Amid the silliness and schoolyard taunts of Tuesday’s parliament, crossbencher Andrew Wilkie asked a sensible question.

“Seeing as the crossbench is now as big as the Liberal party and likely to soon exceed them with more defections, on what basis are the Liberals still regarded as the opposition?”

There was, of course, a level of levity in the question – good luck corralling the independents-teals-Greens-One Nation-Katter party into one voting bloc.

But watching in real time the disintegration of the Coalition, as Sussan Ley led the smallest ever opposition party in this Parliament House while watching leadership aspirants over both shoulders – Angus Taylor just on her rear-left, Andrew Hastie further back over her right – there was a sense that it couldn’t hurt to let another party have a go for a while.

Parliament’s traditional first-day ecumenical service at a local Canberra church always throws up the chance for strained media metaphors about duty, forgiveness, and prayers. Liberal MP Scott Buchholz joked on his way in that his colleagues needed some “divine intervention”; others said they were praying for the Liberals and Nationals to end their trial separation and resume their troubled marriage.

Sign up: AU Breaking News email

Anthony Albanese on Monday compared the situation to the reality TV outrage of Married At First Sight; minister Jason Clare said it was more like the Beckham family breakdown; while Greens sources likened it to Jerry Springer.

Elsewhere on television, as Labor fired an endless barrage of jokes in question time, the Reserve Bank governor, Michelle Bullock, announced the first interest rate rise since 2023. A more organised opposition could have hammered a government over their economic record – instead, Jim Chalmers skated through without a sweat, instead poking fun at counterpart Ted O’Brien for being named as his own assistant.

The end of 2025’s “year of the snake”, astrologically minded friends note, is prime time for “shedding” old baggage. Freshly shed of the Nationals, Ley’s troubles didn’t look any lighter, but the benches behind her did. Labor’s Tony Burke remarked that the crossbench and opposition party hadn’t been of a similar size since the 1930s.

“We still have the traditional crossbench, but now we’ve got the cross, the very cross and the apoplectic,” Burke told the chamber, gesturing to the independents, the Nationals and the Liberals respectively.

Telling the lower house that the opposition would now get the same amount of questions as the newly expanded (courtesy of David Littleproud and the Nationals) crossbench, Burke said other procedural questions like membership of committees would remain unresolved until there was clarity on the Coalition.

“We could restructure the committees, I just have no idea what the arrangements will be on that side in seven days’ time,” he said.

Liberal MPs shot back, claiming the government’s barely concealed glee at the Coalition catastrophe was to divert attention from their unpopular changes to freedom of information, and years-long delay in responding to the late Peta Murphy’s report on gambling. Both were fair and good points, with the FoI bill friendless and even Labor MPs unhappy at the lack of action on gambling ads.

An organised opposition could have held the government to account and prosecuted those arguments, too.

Even recent One Nation defector Barnaby Joyce condemned the “total fiasco”, urging former colleagues to “get it together” – showing how off-kilter things have gotten, when Joyce gets to stand up as the calm voice of reason and call for sensible politics.

The Nationals found themselves relegated off to the side from the main action in the parliament, the threadbare Liberal-only opposition clumped tightly behind Ley. Like divorced parents at a wedding, the two political parties sat side-by-side, but rarely interacting.

Nationals MP Darren Chester looked up at the press gallery and curled his hands into the shape of binoculars, as if struggling to see so far up into the chamber.

With smiles which may as well have been painted on, lips curling as a mask to meet the barrage of gags and derision from the other side through question time, the Liberals and Nationals were the dictionary definition of having to “grin and bear it”.

While many Labor ministers shoehorned in oblique or awkward references to the disorder opposite, health minister Mark Butler aimed up squarely to Taylor, claiming he was “plotting against his leader from the frontbench”. After protests from Liberals at the language, Burke hit back to jibe that Taylor “never claimed he was misrepresented”.

Taylor sat through this exchange, protesting and making pained faces.

With no Coalition reunion yet in sight, this could be the status quo for parliament this week: an opposition in disarray, a government skating through with insufficient scrutiny. While we won’t see Andrew Wilkie named opposition leader for the crossbench party, insistent mutterings of a Taylor leadership spill might see other leadership changes before too long.