Eldar Isgandarov ambles up to Irving Square Park for an interview in a sweatshirt covered in cat hair. The actor, who has a delicate face set off by thick eyebrows and shock of messy black hair, has come from his apartment nearby, where he and his roommate have recently adopted a misbehaving orange cat — Isgandarov has big plans to see if he can train him to wear a leash and a harness — and he spends a lot of his downtime in the park. On a bright early-fall afternoon, the rectangular block of Bushwick public space is relatively empty, aside from a few people walking dogs, a publicist from the film studio A24 trailing us in a leather jacket, and a host of local birds, which Isgandarov has recently been working hard to befriend. “I’ve been trying to come here with pigeon food,” he tells me. “If you can get them to recognize you enough, they’ll show up to you.”

Were it not for the publicist — and the fact that Isgandarov’s sweatshirt is emblazoned with the title Nosy Neighbors, the fake musical from one of his movies, Jesse Eisenberg’s The Debut — this would be a pretty typical park hang with a 25-year-old in Bushwick, complete with a long discussion of Red Dead Redemption 2 and Isgandarov asking, mid-interview, if I mind if he smokes a cig. But fate and talent have conspired to give Isgandarov a sudden and very memorable launch into the movies — his first two professional acting roles turned into small but scene-stealingly funny performances in two of the fall’s most talked-about films, Club Kid and the aforementioned Debut. Soon after graduating from the Savannah College of Art and Design, he booked a role in the latter film, out in December, in which Julianne Moore is a New Jersey housewife who gets too invested in her community-theater musical. Isgandarov plays the harried, coffee-laden assistant to her domineering director, played by Paul Giamatti. Isgandarov then landed the role of writer-director Jordan Firstman’s mooching roommate Nicky in Club Kid, in which he’s introduced in tiny red underwear cussing out opponents while playing a video game on Firstman’s character’s couch. (Completing an A24 trifecta, Isgandarov also appears in Molly Gordon’s upcoming movie Peaked, though there’s very little he can say about that yet.) We’re meeting a week after the end of the New York Film Festival, where both The Debut and Club Kid were warmly received. Even before the films’ debut, he’s found himself getting recognized by New Yorkers in the know. The day before we met, he was at a short-film screening in Bushwick, he tells me. He was trying to compliment his friend and her collaborators on their movie, and they suddenly got excited about the fact he was in The Debut and Club Kid. “I was like, ‘Guys, tonight is your night,’” Isgandarov tells me.

Audiences who haven’t been at film festivals will meet Isgandarov first through Club Kid, where he plays a persistent, hilarious thorn in the side of Firstman’s Peter, a hard-partying gay guy in his mid-30s who starts reevalutating his life once he discovers he has a son he never knew about. We don’t know how exactly Nicky ended up in Peter’s enviably large and rent-controlled Chinatown apartment — perhaps they hooked up once and Nicky just stuck around, or perhaps, as Isgandarov suggests, Nicky is helping Peter reach younger guys who will buy the drugs he’s started selling — but we do know that Nicky has been there for three weeks and made himself very much at home. The character provides one possible answer to the question “What if Kramer from Seinfeld were a twink who would not leave your home?” He’s entitled, sarcastic, and very little help at taking care of a child, though he does launch himself into kooky side quests. The second half of the film involves Nicky’s romance with Firstman’s fusty older downstairs neighbor, played by Colleen Camp. It’s unclear how much Nicky has fallen for her or whether he’s just doing an extended bit. “We decided that they’re probably not hooking up, but he’s definitely doing her favors,” Isgandarov says. “He’s cutting her hair and some other things,” he adds with a laugh. But it’s hard not to be charmed by Nicky’s, and by extension Isgandarov’s, gleeful commitment to the transformation. He starts the movie in that red underwear — that was Isgandarov’s first day on set, and after it, he thought the rest of the film felt easy — and ends it wearing Camp’s husband’s old Sherlock Holmes–esque tweed outfits. “To go from almost naked to full suits,” Isgandarov says, “I thought that was so funny.”

Isgandarov in Club Kid.
Photo: A24

Club Kid is full of Firstman’s friends and other members of the New York club scene who are playing versions of themselves — like Miss Benny, who plays a member of Peter’s going-out crew. But Isgandarov is a relative newcomer to that world. When Isgandarov first heard about the film, he only vaguely knew of Firstman from his supporting role in I Love LA, which Isgandarov’s roommate was watching at the time. He looked up Firstman’s infamously active social-media presence before they met. “Oh my God, his Twitter is crazy,” Isgandarov remembers thinking, but when they met in person, he found him to be a lot more approachable — for most of the meeting, Isgandarov complained to Firstman about dating, while Firstman gave him “tips and tricks” — and soon, he was offered the part in the movie. By now, Isgandarov feels much more familiar with the world of the movie (“I’m up to date on my terms,” he says), though he’s still learning a phrase or two. (In the midst of the New York Film Festival, he learned the meme concept of a “mother toilet,” which Isgandarov initially misquotes as a “mama stall.”)

