February 11, 2026 — 8:00pm
Save
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
Save this article for later
Add articles to your saved list and come back to them anytime.
Got it
AAA
Photo: Megan Herbert
To submit a letter to The Age, email letters@theage.com.au. Please include your home address and telephone number. No attachments, please include your letter in the body of the email. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published.
I wonder about the concept of proportionality in Australia when looking at the protest outcomes of the visit by Israel’s President Isaac Herzog. That respect for the murders of Jewish people in the form of a visit from an Israeli dignitary should be able to occur peacefully is a given. But when that same leader questions why people are protesting the continuing slaughter in Gaza and expansionary Zionist ambitions in the West Bank and police, acting under powers usually associated with major events as a restrictive law to quell protests here, are very vigorous in their responses, I suspect it is taking international niceties too far.
Graeme Foley, Werribee
When these laws are unenforceable
Columnist Ben Saul writes that ″the NSW anti-protest laws clearly violate international law″ (Comment, 11/2). Unfortunately, international law is rarely worth the paper on which it is written, mainly because it is unenforceable when the alleged breaches take place. Advocates of international law must envy the NSW government’s ability to immediately enforce its laws via its own police force. Even local council officers handing out parking tickets generate more respect, or at least fear, than international law.
Rod Wise, Surrey Hills
More division in the community
I expected the visit of Isaac Herzog would cause trouble. The killing at Bondi beach is like a stain on our nation. But on the other side we see what is going on in Gaza on our TV screen. Herzog signing a bomb, and estimated 70,000 Palestinians killed. The government should never have invited Herzog to Australia; it will cause more division in the community.
Margareta Maeder, Keilor Park
The other side of grief
Why are our politicians, with a few exceptions, seemingly incapable of acknowledging or even comprehending the grief, grave offence, and anger felt by Palestinians, Muslims and others at seeing a red carpet rolled out for the representative of a state that has obliterated Gaza, and engaged in the killing and maiming of Palestinian civilians over the past two-plus years?
Angela Smith, Clifton Hill
Conflation fans embers of antisemitism
There’s no single ″Jewish community″. We’re many-headed, and we speak with many, disunified tongues. To say ″the Jewish community asked for their head of state to visit″ – I was never ″asked’, nor was my ″Jewish community″. And my ″Jewish community″ does not have any ″head of state″. Jews + head of state conflates religion + socio-political entity; this conflation, among other things, fans the embers of antisemitism. The State of Israel, President Herzog, Israeli politicians including PM Benjamin Netanyahu, many Australian Jews, and our PM should know better than to project this conflation repeatedly. Herzog is President of Israel, which is Jewish 73 per cent, Islamic 18 per cent and Christian 2 per cent, from Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics. As such, Herzog is head of state of ″Israelis″ not just the subset of Jews. T
Judy Bamberger, O’Connor, ACT
Police were on receiving end, too
While some of the vision from Sydney of police reactions to some Palestinian protesters was confronting, it needs to be remembered that the police were copping their own share of violence from a small section of the crowd. The organisers of this protest should have kept the crowd under control. Everyone has a right to peaceful protest but should know that the police have the law behind them to take appropriate measures if the protest turns violent. Police are not punching bags and need to protect themselves, their mates and the community.
Alan Leitch, Austins Ferry, Tas
THE FORUM
Mocca of reputation
I agree with the exasperation of London-born Louise Huynh (“Bourke Street Mall was once a shopping mecca. What happened?“, 11/2) on trying to find a coffee past 3pm because basically it’s near impossible. Whenever my husband and I are having lunch in the city, and if at a restaurant that doesn’t serve coffee, then we make sure we leave by 2.45 so we can get to a cafe before it closes.
So just like the six o’clock swill of the past, where pub goers would order several beers before the taps were turned off at six, now it’s order several coffees before the machine is turned off at 3 o’clock!
