If the Australian response to the attack on the Jewish community in Bondi showed us anything it is that the Australian people have an inexhaustible capacity for greatness. Undoubtedly, we saw this in the heroes, both in and out of uniform, who ran into harm’s way to protect us from terror. We saw it too in the outpouring of grief and solidarity in the wake of the horrific event.
No reasonable person wishes for such a dark time to fall on our community again, but should it do so, we have the persistent hope that in such times we will have the light of the individual and collective Australian response to guide us.
This greatness deserves to be matched by our political leadership. Australia deserves a government and principled opposition that reflects their courage, capacity and imagination at such difficult times. Instead, our political leadership has fallen short of this at a state and federal level. The Albanese government has undermined our democracy, community cohesion and trust by enacting laws that erode key democratic principles instead of defending our values and way of life in the face of terror.
When first proposed, it was clear that the federal government’s hate speech laws – which were intended to deal with hate in our community – represented a very significant risk to freedoms of political communication, speech, association and religion. We cannot have peace in our community without all of these.
The conduct of the inquiry that followed the introduction of the laws, a mere three days for consultation, was an exercise in bad faith that prevented civil society from providing legitimate criticisms of our government’s proposals. This breach of trust was not corrected because the government reneged on some of the controversial components of the laws touching on speech and religion. Especially, when without any substantive consultation, it proposed more regressive laws with respect to political communication and association, and in agreement with the Coalition.
At a time when we look in horror at the abuse of executive power and federal law enforcement by the Trump administration in the US, the Albanese government has expanded the executive power of the home affairs minister, Asio and the Australian federal police to decide which groups are considered hate groups under the legislation.
What is worse, so vague and ill-conceived are these laws that Australia’s leading lawyer – the attorney general, Michelle Rowland – could not readily explain what conduct the laws captured when pressed to do so, including whether protesters expressing criticism of actions of the Israeli government would potentially fall foul of the laws.
We cannot have criminal laws on our books that the community does not understand. This sort of ambiguous expansion of executive power without reasonable checks and balances only undermines the rule of law. No one wants more hate in our community, but without the rule of law and responsible government the divisions that drive hate in our community will only grow.