At the beginning of this week, Opposition Leader Sussan Ley’s camp was preparing for a challenge led by Angus Taylor. By week’s end, there was no spill and MPs were increasingly frustrated at the instability Taylor’s ambitions had brought to the party.

“Everything Angus touches turns to shit,” a Liberal colleague tells The Saturday Paper. “He was a disaster as energy minister. He was a disaster as the shadow treasurer. And the definition of insanity would be to put someone with a disastrous track record into the top job hoping things would be different.”

It is not just Taylor. Frustration extends to Andrew Hastie, who withdrew as a candidate even before a challenge was announced.

“To be fair to Angus, Hastie and his crew were the agitators,” a member of the Liberal right says. “He just sat there and sort of did nothing, and then Hastie’s baulked when it got real. That’s what’s happened.”

The numbers floated by the different camps to explain the past two weeks are fluid. The Saturday Paper understands that Hastie’s support was significant, but not enough. Some in the National right faction remained undecided between the two men and would not guarantee their numbers.

“There was broad support, and I think that the generational change argument was one that attracted people,” another Liberal says.

“Let’s be blunt, I think there’s a lot of people on the front bench who are still there from the period that causes problems.”

Taylor has not ruled out a challenge, although Ley tried to hose down any suggestion of plotting during the week as “ridiculous”.

The likely challenger has not fronted the media in weeks. The shadow defence minister kept his counsel even on Wednesday when there was a major Defence land sale announcement from the government. Defence Minister Richard Marles baited Taylor in parliament as the “dog over here who hasn’t barked”.

On the same day Hastie, a former SASR captain, went to the effort of leaving out for photographers a mock-up of Sun Tzu’s The Art of War stuck to a blue folder on his desk at the back of the chamber. Because he could, he crossed the floor with a group of fellow Liberal backbenchers to sit with Nationals MPs over amendments to Labor legislation to freeze the beer excise.

The surge in voter intention support for Pauline Hanson’s anti-immigration party, One Nation, two years out from the next federal election, is front of mind for many in the former Coalition. Former Nationals leader Michael McCormack sees it as an “aberration”, but others are worried about survival.

“One Nation is a threat and we are facing an existential threat as a party right now,” the right faction Liberal MP says. “We need to consolidate our base, but One Nation is not only pulling votes from us, it is pulling votes from Labor and teals, so you see the teal–Green vote go down.

“Why is Angus the right person to counter that? I think the majority of those who are now supporting One Nation are people who would have traditionally been Liberal voters.

“Angus is very clear on values, what he stands for, and what the Liberal Party believes.”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yeN8ByDFXEI

While the focus is now on Taylor and what he will do as the right’s challenger-in-waiting, there is still heat directed at Hastie. Partly, this relates to photographs of him emerging from a sit-down with Taylor and other powerbrokers on the morning of Liberal MP Katie Allen’s memorial service in Melbourne.

“He’s spent the entire time of Sussan’s leadership undermining her and when he had the opportunity to fight for the conviction that he’s got in himself, he chickened out,” another Liberal tells The Saturday Paper.

“He’s just looked like he’s been busted coming out of somewhere he shouldn’t have with that stupid meeting.”

It is yet to be seen how much Hastie has upset colleagues and whether there will be a lasting effect.

A narrative circulating – that Liberal moderates and others not aligned with the right were more likely to support Taylor over Hastie – has been rejected by a Liberal source close to the Ley camp.

They said those not in the hard right would have a big problem with a candidate “hand-picked by Tony Abbott” – a reference to Taylor’s support from the former prime minister.

“There was a view amongst moderates,” they said, “that we need a generational change and a break from the failures of the past.”

That past includes Taylor, although renewal seems to be on the backburner for now.

“Why are they moving against Sussan? … I think she’s done a remarkable job. It looks pretty misogynistic to me. The boys don’t like a girl.”

“I think it looks like the blokes are trying to run the show, but quite clearly they’re not,” a moderate Liberal MP tells The Saturday Paper.

“Why are they moving against Sussan? You can’t blame her for the polls. The polls are a direct reflection of the fact that we have been at each other’s throats now for eight months, and the National Party is all played into that.

“It just seems to me that no one’s made the case for why a democratically elected leader should go. I think she’s done a remarkable job. It looks pretty misogynistic to me. The boys don’t like a girl.”

As for Taylor, Ley supporters expect that a challenge is “baked in”. However, one Liberal observes that he is “not really driving anything, he’s not pushing himself forward”.

There is a strong view that the internal ructions must “come to a head” so the opposition can get back to scrutinising the Albanese government.

The leadership contest immediately post election was tight, with Ley besting Taylor 29 to 25. Much has changed in the eight months since, however, including the loss of several Liberal supporters, such as Gisele Kapterian who failed to hold the seat of Bradfield for the Liberals.

“I think at some point a spill would be probably beneficial, even if Sussan wins,” says the Liberal MP who suggested there was broad support for Hastie. “I think we’ve probably gone so deep into this, we may need to now.”

The expectation in leadership contests is that you go when you can win.

A shallow win – by two votes, say – would bring its own destabilising problems in the current environment. According to one Liberal, it would “achieve nothing”. They said Taylor would “need to get 35 votes in the party room, not 25”.

Taylor is a polarising figure in the party.

The former Morrison government industry, energy and emissions reduction minister has long been seen as leadership material. In the wake of the party’s worst-ever electoral defeat, his appeal is seniority, experience and traditional Liberal values.

Supporters say Australians are looking to be led in a time of uncertainty.

“If this was a job interview, which when you’re looking at people’s qualifications, Angus would be a 10 out of 10, but that’s not what I’m talking about,” a member of the Liberal right says.