And though I understand staffing costs can be an issue we need to do something, as Melbourne likes to pride itself on being one of the coffee capitals of the world. It’s hard, however, to make that claim when you can’t even get one.
Samantha Keir, East Brighton
Education funding
So there was actually a $428 (2 per cent) reduction in state government education funding per student for the 2023-34 year according to the Productivity Commission (″Parents plug state school funding gaps″, 11/2).
That cutback sees Victoria at the bottom of the table of states for the funding of students for education, and furthermore, lower than the all-states average by 9 per cent and a whopping 22 per cent below that of NSW. It certainly makes one wonder about the truism of our current government number plate slogan ″Victoria – The Education State″.
Brian Marshall, Ashburton
Little has changed
Seems not much has changed over the decades in regards to funding for state schools. In the late 1970s-80s we parents ran weekend working bees to fix the grounds and some parts of the school buildings so our kids were safe. Not an issue, obviously, for private schools.
Marie Nash, Balwyn
Data depletion
We have squandered decades fighting the climate wars, sustained by climate change denial by some in the Coalition, and the mining sector’s self-promotion (″Australians paying high price for ‘second-best’ climate plans″, 11/2).
Just as we are making some headway with renewables, we are set to undermine those gains (and our precious water supplies) by ″hosting″ huge data centres (which harvest our data for profit).
We are already drowning in data. AI may excel at telling us about efficiency, such as where to make energy savings, or how systems can reduce waste. But computer science experts looking at the bigger picture argue AI tools and humanoid robots could make hiring humans uneconomical in nearly every sector.
As for nuclear power, in most cases that technology also requires huge amounts of water for cooling. In a nation that continues to flush its drinking water down the toilet, it is tragically predictable that we would cede this basic resource to those whose care for the future amounts to “a big patch of land in Big Sur I can fly to”, as OpenAI CEO Sam Altman quipped on preparing for the apocalypse.
Fiona Colin, Malvern East
A full service
The declining number of people working in the city, and opting to ″work from home″ (″Bourke Street Mall was once a shopping mecca. What happened?″, 11/2) surprises me as my local station (Rockbank) car park is full about 7 am. If I am lucky to be driven to the station I then have to stand to Southern Cross. I think people are opting for WFH because infrastructure hasn’t kept pace with the population in the west.
Steve Bell, Deanside
Care for the kids
The latest Productivity Report into childcare is shocking (″Serious incidents in childcare rising″, 11/2). Children locked out of, or in, childcare centres; injured, ill or traumatised; less safe than they were five years ago; emergency services called 830 times just in Victoria. Breaches of care are on the rise.
Childcare services were once largely provided by community groups, local government and churches with funding provided by the federal government. A range of services were provided and regulated. That all changed when the Howard government opened the sector to for-profit organisations. Making money became, too often, the goal. Staffing numbers and qualifications have fallen, care has been compromised. We are facing an unacceptable situation, as the report indicates. Government attempts to ″strengthen the sector″ by providing a much needed pay rise for educators, increased penalties and more frequent checks are not enough.
Childcare is an essential service for families. Early childhood education is a strong foundation for our children’s growth. The Scandinavian countries do it well. It is an integral part of their education system. Can we please check how they do it then start providing quality, affordable, universal and community provided care for our children? It may cost us more, but worth every cent, and our future depends on it.
Anne Sgro, Coburg North
Back to Speakers Corner
Maybe the Liberals and Nationals, Sussan Ley and Angus Taylor could all sort out their differences down at the old Speakers Corner by the Yarra. Television coverage would be a ratings winner and the nearby river a great finale for the losing team.
Greg Lee, Red Hill
Fade off into distance
Suggestion: Ley and Taylor do a Gillard-Rudd, whoever loses goes and then forever holds their peace.
Luise Mock, Tawonga South
Wrong priorities
If the Liberals spent as much time as they do plotting and counterplotting for leadership on developing viable policies, they might become relevant.
