residential development, that seems like a good compromise.”

The Punt Road acquisition overlay  starts at from Alexandra Avenue near the Yarra River and stretches some 2.6 kilometres to Union Street in Windsor.

The Punt Road acquisition overlay starts at from Alexandra Avenue near the Yarra River and stretches some 2.6 kilometres to Union Street in Windsor.Credit: Joe Armao

Though there is currently no plan to widen Punt Road or acquire properties there, it emerged as a flashpoint issue after the state government set a target of building 50,000 new dwellings in Stonnington by 2051. But the council’s plan, which advocates for a different development strategy, shows some 67,000 new dwellings could be accommodated in the area.

During a debate earlier this month, Stonnington Council voted to advocate for the overlay to be dropped by the state government. In part, the motion stated developing the 9880m² of property along the Punt Road corridor owned by VicRoads could help meet imposed housing targets.

South Yarra Ward councillor Kate Healy said state-owned assets in Stonnington were worth some $100 million, and hundreds of new homes could be built next to train stations and trams, and close to jobs.

Councillor Tom Humphries, who represents Toorak Ward, said the government had ignored the council’s plan and claimed scrapping the overlay would allow them to “have their ugly skyscrapers” and meet its housing targets.

Loading

RMIT urban policy lecturer Liam Davies said it was unusual to have an overlay in place for so long without development.

“It’s a bit of a traffic sewer, and it’s kind of not working for anyone at the moment. But is widening it going to make it better? I don’t know,” he said.

Davies said properties on the eastern side of Punt Road have effectively been held in stasis and “rightly or wrongly”, governments want to minimise the cost of public acquisition.

Stonnington Mayor Melina Sehr said the government was asking Stonnington to accommodate significant growth while a large amount of state-owned land was “effectively frozen” with no funded plan for its future.

A Victorian government spokesperson said Stonnington’s housing target was developed with a full understanding of existing planning settings, including the acquisition overlay.

“We need to both plan for the homes and the infrastructure Victorians will need for the future,” they said.

Given the land’s proximity to the CBD, as well as access to public transport and jobs, the value of properties could be significantly affected if the planning rule was dropped.

A ministerial advisory committee examined the overlay in 2016 and in 2017, with then-planning minister Richard Wynne deciding to keep it, citing Punt Road’s importance for traffic and transport.

Both the Coalition and Greens both favour dropping the overlay.

The Arcadia Pub owner Ken Nicholls says this is why he never tried to renovate or expand outside the pub’s 1890s building, which is in the middle of the acquisition zone because he assumed he’d be knocked back.

Having been in the area for 26 years, Nicholls says he doubts the government will widen Punt Road, but the overlay has meant many properties in the area have fallen into disrepair because owners are reluctant to spend money due to the uncertainty.

“People don’t want to see massive towers here, but I think three or four levels, which seems to be what the regulation allows in this proximity, would provide a lot of accommodation for people and at least make the area look presentable.”

Teluk says he hopes he never has to leave his apartment. The failure of successive governments to deal with a planning overlay rolled out before he was born, though, has left the retiree frustrated.

“It’s almost like a catch-22 situation. ‘If we get rid of it, we won’t have it’,” Teluk said of the government’s logic.

“Yes, but what are you doing with it? That’s my question.”

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.