Hordes of devoted customers are fuming as one of the biggest names in rock ’n’ roll tumbles through a PR disaster, with many now calling for a recently-instated CEO to get the sack.

Fender, the iconic guitar manufacturer founded in 1946, was the first company to mass-market electric guitars back in the 1950s. It is an institution adored by many, having cemented its place in history across thousands upon thousands of memorable bands and tunes.

Their famous Fender Telecaster is still regarded as the most robust guitar on the planet, capable of enduring decades of touring abuse and still playing and sounding like a million bucks.

The Telecaster’s younger brother, the Stratocaster, went on to even better things. So big, in fact, that the company is now in a scramble to “protect” its DNA.

Upon hitting the market in 1954, the twin-cutaway design quickly became synonymous with the electric guitar itself. Fender historian Richard Norvell estimates there are “millions, possibly tens of millions” of Strats in existence.

Jimi Hendrix, Jeff Beck, Stevie Ray Vaughan, Eric Clapton, John Frusciante, Billy Corgan. It’s hard to imagine any one of those guys without a Strat over their shoulder. Their impact on guitar sales worldwide is immeasurable, and over 70 years on, it remains omnipresent.

In short, Fenders have a well-earned reputation as the hammer in the toolboxes of working guitarists.

But today, the company finds itself in an unusual position as its new CEO steers the ship into perilous waters. The company that helped build modern guitar culture is now being accused of ripping it apart.

A recent legal victory in Germany has given Fender ammunition in a deeply controversial fight over ownership of the famous Stratocaster body shape. The ruling recognised the Stratocaster’s silhouette as a protected work of applied art, allowing Fender to pursue manufacturers whose instruments it believes too closely resemble its iconic design.

To say it’s kicked up a stink would be an understatement.

CEO addresses mounting controversy amid PR disaster

The problem for players is that the Strat has spent seven decades being modified, upgraded and reimagined by hundreds of manufacturers.

From boutique workshops employing a handful of people to major brands selling thousands of guitars every year, the broader guitar industry has long treated the Strat shape as a foundation.

There have been entire markets springing up across the globe to cater for musicians looking for bespoke Stratocaster upgrades or original custom builds that vaguely resemble the instrument at face value.

Popular guitar personalities Rhett Shull and Rick Beato have heavily criticised Fender’s approach, while thousands of players have flooded forums, YouTube comment sections and social media with accusations of corporate overreach.

Shull went as far as ending his commercial relationship with Fender after years of receiving gear to review to his millions of viewers.

“If I want to play a Fender guitar on this channel, I’ll go buy one,” he said.

‘Not suing anybody’: CEO responds

The initial wave of backlash was unavoidable for new CEO Edward ‘Bud’ Cole.

Barely six months after taking the role, Cole has found himself at the centre of a global storm, forced to address a controversy that doesn’t appear to be slowing down.

This week, he addressed the matter at a dealer event in the US where he attempted to clarify the reasoning behind the strategy.

“First and foremost, Fender is not suing anybody,” he told the event.

“What we’ve done is reach out thoughtfully and respectfully to a handful of companies whose guitars come extremely close to replicating the iconic Fender Stratocaster design.

“Let’s also be very specific. We’re talking specifically about the Stratocaster, because that’s what this is really about.

“Calling it simply the S-style or the S-shape is an attempt to diminish and whitewash the immeasurable game-changing contribution that Leo [Fender] and his team made to the entire industry that all of us have built so much of our success and careers around.”

The original cease-and-desist letters reportedly included demands that builders recall and destroy inventory, which is one reason the backlash exploded.

But the story became more complicated after Fender started publicly walking that back.

“Those comments were unfortunate. We are not asking anyone to destroy inventory,” Cole said.

For critics, Cole’s speech only threw more fuel on the fire.

Family-run manufacturer LsL Instruments said the guitar giant’s unwavering stance “threatens not only our business, but also the future of S-style guitars.”

Shull also doubled down on the issue after the video went public, posting another widely-viewed spray with the caption: “Fender, I think you should fire your CEO.”

He accused Fender’s cease and desist letters of being a “tactic to bully and intimidate” small manufacturers.

Hundreds of players agreed that Fender had spent decades allowing the Stratocaster design to become part of the common language of music before the sudden attempt to reclaim ownership.

Some have pointed to the irony that Fender itself sells dreadnought acoustic guitars — a body style originally developed by Martin more than a century ago.

Shull argues that no guitarists today associate the word “dreadnought” exclusively with Martin, and hundreds of guitar manufacturers are free to utilise the design at will.

For the musicians, who are ultimately the ones that drive the success of the instrument industry, certain designs have simply become bigger than the companies that created them.

The controversy is made even more awkward by the involvement of John Mayer. The world-famous guitarist famously left Fender for PRS in 2018 after reportedly becoming frustrated by creative limitations surrounding his signature Stratocaster line. The result was the hugely successful Silver Sky — now one of the very guitars caught in Fender’s legal crosshairs.

Players seem to believe it’s just another case of a company badly misreading the room, with many expressing sincere hope that Fender can get back to their glory days of making innovative, market-leading instruments that made it iconic.

Fender’s position remains unchanged. The company says it has “tremendous respect” for the guitar world, but must protect its “brand identity”.

“Fender has tremendous respect for the guitar community, independent builders, and the creativity that continues to shape this industry. At the same time, Fender has a responsibility to protect the iconic designs and brand identity associated with its instruments around the world,” Fender said in a statement provided to news.com.au.

“For 80 years, Fender has helped drive innovation in guitars and amplifiers, beginning with Leo Fender’s vision and continuing today through new ideas, new technologies, and original designs that shape how players create.

“We believe competition and innovation is healthy for the industry, and we encourage the creation of new and distinctive designs that push guitar innovation forward rather than relying on direct copies of Leo Fender’s pioneering work.

“Protecting these iconic designs is part of Fender’s obligation as a steward of the brand, its legacy, and the authenticity musicians associate with Fender instruments.

“We remain open to engaging constructively with partners and companies across the industry as we navigate this process. Our goal is to protect that legacy while supporting a vibrant future for guitar makers, builders, and musicians alike.”