NBA players pick the league’s most overrated athletes

Every year, anonymous player polls offer one of the most fascinating glimpses into how NBA athletes truly view one another beyond highlight reels, social media praise, and television debates. The Athletic’s 2026 Anonymous NBA Player Poll once again sparked league-wide conversation after players voted on who they believe is the NBA’s “most overrated” player — a category that is often less about talent and more about expectations, reputation, media attention, and playoff perception. While the label can sound harsh, it also reflects the immense spotlight these stars operate under every night.

The results featured several high-profile names, including rising stars, established All-Stars, and proven veterans with polarizing reputations. Some players landed on the list because of contract value versus production, while others continue to battle criticism tied to postseason shortcomings or inconsistent performances despite gaudy statistics. In many cases, being called “overrated” can actually be a byproduct of success, since players who receive the most attention naturally face the most scrutiny from peers around the league.

What makes this poll especially compelling is that the opinions come directly from NBA players themselves — competitors who prepare against these stars night after night and understand the league at its highest level. Whether fans agree or disagree with the results, the poll reveals how perception can differ dramatically between public narratives and locker-room opinions. From emerging franchise cornerstones to perennial All-Stars, these players remain among the NBA’s most discussed and debated figures heading into the 2026 season.

Alperen Şengün — 12.3%

Alperen Şengün topping this poll surprised many fans given his undeniable offensive talent and rapidly growing influence in Houston’s resurgence. The Turkish big man has developed into one of the league’s most skilled passing centers, often drawing comparisons to Nikola Jokić because of his creativity and feel for the game. However, some players around the league may believe the hype surrounding his stardom has accelerated faster than his overall impact, particularly on the defensive end where he still faces criticism. Even so, being labeled overrated does not erase the fact that Şengün has become one of the NBA’s most entertaining young stars and remains a centerpiece of the Rockets’ future.

Rudy Gobert — 8.6%

Rudy Gobert appearing on this list is hardly new territory, as the four-time Defensive Player of the Year has long been one of the league’s most polarizing stars. Supporters point to his elite rim protection, rebounding, and defensive consistency, while critics continue to question his offensive limitations and playoff adaptability against smaller lineups. Despite the criticism, Gobert’s impact on winning has historically been significant, with teams consistently improving defensively when he anchors the paint. His inclusion in the poll likely reflects the ongoing debate over how valuable a defense-first center can truly be in today’s perimeter-oriented NBA.

Trae Young — 8.6%

Trae Young’s placement on the list reflects the divided opinions that have followed him throughout his NBA career. Offensively, few guards can match his combination of deep shooting range, elite passing vision, and ability to control tempo with the ball in his hands. Still, critics often focus on his defensive shortcomings, high-usage style, and questions about whether his style consistently translates to deep playoff success. Even with those concerns, Young remains one of the league’s premier offensive engines and one of the most dangerous playmakers in basketball when fully healthy.

Karl-Anthony Towns — 7.4%

Karl-Anthony Towns has always possessed superstar-level talent, but the perception surrounding him has fluctuated throughout his career. His offensive versatility remains rare for a seven-footer, as he can stretch the floor, score in the post, and create mismatches against virtually any defender. However, inconsistent postseason success and questions about defensive intensity have often fueled criticism despite his impressive statistics. Towns’ appearance in the poll likely stems from the gap some players perceive between his immense talent and his ability to consistently dominate at the highest level.

Paolo Banchero — 4.9%

Paolo Banchero’s inclusion may say more about the massive expectations surrounding him than his actual performance. The Orlando Magic forward has quickly emerged as one of the NBA’s brightest young stars thanks to his physicality, scoring versatility, and leadership at a remarkably young age. Some players may feel the media has elevated him into superstardom before he has fully proven himself over multiple playoff runs or elite seasons. Nevertheless, Banchero continues to trend upward and still looks capable of becoming one of the defining forwards of his generation.

Ja Morant — 4.9%

Ja Morant remains one of the NBA’s most electrifying players whenever he is on the court, but his career has also been clouded by inconsistency, injuries, and off-court controversies in recent years. His explosive athleticism and fearless attacking style make him a nightly highlight machine, yet some around the league may question whether his overall impact consistently matches the superstar label he carries. Memphis has struggled to regain stability amid Morant’s absences, which has only intensified scrutiny surrounding him. Still, when healthy and focused, Morant possesses game-changing talent that very few guards in the league can replicate.

Conclusion

The Athletic’s 2026 Anonymous NBA Player Poll once again proved how subjective player perception can be across the league. While the “most overrated” label generates headlines and debate, every player mentioned remains an impactful and highly respected talent capable of changing games at the highest level. Ultimately, the poll highlights the pressure that comes with stardom in today’s NBA, where reputation is constantly judged alongside production, expectations, and postseason success.

Tags: