The case against is more compelling, however.

First, it is not right to have a team that finished in the bottom half of the ladder given an opportunity to win the premiership.

Had the system existed this year, the Hawks (eighth) would have hosted the Bulldogs (ninth), while Gold Coast (seventh) would have copped the 10th-placed Swans, who won 12 of 23 games and had an underwhelming percentage of 97; Gold Coast won 15 games and had a percentage of 124.9, yet they would meet on equal footing.

The 2025 season was anomalous in that there was a huge gulf between the top nine sides, and the bottom eight (Sydney belonging to neither group). This was proven in the finals, when the Hawks stormed to the preliminary final and the Suns upset the Dockers in Perth.

The top eight was remarkably even, albeit the Brisbane Lions’ innate talent was supreme when everything was on the line.

The 10th team didn’t deserve to stay alive in September. In 2019, 2021, 2022 and 2023, the 10th team won 11 games three times and just 10 (St Kilda, 2021) once; from 2023, there have been 23 regular-season games.

Yes, the Crows were fleeced of a finals berth in 2023, but that was due to a goal umpire’s blunder and irrelevant to the finals system.

When Tasmania arrives, likely in 2028, it will be 10 finalists from 19 teams – that’s slightly less egregious than 10 from 18 teams. Yet, the same principle applies; a majority get to play finals. Tenth is the embodiment of mediocrity.

The league has had an expansion of finals on its agenda for a while. In July, when it was put to the club chief executives, there was no pushback. The sentiment was “why not do it” from those in the room, who could see the dollars it would generate.

Loading

The clubs are at odds with their own fans, who are admittedly conservative on such reforms (77 per cent oppose the wildcard, according to the AFL Fans’ Association survey). But they will not care so much once it’s established.

I would contend that 2023 and 2024 were more representative of the new norm than 2025, when so many teams fell away relatively early in the season and were out of finals contention by round 12 or 13.

Carlton and the Giants revived from bottom five in 2023 at the midpoint to reach preliminary finals, while the Hawks transformed from 0-5 to be within a James Sicily kick of reaching the penultimate last year. There was no need for a top 10 to maintain the rage and enthusiasm of clubs outside the top half of the ladder then.

Loading

It is a reform, once suspects, that derives from the AFL’s wish for further “big tent” events that will draw eyeballs, in particular. It could well reflect concerns the AFL harbours about the NRL’s advantage in state of origin – handing it four grand final-level broadcast events – as a television product. Note that the final 10 follows the resurrection of state of origin footy in pre-season.

But adding more all the time doesn’t necessarily mean improving the product.

A final observation, to so speak: the Bulldogs’ miracle of 2016 came as Bevo’s boys achieved the most improbable of premierships, from seventh.

Improbable and a fairytale then, it is more like scaling Mount Everest without oxygen now.

Last year, when the Americanised notion of the top 10/wildcard round concept was exhumed by the league, I wrote that this was an AFL idea that kept being regurgitated like a bad, burpy attack of reflux.

Alas, it is one we must all swallow now.

Keep up to date with the best AFL coverage in the country. Sign up for the Real Footy newsletter.