In the frenetic first few hours after the Bondi shooting, Sussan Ley was quick to issue a statement on the worst terror attack on Australian soil.
As the national security committee of cabinet met in Canberra and intelligence agencies and police scrambled to respond to the carnage on 14 December, Ley offered the Coalition’s “full and unconditional support” for the government’s response.
An intense four weeks of summer politics followed, with Ley appearing almost daily to smash Labor over its failure to call a royal commission and demand parliament be recalled to pass legislation to fight antisemitism. A quickly cobbled together list of Ley’s statements pledging bipartisanship and urging immediate new laws ran to three pages.
But as MPs prepare to come back to Canberra for a special sitting next week, for condolence motions and to consider Labor’s new hate speech and anti-vilification laws, Ley looks badly exposed. Her authority within the Coalition and her credibility with voters are under serious pressure.
The opposition leader was uncharacteristically quiet on Wednesday as Liberal and Nationals MPs considered the government’s draft bill, announced by the prime minister, Anthony Albanese, 48 hours earlier and combining tough new legal protections with provisions to establish a national guns buyback scheme.
What happened while she was at home in her electorate was instructive. Ahead of a meeting by the Coalition leadership group on Wednesday night, backbencher Andrew Hastie used a social media post to announce his opposition to the plan.
Looking comfortable and assured at home in Western Australia, the putative Liberal leadership rival said the bill represented “an attack on our basic democratic freedoms”, including freedom of conscience, freedom of speech and freedom of religion. He slammed Albanese for trying to rush it through parliament next week and even suggested the 12-month royal commission should be allowed to complete its work on antisemitism before new laws were drafted. Hastie, who appeared as the opposition leader in everything but name, demonstrated how difficult Ley’s internal politics remain.
Having gone out so hard with demands on Labor, in part to shore up her leadership with conservative Liberals on a touchstone issue, she could not support the very legislation she had said dozens of times was so urgently required.
The decision to oppose Labor’s plan – which Ley described as “pretty unsalvageable” a day later – was subsequently supported by a factional cross-section of Liberals, including moderates Anne Ruston and Paul Scarr and Ley’s other likely rival, Angus Taylor.
Explaining its shortcomings, the opposition leader said the legislation failed the two key tests of stopping antisemitism and stopping Islamic extremism.
Ley’s position, and the subsequent announcement from the Greens that they would not support the plan in its current form either, badly angered Albanese and Labor. Denying he had tried to wedge Ley by combining hate speech and guns in the same bill, the prime minister said he was stunned by the opposition’s intransigence. He accused Ley of hypocrisy and insisted responding to Bondi should be a moment of national unity.
The foreign minister, Penny Wong, dialled things up to 11 again on Friday, alleging it was Ley’s leadership that was “unsalvageable”, while the treasurer, Jim Chalmers, accused the Coalition of having lost the plot, suggesting Ley was cooked.
But the politics of the draft legislation must not be allowed to hide the fact that the bill would be bad law.
Like most legislation rushed through parliament predominantly for reasons of public perception, it is too big and too significant to be properly scrutinised in just a few days. The committee charged with reviewing the draft laws held a two-day inquiry this week, and will be working through the weekend to prepare a hurried report. The deputy chair, Liberal National MP Phil Thompson, said thousands of submissions were still unread as of Friday afternoon.
Among submissions that have been considered by the committee, the New South Wales Council for Civil Liberties warned the bill would impose significant limits on free speech, and that selective or biased enforcement by government and police was a recipe for failure. Anne Twomey, the leading constitutional expert, likened provisions designed to ban hate groups to the Menzies government’s failed efforts to dissolve and ban the Australian Communist party in the 1950s. Twomey warned such laws might be unwise and unnecessary, and bring strong potential for abuse further down the line.
The Coalition also wants individual phrases considered antisemitic, including “globalise the intifada” and “from the river to the sea”, to be explicitly outlawed in the bill. The NSW premier, Chris Minns, is considering such moves, but legal experts including Equality Australia’s Heather Corkhill and University of NSW law professor Luke McNamara say that approach is risky and the wider context of comments and the individuals making them should be considered.
With the Coalition dealing themselves out, the Greens represent the only viable pathway for the legislation in the Senate. Leader Larissa Waters said on Friday that negotiations would continue but the risk that the legislation could criminalise legitimate political expression was too great based on the current draft. “That is a dangerous path,” she said, asking why legal protections would be extended to one vulnerable group in the community but not others. Labor says it is open to passing new laws for other groups in the future, including LGBTQ+ Australians and people with a disability.
Albanese has been in close contact with the Executive Council of Australian Jewry co-chief executive Peter Wertheim since the Bondi attack. The group opposes proposed defences to provisions on incitement or promotion of hatred on the grounds of race, colour, or national or ethnic origin, where the speech or writings directly quote from religious texts. But Wertheim has urged the Coalition to work with the government to improve the bill, rather than reject it completely.
On Friday, religious leaders, including Albanese’s close confidant, Sydney’s Catholic Archbishop Anthony Fisher, said the bill would have adverse implications for religious freedom and freedom of expression, urging it be delayed and redrafted.
Labor’s bill looks friendless as MPs prepare to head to Canberra.
Both Ley and Albanese should learn from the rush to action in the wake of the Bondi attack, potentially saving themselves from future embarrassment and sparing the parliament from shoddy lawmaking.