For decades, Labor governments have been waiting for a “catalysing political trigger” to convince the opposition that there was a real and urgent need for a comprehensive, codified Australian charter of rights as exists in all other comparable nations.
It is a shame that the tragic event at Bondi last December has not yet become that political trigger. The shock was palpable, public sentiment was high, human rights had demonstrably been trashed, lives were lost and irrevocably changed, the social fabric frayed.
Clearly something needed to be done to reinforce the rights and safety not just of the Jewish community, but all Australians.
The immediate response to criminalise and punish was understandable – outlaw hate speech, ban hate groups, prohibit demonstrations and phrases, make the hatred of other human beings and their views go away by force of law and ministerial decree.
This punitive response lies deep in the Australian psyche. No doubt it provides a moment of comfort and reassurance that something can be done – visas revoked, bad actors detained and outlawed, arrests made, charges laid, guns bought back.
But as UNSW law professor Luke McNamara wrote, “We need to moderate our expectations on how much ever-expanding forms of criminalisation can deliver the community safety and social cohesion to which we aspire. We must also recognise both the harms that can be done by hastily widening the net cast by the criminal law, and that there are often better ways of encouraging public discourse that is both robust and respectful.”
Despite the national day of mourning, “robust and respectful” are probably not the words that come to mind when reflecting on the discourse of the past few weeks.
Instead we have had low-grade political posturing. Legislative overreach in two parliaments and retreat into the safe ground of Australian politics: the theatre of leadership speculation.
Give us a break. I don’t really care who leads the Liberal or National party; they have a snowball’s chance in a heatwave of forming government anytime soon. But I do care if we keep putting Band-Aids on top of foundational flaws.
It is slightly paradoxical that these parties that for decades were at the forefront of opposing a bill of rights, which would have included freedom of speech as one of its key principles, were the strongest opponents of the proposal to criminalise hate speech.
That human rights were again reduced to a debating point in a political game pointed to the need to better define the rights and responsibilities of all citizens and residents. This would be an important step in building the positive social capital that shapes the essence of what it means to be Australian.
It only takes a few minutes of watching what is happening on the streets in America to know that a codified bill of rights does not prevent overreach by the state. But public knowledge of these enforceable rights helps embolden the opponents of an out-of-control state.
Despite longstanding Liberal and National party opposition to legislating for rights, as documented in the comprehensive report published late last year by the Whitlam Institute and the Human Rights Law Centre (HRLC), the Australian public hasn’t needed much convincing.
More than 50 years of polls, surveys, reports, inquiries, town halls and focus groups have shown that somewhere between 70% and 87% of the population want a codified charter of rights. To know what their rights are and be reassured that they are used to frame policy and legislation. To make the ideal of “a fair go” real. Where everyone has the rights to freedom of thought, conscience, religion, expression, privacy and association, to hold opinions, vote, move, have legal protections and minimum living standards – including for health, education, work, culture and the environment.
Instead, if you read the op-eds, debates in parliament or the petitions presented by MPs over decades, you would think that most Australians consider an articulation of rights, such as exists in every comparable country, as an “evil” plot to strip citizens and states of their rights.
More than 130 groups have now signed up to the campaign being led by the HRLC, which considers that more than 80 years after the idea was first put to the Australian people in the 1944 referendum, the time is right to finally catch up with the rest of the world.
In the debates leading up to federation 125 years ago, there were some who advocated including a bill of rights, which was already a feature of other constitutions. But the fear that this would limit the power of the colonies that were about to become states presented an insurmountable obstacle. And so it has proved to be ever since.
If constitutional change is too hard, there is at least a need for national legislation to buttress the limited rights defined in the constitution and replace the scattered and piecemeal legislation that otherwise frames. To paraphrase Mark Carney, the “pleasant fiction” that we don’t need it has been blown apart by events, royal commissions and increasing concern about social cohesion.
All that has been lacking has been the political will to act.
Sadly, it is a repeated pattern.
“They are nowhere near recognising this,” one government insider told me during the week. “It’s just too hard.”
But changing the terms of the political debate to a positive assertion of rights could do more to build social capital and enhance social cohesion than punitive laws.
Julianne Schultz is the author of The Idea of Australia