“A day in the cell in the Karlton unit of [Western Plains] felt like a 24-hour lockdown day at Barwon Prison,” one of the group’s affidavits says.
They claim the roof prevented any direct sunlight from entering both the cell yard and exercise yards. “This is an enclosed space in every sense of the word ‘enclosed’, it is not in the least bit open air,” court documents state.
Each prisoner is asking for the court to make a range of declarations, including that the exercise yards at the Karlton unit are non-compliant with the human rights charter.
In September, a judge refused to allow the case to run as a class action, which is being appealed.
An open letter was sent to inmates jailed at the unit around the same time, outlining the intention to fight for a reduction to their prison sentences.
Under Victorian law, prisoners are eligible for a maximum four-day sentence reduction for each day spent in emergency or deprived environments. These are known as emergency management days (EMDs).
“The prison system is arguing that our cases should not be allowed to benefit any other prisoner because there is no evidence that other prisoners [want to complain] about the yards in the Karlton unit or get the EMD’s [sic]. So [we ask if] you will support us in the case we are bringing,” the July letter said.

The construction of Western Plains Correction Centre in Lara cost $1 billion.Credit: Photograph by Chris Hopkins
The two men who attacked gangland figure Tony Mokbel, Teira Bennett and Eldea Teuira, responded to the letter, as did serial rapist Vinod Kumar; Carlos Lam, who attacked a prison guard; and Bassam Tiba of the notorious Tiba crime family. But so far, they have not launched their own proceedings.
Binse said in his affidavit: “I did not feel the sun on my skin as the roof of the yards are fully covered by iron sheeting, thick bars, and some tightly woven mesh covering which allows very little light to come through.”
Tiba said that the lack of gym and kitchen, as well as the limited phone calls, made him feel lonely, depressed and, at times, suicidal.
Loading
Another inmate said the unit was a “waste of taxpayers money”, saying there were daily issues with lights, toilets and ventilation.
Treasure said: “The exercise yards are the worst I’ve ever been held in. Where I’m totally 100 per cent blocked from sunlight as roof is all concrete slab as well as the walls are one end with a mesh cage.”
None of the prisoners who have joined the legal fight are currently housed at the Karlton unit.
A Department of Justice spokesperson declined to comment, saying it would be inappropriate to comment on ongoing court proceedings.
Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.