Haddin said, “with the power in this form of the game”, the pair simply “needed to face more balls”.
Australian great Mark Waugh, who like Haddin was commentating the match on Fox, suggested Maxwell’s current form worked against him.
“If he was in better form, he would have demanded opening, but I just think he probably wasn’t that confident to do it,” Waugh said.
But Haddin replied by saying: “Even Stoinis… in a seven-over game, it doesn’t matter – he’s not going to face 10 balls. If he faces 10 balls, he’ll be 25 runs. I just think they got it wrong there.”
Earlier in the game, Haddin said: “I don’t want to be playing at the back end of the game with Maxwell and Stoinis only batting one or two overs.
“Marcus Stoinis is one batter who can get 20 off the last over.”
Stoinis is 13th on the list of the highest run-scorers this Big Bash season, but the out-of-form Maxwell is an eye-popping 59th.
Harper, meanwhile, is third with 381 runs from 11 matches at an average of 54.42 and a strike rate of 155.51.
Proven commodities Maxwell and Stoinis were named in the Australian squad for this year’s T20 World Cup, while Harper missed out.
The Stars were 1-9 when rain forced players off the field, with their victory target altered under DLS.
Cartwright hit Mitch Owen for six off the second last ball of the innings, leaving the Stars needing five to win and four to tie – and force a super over – from the final delivery.
But Owen held his nerve, keeping Cartwright to just a single as the Stars finished at 4-81.
Earlier, when Hurricanes speedster Riley Meredith slipped in the wet conditions, ex-Australian keeper and Hobart gloveman Matthew Wade said, “We shouldn’t be playing in this”.
During a previous rain break, Wade said on Fox Cricket: “Everyone wants to play, no doubt, but there’s a point where if the rain keeps coming down, and guys are coming in trying to bowl 145 [km/h], there has to be some common sense involved.”
Riley Meredith spilled this ball over the rope for six in the final over of the match, but the Hurricanes still held on.Credit: Getty Images
It was a brutal end to the season for the Stars, who could have locked up top spot and two bites at the cherry with a win over Perth in their final regular-season game.
Following the clash, Stars coach Peter Moores said his side got their use of Maxwell and Stoinis right, but a tweak to the power surge rule should be discussed after the Stars lost their ability to use the fielding restriction tactic when their target was adjusted.
“We sent out two lads who have played really well … to send them out for the two overs of power play made complete sense,” he said.
“Joe Clarke is an opener as well. We lost an early one in Tommy [Rogers] and [sent out] Joe, and then obviously the rain came.
“Marcus [Stoinis] was next and Maxi [Maxwell] after that. You’re making decisions as the game evolves. I think we made the right calls.”
The Hurricanes were able to call a power surge for one over in their innings, but the Stars lost theirs after the DLS adjustment.
“It makes a difference in a short game,” said Moores, a former England national coach.
He pointed to English competitions in which fielding restrictions in rain-reduced games are calculated as a percentage and can sometimes span for a portion of an over.
“It seems to make sense – it’s quite simple to do,” Moores said.
“We’ve done that over in England for a bit. Maybe it’s something [for the BBL to look at], but we play to the rules of each competition, and we’ve got no complaints about it.”
Stoinis carved a six off the first ball of the final over but then holed out, before Cartwright did his best with three boundaries in three balls.
Hurricanes quick Riley Meredith (2-19) got a scalp early in the chase to help put his side ahead of the game.
Earlier, Webster, who has only played four times in the Big Bash League this summer due to Test squad commitments, whacked three sixes in a final over from Tom Curran that went for 21.
The Stars dropped two outfield catches, including Nikhil Chaudhary (24 from 11) who hit back-to-back maximums after Curran put down a sitter at cover.
Mitchell Swepson bowled a tight two overs that only went for 12, while Stoinis took 1-6 but only sent down one over.
After they lost the toss, Hobart opener Owen, who hasn’t hit full flight this season, hit Maxwell into the stands but was out two balls later for seven.
If the game had been washed out, the higher-ranked Hurricanes (third) still would have progressed at the expense of the Stars (fourth).
With AAP