Once Isgandarov was cast, Firstman shaped Nicky around him. The film involves a lot of ad-lib, but Isgandarov’s biggest laugh line is written into the script, a huffy moment where Nicky tells Peter he can’t move out because “Do you know what it’s like to be an aspiring queer philosopher in Azerbaijan?” Isgandarov is himself Azerbaijani. His father was an ambassador, and he grew up going to international schools in the Netherlands and Belgium, spending his summers back home in Azerbaijan. (Isgandarov speaks English, Russian, Azerbaijani, and some French; “I paid a little bit of attention in class in Brussels.”) When he first saw the line, he was “a little freaked out” by its political charge. He prefers not to talk about his own sexuality, but in terms of his home country: Same-sex activity is legal in Azerbaijan, a secular, Muslim-majority former Soviet republic, but it’s still heavily stigmatized. Homosexual marriages aren’t recognized, and discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity is allowed. Isgandarov’s hopeful that a younger generation has become more progressive, though the country is still entrenched in more conservative gender roles. After some thinking about the line and consulting with his twin sister, he decided it was worth the conversation it might start. (He also wore a T-shirt emblazoned with the quip to the movie’s New York premiere.) Comparing life in Baku, Azerbaijan’s capital, and around Irving Square Park, Isgandarov says he was recently scrolling around the digital project Queering the Map, in which users can add pins with their memories about LGBTQ+ experiences. “In Azerbaijan, it was the most heartfelt, incredible thing from a girl who wrote something like, ‘One day we’ll be free,’” he says. “And then I looked at the Bushwick one and it was like, ‘Just tried pegging someone for the first time.’”

Paul Giamatti and Isgandarov in The Debut.

Isgandarov’s itinerant international childhood was something he ended up bonding with Julianne Moore about on the set of The Debut. Her father was in the U.S. military and she moved around a lot too, spending part of her high-school years on a base in West Germany. “We talked a lot about Soviet experiences on set,” Isgandarov says, and they agreed that the movie’s fake show, Nosy Neighbors, a send-up of ’70s musicals about an apartment building, “is a little USSR-y, in the sense of everyone looking into each other’s lives.” Compared to his role in Club Kid, Isgandarov’s part in The Debut is smaller, though it provided him the chance to work up close with one of our great film actors — Moore is already being talked about as a potential front-runner to win another Oscar for Best Actress this year — and to learn the lingo of a whole different New York subculture, that of theater kids. He’d played Mrs. Lovett in a college production of Sweeney Todd that went disastrously wrong because glass had been accidentally shattered onstage (“There was a broom backstage, so I pulled up with the broom in character”), but he wasn’t as familiar with New York’s theater scene. “I had to do my research again,” he says. Isgandarov’s relentlessly perky character, Piotr, inspired by a childhood friend of Eisenberg’s who was Georgian, doesn’t get to sing and dance in the show himself, however, so he found himself studying the production assistants on The Debut set. They were running errands a lot like the ones Piotr is running in the movie. He was baffled and amused, for instance, by the fact that someone on set would offer to hold an umbrella for him in the rain. “I learned a lot from them for the role,” he says, “because there’s an urgency there, but you also have to be kind and sweet and respectful.”

Isgandarov would be happy doing any odd job like that as he’s killing time between acting gigs. Part of the reason he’s spent so much time in the park recently is because he’s in America on an O-1 visa, given to individuals with “extraordinary ability,” which limits him to work in his chosen field: acting. (Visa technicalities also prevented him from making it to Cannes, where Club Kid made a splashy debut over the summer.) In his downtime, he can’t take any of your typical Bushwick survival gigs, like a job as a barista. “I have so much time to think,” Isgandarov says, so he’s been writing a lot, “though it would be nice to just go work at a bookstore.” He does have at least one distraction to look forward to, aside from the rest of the awards-season circus. Isgandarov is very into video games — one small factor in his decision to go to SCAD was that he was familiar with the city of Savannah, because it served as a level in a Walking Dead game — and is eagerly awaiting the release of Grand Theft Auto VI. In disappointing news for anyone who might want to see Eldar Isgandarov in every A24 movie going forward: “Once that comes out,” he says, “nobody’s seeing me ever again.”

Related