“That’s his business experience, his ministerial experience, his academics. They’re not what I’m talking about. He has beliefs and stands for something. Real beliefs.

“Angus has both experience and intellect – and what we need is actually someone to bring the party together, to be a unifying force.”

As shadow treasurer under Peter Dutton, Taylor was responsible for the Coalition’s economic direction in the last term.

The frontbencher regarded his job as being to re-establish the Coalition’s economic credibility, much of that by opposing more than $100 billion in government spending and promising to “get back to basics”.

However, the Coalition narrative on economic management was largely wiped away when Dutton made the call to oppose Labor’s small top-up tax cuts before the May 3 election. Suddenly, the Liberals were a party of higher taxes. Polls indicated they had lost their place as preferred economic managers.

This episode likely features in the party’s review of its election loss, which has been delayed after a defamation threat from Dutton over its contents.

According to insiders, the review, conducted by senior Liberal figures Pru Goward and Nick Minchin, is not just bad for Dutton but also equally bad for Taylor. There is concern that Taylor won’t release it if he becomes leader.

The broader point is that, according to colleagues, Taylor has not prosecuted the case that Ley needs to go or that it needs to happen now.

“The question has got to be what is his legacy?” says a moderate Liberal, before adding, with long pauses: “Thinking… thinking… thinking…”

The moderate issues a challenge to Taylor: “Tell us what you’ve done since you lost to Sussan the leadership ballot in May last year. What have you done to impress on your colleagues that you are the one who should be leading our party now, when we didn’t think you should be leading our party in May?

“What’s changed? What have you done? What is your demonstration of your change, your new skills? What is your offering, apart from you’ve been doing some broad talking in the background?”

Liberals expect Taylor won’t be satisfied until he is leader. They say it is a question of his nature, his character.

“His ambition is so all-encompassing that no other would-be leader could ever enjoy success until he is given the job,” a source close to the Ley camp says.

“It’s a sad situation where he may get enough votes in a spill, not because of talent but because otherwise the internal attacks would be worse than anything the government could throw at whoever would be unfortunate enough to have the job that Angus wants.”

Ley’s other front remains at a stalemate with the Nationals, which continues to take its toll.

“I’ve been a human pincushion for the last two weeks; much of this spewing and hate out of this part of the building,” Nationals leader David Littleproud told journalists in the press gallery three days after staving off an attempt at a leadership challenge in his party room.

“I don’t care. You know what? Give you a little tip: most people in Longreach and Cunnamulla don’t read you. So, I can look them in the eye and just say, ‘Yeah, I did what you asked me to do.’ And I haven’t been pulled up in any town I’ve been, saying, ‘You did the wrong thing’, and that gives me solace.”

The second split this term in the Coalition, sparked by Labor’s hate speech legislation and three Nationals frontbenchers breaching shadow cabinet solidarity over it, is still a matter of negotiation between Ley and Littleproud.

Ley must consider a Liberal-only front bench, which would formalise the rift and bestow more frontline duties and resources to more Liberals, or a reform of the conservative partnership with concessions on either side.

This week, leading moderate Andrew Bragg said the Liberals would be “very capable of running a Liberal Party organisation to the next election”.

The Liberals and Nationals sat separately in parliament this week, pushing out crossbench numbers to a record 28 – a number that rivalled the seats held by the Liberal Party and disrupted the flow of questions to Labor in Question Time.

The Nationals members have been particularly boisterous. Some MPs left Question Time early amid Labor ridicule.

Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government Catherine King joked that she couldn’t hear the Nationals “way over there”. Education Minister Jason Clare said the Nationals made “the Beckhams look like a happy family”.

A Coalition reunion would not make some Liberals happy, but it is the requisite alliance for conservative government in Australia.

Partyroom members are again being urged to give Ley a proper chance.

“Every turn, they’ve tried to stick a hurdle in front of her and trip her up. It’s just crazy,” the unnamed moderate Liberal says.

“Unless they’re prepared to actually do that, I just think we just get more and more of the same.”

This article was first published in the print edition of The Saturday Paper on
February 7, 2026 as “The not-yet coup: ‘Everything Angus touches turns to shit’”.

For almost a decade, The Saturday Paper has published Australia’s leading writers and thinkers.
We have pursued stories that are ignored elsewhere, covering them with sensitivity and depth.
We have done this on refugee policy, on government integrity, on robo-debt, on aged care,
on climate change, on the pandemic.

All our journalism is fiercely independent. It relies on the support of readers.
By subscribing to The Saturday Paper, you are ensuring that we can continue to produce essential,
issue-defining coverage, to dig out stories that take time, to doggedly hold to account
politicians and the political class.

There are very few titles that have the freedom and the space to produce journalism like this.
In a country with a concentration of media ownership unlike anything else in the world,
it is vitally important. Your subscription helps make it possible.

Send this article to a friend for free.

Share this subscriber exclusive article with a friend or family member using share credits.

drawing of walking

Used 1 of … credits

use share credits to share this article with friend or family.

You’ve shared all of your credits for this month. They will refresh on March 1. If you would like to share more, you can buy a gift subscription for a friend.

SHARE WITH A FRIEND
? CREDITS REMAIN

SHARE WITH A SUBSCRIBER
UNLIMITED

Loading…

RELATED READING

Opposition Leader Sussan Ley at a memorial service for Liberal MP Katie Allen.

News

‘She’s dead … they’re amateurs’: The plot to roll Sussan Ley

Jason Koutsoukis

The Liberal Party is expected to vote on its leadership on Tuesday, with Ley having been undermined by the ‘ego and hubris of two conservative men who can’t work out who wants to be the leader’.