Pauline Hanson was caught off guard when the then Queensland premier Annastacia Palaszczuk announced a snap election back in October 2017.

Riding high in the opinion polls, the One Nation leader was travelling overseas while Palaszczuk got the jump on her rivals by announcing the poll months ahead of expectations.

As one veteran of Queensland campaigns remembers it, the major parties feared voters were sleepwalking into handing One Nation the balance of power in the state parliament. The hype would have seen Hanson locked in as a powerbroker in Queensland politics, even while serving in the Senate in Canberra.

Then Pauline flew home.

Things quickly went to custard for One Nation, as many of the party’s candidates were revealed to have disqualifying features and the leader struggled under the scrutiny of the campaign glare. Not all publicity is good publicity after all.

Despite polling north of 20% and driving a “battler bus” around the state, One Nation won just one seat. While securing 13% of the vote, it emerged with fewer MPs than Bob Katter’s party, and went on to lose half that vote the next time around.

This clash of expectations and reality remains instructive for politics today.

As the party’s support in national polls climbs, Hanson’s ability to win big at the next election is far from assured. Sober analysis of the party’s prospects are warranted, even when the firebrand senator’s influence appears to be soaring.

Sign up: AU Breaking News email

Once described by strategist Lynton Crosby as “the accidental tourist of Australian politics”, Hanson has instead become one of its great survivors. Approaching 30 years in public life, her mix of grievance politics and stunts means she is never far from the headlines.

First elected in 1996, she returned 20 years later with a Senate seat, boosted by paid breakfast TV slots and a turn on Dancing with the Stars. One Nation doubled its representation at last year’s poll and secured the high-profile defection of the former Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce in December.

As the political mainstream fragments, and traditional Coalition voters appear fed up with the Liberal and National parties, One Nation is building remarkable support.

This week’s Guardian-Essential poll put the party’s primary vote at 22%, triple what it achieved at the 2025 election and just three points below the Coalition. In Newspoll, One Nation has 22% of the primary vote, ahead of the Coalition for the first time. Hanson is leading the Coalition by five points in YouGov’s latest poll and three points in numbers released by DemosAU.

In rural seats, One Nation led the Coalition by 35–21 on primary votes in YouGov, leaving them well placed to take seats from the Liberals and Nationals.

Like Nigel Farage’s Reform in Britain, more defections from the former Coalition parties are expected in coming weeks. Hanson has smart strategists around her, including her chief-of-staff, James Ashby, and cuts through on social media with politically incorrect satire and clips from Canberra. She has standing appointments on Sky News and commercial radio, resonating with people who hate politicians and feel as if they are not getting a fair go from the system.

With the support of Joyce’s patron, the mining magnate Gina Rinehart, and a growing list of business leaders, One Nation looks to be much better funded going into the next federal election, due in early 2028.

Ashby has hyped an announcement to “shock the nation” next week, including more big names joining the party’s ranks. An email to supporters on Friday said the party expected to pass Labor in opinion polls soon, promoted Hanson’s new film, A Super Progressive Movie, and bemoaned the fact an accompanying song by rightwing pop star Holly Valance had been temporarily removed from iTunes.

It isn’t exactly mainstream gear, and reveals the sometimes warped online world One Nation inhabits.

Like in Queensland in 2017 and elections dating back to her first major outing with voters nationally in 1998, Hanson and One Nation can struggle to scale up their operations effectively enough to win big. Campaigns are expensive and complex, and a minor party based primarily in Queensland and more experienced in the Senate will struggle to properly vet candidates and organise volunteer infrastructure to outpace the Liberals and Labor.

Hanson also has a glass jaw to even mild criticism or media scrutiny.

The election analyst Antony Green wrote this week One Nation’s high national vote means it is likely attracting numbers north of 35% in some rural and provincial seats. He said that would be enough to win some seats, provided they can maintain the polling position. Green has nominated seats, including Hunter in New South Wales, as possible targets. There, the farmer and coalminer Stuart Bonds took the party to second place at the last election.

Pauline Hanson speaks to the media in Canberra as Barnaby Joyce and Malcolm Roberts look on. Photograph: Hilary Wardhaugh/Getty Images

To win, One Nation will need to attract good preference flows, a hard thing to guarantee, given most voters don’t usually follow how-to-vote instructions line by line.

Asked on Thursday why he was resisting appeals to move to One Nation, the Nationals MP and leadership challenger Colin Boyce belled the cat on ABC radio. He said it was a lot easier for Hanson and her colleagues to win with Senate quotas of about 14%, rather than navigating preferential voting to win in lower house seats.

Hanson will try to replicate one of her most successful campaigns: the 1998 Queensland state election when One Nation had 11 MPs elected. That result was off the back of her xenophobic maiden speech in federal parliament, when she claimed Australia was “in danger of being swamped by Asians”.

Growing economic anxiety and another heated political debate about immigration in Australia, driven this time by the Liberals and Nationals, will play to Hanson’s strength and instincts. After the pandemic, the Scanlon Foundation’s annual assessment of social cohesion is among polls showing a marked rise in the proportion of Australians who think that immigration is too high. It was 24% in 2022, but had jumped to 49% two years later, and crept up to 51% last year.

Claiming her recent surge in popularity means she is now a major party leader, Hanson said last month the challenge was continuing to “earn” the growing support and trust of mainstream voters.

History suggests she’ll struggle.

Tom McIlroy is Guardian Australia’s political editor