The images of a cabal of rightwing Liberal men gathering for clandestine talks to overthrow the party’s first female leader – hours before a memorial service for a late former colleague, no less – confirmed two things.

First, the internal plot to oust Sussan Ley has descended into a political melodrama.

And second, that while Ley might escape a leadership spill when federal parliament returns next week – a challenge is coming.

First, to the soap opera.

More than a week has elapsed since the implosion of the Coalition sparked immediate speculation that Ley would be rolled as soon as Angus Taylor and Andrew Hastie decided which of them would run against her.

Sign up: AU Breaking News email

Their right-faction colleagues hoped for a quick resolution, conscious that a drawn-out process to determine a candidate would only serve to buy precious time for Ley.

That hasn’t happened despite interventions from the likes of conservative elder Tony Abbott.

The more experienced Taylor – who was overseas when the shadow leadership campaign started in earnest – won’t step aside because he believes his seniority gives him claim to the faction’s backing.

But Hastie’s camp is digging in, adamant the former soldier has the numbers.

The private stalemate has continued without either publicly declaring their intentions, leading to days of tortured “will they, won’t they” speculation.

On Monday night, Hastie wrote an Australia Day email to supporters that some viewed as the entree to a formal announcement.

“Politics as usual just isn’t going to cut it,” he wrote. “What we’re doing now just isn’t working. Australians are asking for something new.”

Was it Hastie putting himself forward as a future leader? No. Nor was an exclusive in The Australian that reported Hastie’s wife had given her blessing to her husband’s yet-to-be-announced leadership tilt.

Which brings us to Thursday and the secret of meeting of Liberal power brokers at a private residence in Melbourne.

The Australian captured footage of Hastie and fellow rightwingers Jonno Duniam and Matt O’Sullivan arriving at the talks with Taylor, which were reportedly brokered by the former Liberal MP Michael Sukkar and also attended by James Paterson.

Images from the meeting were broadcast widely across the media on Thursday morning, overshadowing the reason the men were in Melbourne: to attend a memorial for their former colleague Katie Allen, who died aged 59 after a battle with cancer.

Liberal MPs – male and female – were privately aghast that colleagues would use such a sombre occasion to discuss the mechanics of a leadership coup.

The prime minister, Anthony Albanese, said it was “astonishing” such talks took place, noting that just last week David Littleproud confirmed the end of the Coalition on the national day of mourning for the victims of the Bondi massacre.

The talks ended without a resolution, meaning a leadership spill when parliament returns on Tuesday appears increasingly unlikely.

But the meeting all but confirmed a challenge would come.

Duniam, Paterson and Taylor don’t just sit in shadow cabinet but are members of Ley’s Liberal leadership team, a supposedly loyal circle of senior confidantes.

Their presence at talks about essentially ending her leadership confirms the push to oust Ley is not just the work of a few rogue backbenchers – as some of Ley’s allies have privately sought to characterise in recent days.

In an interview on ABC’s RN Breakfast on Thursday morning, Paterson was asked if Ley retained his support.

A skilled political communicator who rarely puts a word out of place, Paterson replied: “Yes, she does. I wouldn’t be speaking to you this morning as the shadow minister for finance if she didn’t. The first responsibility if you don’t support any leader is to tell them, and the second responsibility is to resign, and I haven’t done either, so you can assume I continue to support Sussan.”

Hardly a ringing endorsement.

Duniam, in a podcast interview broadcast on Thursday, also declined to directly endorse Ley as he called for an urgent resolution to the “unhelpful” speculation surrounding her future.

If this unedifying political melodrama continues as it has, that resolution won’t be reached quickly.

But if and when it does, it appears certain to be the end of Ley’s leadership.

Dan Jervis-Bardy is Guardian Australia’s chief political correspondent