Isaac Heeney’s fiancee has reportedly decided the Pullman Hotel incident is “too much to forgive” as speculation grows she has called off their engagement.
Steffie Waters, who Heeney proposed to in October last year, has wiped photos of the Sydney Swans star from her Instagram.
Be the first to know when news breaks. Download our new app
That includes images of their engagement in French Polynesia.
It is understood she has been struggling to come to terms with the Pullman Hotel incident in August — which saw Heeney and four Swans teammates stood down for the rest of the season for breaches of the club’s code of conduct.
Waters has spent some time in Noosa since the scandal broke, and is also reported to have gone overseas.
She has been spotted not wearing her engagement ring, however a friend told the Herald Sun it was being resized.
Heeney, who has deleted his Instagram account altogether, has reportedly been trying to reconcile with Waters for weeks.
Now, though, a close friend of Waters has told the Daily Mail the Pullman incident was simply “too much to forgive”.
It comes despite Waters recently re-sharing some old photos of her with Heeney from June.
Heeney, Chad Warner, Nick Blakey, James Jordon and Riley Bice were last month suspended for the remainder of the 2026 season for failing to meet club behavioural standards during a night out on August 17 where they were found to have stayed out late, consumed alcohol and brought women back to the club’s hotel rooms.
Four of those players are the subject of an ongoing police investigation, with Bice having been cleared of any criminal wrongdoing.
No one has been charged in relation to the incident.
Victoria Police sexual crimes investigators have interviewed four Sydney men from age 25 to 30 in relation to the incident.
Those men have been identified in media reports as Heeney, Warner, Blakey and Jordon.
Victoria Police said earlier this month investigators have identified “all parties” present inside the hotel room when the alleged sexual assault incident occurred.
Victoria Police told news.com.au last week there have been no updates in relation to the ongoing investigation.
As the saga continues to play out, Heeney has been deserted by sponsors.
The publisher of his kid’s book series has also paused its association with him.
Heeney and the rest of the “Pullman Five” returned to the club earlier this month to face their teammates and the Swans’ AFLW players.
They will not attend the club’s Best and Fairest Awards on Thursday night.
Originally published as ‘Too much to forgive’ for Isaac Heeney’s fiancee amid investigation into Swans star