This post is in response to
Animals, Yoga, and Connections to the Natural World
By Marc Bekoff Ph.D.
I’m always interested in how various nonhuman animals (animals) make their presence known in activities that seem far removed from who they are and what they do. This happened when I learned about Alison Zak’s book Wild Asana: Animals, Yoga, and Connecting Our Practice to the Natural World and this past week when I learned about Dr. Kenneth Valpey’s new highly acclaimed open access book Yoga and Animal Ethics. In his eclectic and eye- and heart-opening work, Kenneth “reorients our understanding of yoga by placing animals and the environment at the heart of the tradition’s ethical teachings.” All in all, “By decentering our anthropocentric presuppositions on horizons of continuity across divine, human, and animal domains, we may yet be able to recover our fundamental kinship with the presence of personality in the world.” I envision yoga as playing a large role in rewilding each of our hearts in highly unexpected ways.
Marc Bekoff: Why did you write Yoga and Animal Ethics?
Kenneth Valpey: As environmentalism has gone mainstream in recent decades, increasingly people are seeing the connection between how humans (mis)treat animals and environmental degradation. Yoga’s rising popularity tells me a similar story: people are seeing the need to connect (the original meaning of the Sanskrit word yoga) with nature and with themselves in ways that are beneficial for all. With this book I wanted to show how the dots connect between yoga and animal ethics to explore how the whole of these two areas—yoga and animal ethics—can bring us to a greater vision than the two individual parts.
MB: How does your book relate to your background and general areas of interest?
KV: I’ve been practicing yoga (specifically bhakti-yoga) for the last five decades. A basic starting point in the yoga tradition I follow is to pursue an ethics of “live and let live”: no need to include animal flesh in one’s diet when plant-based alternatives are available. This logic led me eventually into the company of some fine folks dedicated to putting animals on the agenda—members of the Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics, in the same university town where I’ve been a research fellow of the Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies since two decades or so.
MB: Who do you hope to reach?
KV: Broadly speaking, as I wrote in the book’s dedication, it is “for all who would stretch themselves for the sake of nonhuman animals.” I’ve been fortunate to be able to bring this work to readers as an Open Access publication: as well as being available as a printed book, it is also available digitally as a free download from the publisher. It’s an academic publisher (Palgrave Macmillan), but although it has some scholarly trappings, my hope is to reach a wide reading public open to its ideas—enduring ideas that hark back to quite ancient times in India.
MB: What are some of the topics you consider and what are some of your major messages?
KV: The first two chapters excavate ancient Indian rituals of animal sacrifice that spawned a quiet revolution of yoga, grounded in the ethics of non-harm (ahimsa). Then I take readers through each of the eight “limbs” of classical (ashtanga) yoga as ways to rethink our relationship with animals—as like us humans, as not like us, and as indistinct from us. I conclude with insights from my own bhakti-yoga tradition, showing how the rising tide of devotional yoga raises all ships—all living “vessels” by re-visioning who we are in fundamental ways.
MB: How does your work differ from others that are concerned with some of the same general topics?
KV: There has recently been a lot of very important research and writing about what we might call the “inner life” of animals, not least by yourself, Marc! In Yoga and Animal Ethics I bring attention to ourselves—human beings—with the aid of well-established yoga concepts and practices, as able to benefit animals by first working on ourselves. There has also been great writing on animal ethics during the last few decades. Much of this follows Western models of ethical and moral deliberation, especially in the area of “animal rights.” This work is all good and valuable, and my aim is simply to enrich the discussion by calling attention to Eastern—particularly Indian—insights. This is a promising means to help us step back and see a wider horizon of ways to view ourselves as persons who happen to be living in the very special and strange “clothing” that are human bodies.
Specifically, I focus on four broad aspects of yoga that can help open us to the reality of other living beings. First is attention, a central principle of any yoga practice, that needs to be applied to our relations with animals. Next is yoga discipline, the embrace of certain practices of self-restraint that are liberative for ourselves leading to liberative relations with animals. Third is yoga ontology—opening up to the “depth psychology” of who we actually are and what is our potential for being with other beings. Finally, and closely related with these three aspects of yoga, is self-transformation, which sets a trajectory of internal change that stretches the envelope of cultural convention to effect positive change in our environment.
MB: Are you hopeful that as people learn more about the unexpected connections, they will pay more attention to important questions about how they view and treat animals?
KV: Of course, we always hope that what we write will stimulate meaningful discussion leading to positive consequences for the world. In my case, I hope and anticipate that others will take up the task of bringing yoga culture and animal ethical thought together in inspiring ways. The crying need of our world is creative and effective ways to bring about cultures of cooling down, as we are presently like the proverbial frog boiling in the fires of runaway human extractive economy and consumption. I like to think that ancient ways of yoga can be a significant part of the answer to this need, such that the living world—homo sapiens included—might yet have a chance to survive and thrive.