These areas were six times more effective at reducing emissions than sprawl areas in suburbs like Wallan, Cranbourne and Lynbrook, where people were forced to rely on cars, Kamruzzaman said.

Researchers accessed travel data from more than 78,900 people between 2012 and 2020 collected as part of the Victorian Integrated Survey of Travel and Activity (VISTA).

Transport is tipped to become the largest-emitting sector by the end of the decade. The Australian government is encouraging the uptake of electric vehicles to support emission reductions targets.

Kamruzzaman said relying on technological fixes such as electric vehicles or encouraging people to change travel habits wasn’t enough to meet climate targets alone.

“Existing transport policies are not working to cut down emissions from the transport sector, and we have alternative tools,” he said.

Loading

He said that until now, there hadn’t been enough evidence of what types of neighbourhoods produced emissions and their associated costs.

Retired TAFE teacher Julia Blunden lives in Ashburton in the city’s east but grew up in Werribee, which has limited transport links.

She travels to the outer suburbs for bush walks by train but has always kept a car on standby to get around her suburb.

Now that her eyesight isn’t what it used to be, she is giving up her car and searching for other ways to get around. However, her local buses are unreliable and the nearest tram stop is 25 minutes away.

“I wish I did have a tram in High Street. I wish that the Alamein train service was better than it is,” she said.

“It’s very infrequent after a certain time, at night and on the weekends.”

The findings highlight the gap between policy pushing for accessible neighbourhoods close to transport and the reality of how they are actually built, University of Melbourne transport planning lecturer Paraic Carroll said.

“While we do try to build density closer to rail in particular, it’s not all about living close to a train station, it’s about how you can actually get to and from that station,” he said.

Carroll said relatively “quick wins” like providing more pedestrian crossings and adding to the bicycle network would go a long way towards improving walkability and driving down emissions in existing suburbs.

Loading

“The ratio between funding roads versus public transport and active mobility still really is not at a level where it should be, particularly in the outer suburbs,” he said.

“A lot of attention from a net zero perspective is given to electric vehicles alone, which won’t save us.

“We need neighbourhoods that let people avoid unnecessary travel altogether, or at least give people mobility rather than just replacing one vehicle with another.”

The Monash University study did not include emissions from shipping and air travel based on the assumption they wouldn’t be impacted by neighbourhood design. It used a standardised carbon cost of $60 per tonne.

Get to the heart of what’s happening with climate change and the environment. Sign up for our fortnightly Environment newsletter.