Beggars could be fined, arrested and face jail once again under a Liberal government pledge to re-criminalise begging, walking back the Carroll government’s move to legalise it just months ago.

Shadow attorney general James Newbury promised on Monday a Liberal-National government would reinstate the controversial law, promising to “take action” on a steep rise in begging.

It comes after the Herald Sun on Monday revealed that in the nine weeks since begging was made legal by the Carroll state government, council safety officers had reported nearly triple the amount of incidents.

A total of 470 begging incidents were recorded in the 40 days after the law change — up from 176 in the 40 days prior.

On the back of the exclusive data, the Coalition quickly pledged to reintroduce the offence of begging if elected on November 28.

Speaking with Opposition Leader Jess Wilson in Melbourne’s outer north on Monday, Shadow Attorney-General James Newbury said “we will take action”.

“But it’s not just about the actual law and changing the law,” he said.

“It’s also about making sure police have the tools they need, which is why move on laws are such an important part to give police the option to do something where they see something needs to be done.”

But Premier Ben Carroll held firm on his decriminalisation stance, saying that “beggars need a lift up, not a criminal record”.

“I’ve always been a politician that looks at the evidence and does what’s in the best interests of everybody,” Mr Carroll said.

“We’ve had coronial report after coronial report saying this is what was required.”

It comes as Melbourne traders reveal they’re “suffering” at the hands of a sharp rise in “aggressive” begging, verbal abuse and property theft by rough sleepers.

Farhan Mehmood, who is the manager of Rozzis Pizza and Pasta at Flinders St Station, said numerous people were begging for free food and drinks at his store every day.

“When we say no, they just abuse us,” he said.

“Sometimes, they take our machines and throw them, take our drinks and throw them on us.”

Last week, a woman – who the Herald Sun understands was a rough sleeper – hurled an eftpos machine into his store after employees declined to give her a free slice of pizza, Mr Mehmood said.

Rough sleepers regularly forced their way behind the counter to steal entire pizzas, he said.

“I have reported like three, four times, but there was no action,” he said.

Meanwhile, Fadri Nada Oei, who owns Seedling Cafe on Flinders Ln, said the rate of begging had increased since September, with the store tip jar recently stolen.

“I think every week we see someone begging here, asking for change, money … free coffee, free food,” Mr Nada Oei said.

“There’s some familiar faces, but lately, it’s different (faces).”

Mr Nada Oei – who has previously experienced a physical assault at his store – said his staff were increasingly feeling scared, noting “lots of stabbings”, and daily arrests on Elizabeth St.

While interviewing Mr Nada Oei, one woman who appeared intoxicated could be heard yelling “I will stab you, you f—ing slut”.

He backed the Coalition’s bid to re-criminalise begging to “protect us, because it’s getting worse”.

“We need help, we need support from the government,” he said.

It comes as leading business groups hit out at the rollout of the decriminalisation.

Committee for Melbourne Chief Executive Cath Evans called begging a “complex issue”, and said making it legal “without putting in place the necessary support system” had left businesses and councils dealing with the consequences.

“You can’t change the law and ignore the consequences,” Ms Evans said.

“For the most part, businesses operating in the CBD have been left to navigate these social issues alone.

“Government needs to actively engage with all affected parties, including support services, local council, and business.

“We need to support people experiencing homelessness, while ensuring Melbourne businesses, their workers and customers can operate in a safe and welcoming CBD.”

While the Premier claimed he was “working in the best interests of everybody”, Australian Restaurant and Cafe Association CEO Wes Lambert said he felt business had been left behind.

“I guess the Premier doesn’t include small business in the definition of everybody because having beggars out front of businesses and ATMs and banks is not going to help Victoria, especially the City of Melbourne,” Mr Lambert said.

“Ultimately it will be small businesses that pay when their customers stop coming because there are beggars on every square metre of sidewalk.”

Traders like Johnny Sandish said the rate of begging was “increasing day by day.”

Mr Sandish, who manages Xpressomondo on Degraves St, describes “aggressive” and drug-induced individuals leaving his staff “very scared”.

He said he worked at the restaurant seven days a week, partially to shield staff from having to confront beggars directly.

“Some (homeless people) are coming indoors, helping themselves to knives and forks, telling me that they work here,” he said.

“I think the government should step in and do something about it.”

Nelson Acosta, who works for Hit Collectables on Swanston St, said beggars were regularly blocking the storefront and advertising.

The collectable card store shares a space with EzyMart, where staff reported beggars attending or stealing stock twice daily.

Footage shared with the Herald Sun showed one man, wearing socks and no shoes, leaping over the counter toward a staff member before shouting at him.

Council Watch’s Dean Hurlston welcomed the Coalition’s pledge, saying Labor’s decriminalisation of begging had “undermined” the work of the City of Melbourne.

But he warned local councils needed to pause any plans of new local laws that could have criminalised begging by stealth until after the election, urging councillors to “act like grown-ups and not waste public money until they have had an audience with the state”.

Begging charges had been rarely used in the years leading up to the September 10 decriminalisation.

Instead, they were used primarily as a deterrent for authorities to encourage people into support services.

Begging charges fell by 90 per cent in the past five years, with just 10 charges laid in 2024-25 and no jail time imposed since 2023.

The 2025 coroner’s findings recommended Victoria Police discourage criminal responses to begging and instead prioritise welfare.

Western Australia, NSW, the ACT and Tasmania have already decriminalised the offence.