A year is a long time in football and that is certainly the case when it comes to Scotland’s fortunes.

From a historic night against Denmark as the long wait to return to the World Cup finally ended, to a bruising 4-0 defeat to Switzerland at the end of a frustrating Nations League campaign. The contrast is stark.

A second-half collapse against a second-string Swiss side in St Gallen condemned the Scots to their heaviest loss since their 5-1 thrashing by Germany at Euro 2024.

Scotland managed one shot on target against Switzerland

Image:
Scotland managed one shot on target against Switzerland

After also leading Scotland to back-to-back Euros, Steve Clarke was always going to be a hard act to follow. After just six games, some of the Tartan Army have already seen enough from Sebastien Pocognoli.

The new head coach managed two wins against North Macedonia in Group B1. The third-place finish means Scotland will be in pot three when the qualifying draw is made for Euro 2028 on December 6, meaning a potentially more challenging campaign.

Pocognoli wants time, something even his captain Andy Robertson said you do not get in international football.

What is going wrong for the new head coach?

Lewis Ferguson conceded an own goal after a positive Scotland start against the Swiss

Image:
Lewis Ferguson conceded an own goal after a positive Scotland start against the Swiss

Pocognoli has consistently stressed the need for patience as he tries to implement a more attack-minded style.

He favours a back three featuring wing-backs, with two attacking midfielders or a central playmaker supporting a single striker as he looks to press high up the pitch.

The issue is, Scotland don’t have the right players.

Pacy winger Ben Gannon-Doak has frequently been deployed at right wing-back in this system, but his natural attacking fair is being limited by the defensive demands that brings.

While Clarke did use a back five in his early tenure to try and accomodate both Andy Roberston and John McGinn, he favoured a more traditional back four.

Pocognoli’s Scotland start

Slovenia 0-0 Scotland
Scotland 0-3 Switzerland
North Macedonia 0-2 Scotland
Scotland 1-2 Slovenia
Scotland 2-1 North Macedonia
Switzerland 4-0 Scotland

His teams were not always entertaining to watch, but they did get the job done. Most of the time.

The question for Pocognoli is, should he stick to his principles or look at what his predecessor did to bring the highs the Tartan Army had been missing?

Does Pocognoli need more time?

Scotland suffered their heaviest defeat since Euro 2024

Image:
Scotland suffered their heaviest defeat since Euro 2024

After two camps and six games, any grace period the Belgian had is over.

Time with the players is something international managers do not have, but Pocognoli has already had more than some.

The elongated international window between September and October, followed by the most recent camp means he has had 24 days with his squad. That is equivalent to what a Scottish Premiership side has between day one of pre-season and their first game in the League Cup group stages.

Andy Robertson became Scotland’s most capped men’s player against Switzerland, but there was not much for the captain to celebrate.

“That cannot happen in international football,” he told BBC Scotland after the match.

“I don’t think you’ve got time in international football, you have to do it. These supporters who travel everywhere, are they going to give us time? No. Are the people inside Hampden going to give us time? No. Are the people outside Hampden, who are going to be critical and rightly so? No.

“We don’t have time, the players do not have time, we have got to step up.”

John McGinn echoed his skipper when asked if Scotland were on the right path: “Well, obviously the trajectory of the results means it’s impossible for me to say yes.”

‘It’s starting to frustrate people’

James Scott from the Football Park Scotland podcast speaking on Sky Sports News:

“It’s the early days and the players. It’ll take time for us to maybe get going on this but that can’t be the detriment of results.

“We can accept a poor performance against Macedonia, still getting the win, but coming away against Switzerland, it’s a much tougher task and I think we could save face a bit by maybe just making a few adjustments.

“Losing against Switzerland is not a bad thing but to ship four goals in the manner we did with the lack of fight, the jury’s out on the formation now. It’s starting to frustrate people.

It was a frustrating night for Scotland

Image:
It was a frustrating night for Scotland

“We’ve got two friendlies now in March, Euro qualifiers starting next year. If things don’t change in the friendlies, the frustration really will start to build because you don’t get a lot of time in international football and I think mistakes do cost you more.

“We can’t make amends for last night until then and then the qualifiers come around and there’s really no room to slip up there because you don’t want to be relying on the sort of safety net of being a host to get in.

“We would like to qualify and we don’t want to miss out on a tournament that’s happening in our own back garden and not being there.”

What’s next for Scotland?

Will manager and captain be united for Scotland's Euro 2028 qualifying campaign?

Image:
Will manager and captain be united for Scotland’s Euro 2028 qualifying campaign?

The next international break is not until March, with two friendlies before the Euro 2028 qualifying campaign kicks off.

Robertson admitted the long wait is “not a good thing” as they look to regroup after the Nations League disappointment.

While that means no time on the pitch with his players, Pocognoli will have time to assess his squad and tactics. If the Scottish FA decides he is still the right man to lead the national team to their next major tournament.