George Djoneff, Mitcham
Getting to union truth
The latest disclosure that chapters on the Allan government’s inaction regarding claims of corruption and intimidation by the CFMEU associated with the Big Build were deleted from a report into the union is a bombshell revelation (″The Big Bill″, 11/2). It must cast doubt on the credibility of the remainder of the report. Claims that removal of the critical chapters was warranted because they were not well-founded or properly tested suggest an unwillingness to pursue the truth.
This was the very risk many felt when the Albanese government appointed an administrator to conduct a review into the activities of the union rather than have an independent inquiry as established subsequently by the Queensland government. The deletions may raise questions of whether there was an intervention by the Albanese government to protect the Allen government’s reputation in a state election year.
Victoria needs a commission of inquiry based on the Queensland model. Only this will get to the truth. The spotlight on the union must continue.
Martin Newington, Aspendale
Where did my taxes go?
″$15b poured into criminals’ hands … taxpayers … unwittingly funded union corruption … and organised crime rackets” (11/2). I am a taxpayer of retirement age and I can only wonder in despair at how much of my hard-earned income, and that of other Victorians, has gone to these criminals via state-funded projects. We need a government that spends our taxes in a constructive, honest and transparent manner.
Elizabeth Meredith, Surrey Hills
Reforms were lost
Your correspondent (Letters, 11/2) erroneously points the finger at Labor over tax reform. The Australian electorate had the opportunity in 2019 but voted down – driven by LNP fearmongering – the reformist tax policies of Bill Shorten.
Arthur Pritchard, Ascot Vale
True to type
The Liberal Party’s support in the Australian electorate is at a historic low and signals the party’s demolition at the next election, but the men in the federal party room causing the disruptions and frightening the electorate are saying to leader Sussan Ley, “It’s not us, it’s you.” So typical.
Robyn Westwood, Heidelberg Heights
Where will the kids play?
Do people really want to raise their children in high-rise apartments where there is virtually no open space?
It is very unlikely that there will be enough room in surrounding areas to allocate more land for parks.
Jennie Epstein, Little River
Beyond the script
I fully support columnist Ben Saul’s statement that “Anti-protest laws are using a hammer to crack a nut”(11/2).
The NSW government should investigate “shocking allegations of police brutality” that were there for the world to see as protesters expressed their opposition to the visit of Israel’s President Isaac Herzog.
Unfortunately, Herzog went well beyond his script of comforting grieving Jewish families and made provocative statements of a political nature. “Illiberal laws and aggressive policing” is the toxic mix you’d expect of a draconian, authoritarian government.
Kevin Burke, Sandringham
Chuck it in the ute
Speaking of ugly words, let’s get rid of ″utilise″ as well. I’ve not seen a single instance in 50 years where it could not be replaced by ″use″ or ’make use of″.
Lindsay Zoch, Mildura
How to bowl them over
A not-so-good rabbit could change the course of history, Que milagro!
Gerry Balding, Nth Hobart
Photo: Matt GoldingAND ANOTHER THING
Herzog visit
Anthony Albanese has pleaded for all to ″turn the temperature right down″ regarding the Herzog visit. I agree with him, but I wish he had shown foresight by not inviting Herzog in the first place.
Des Bleakley, Vermont South
Sorry Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, you turned the temperature up by bringing Hertzog here. Why?
Ross Hosking, Blackwood, SA
NSW Premier Chris Minns says proportionate force was used by police on protesters under special powers. Minns, we live in Australia, not the US.
Terry Mattison, Mentone
NSW police officers filmed repeatedly punching protesters should be charged with assault.
Reg Murray, Glen Iris
Who’s mourning the Palestinians killed by the IDF?
Chris Hooper, Castlemaine
Furthermore
Activity Centres? Where will you build the schools for the hundreds of children? And car parks? And gardens? And what activities (″20 storeys in housing plans″, 11/2)?
Lance Ross, Kooyong
It is a bit of a worry when ASIO can’t even get the email address correct of the managing director of the ABC (″ASIO got my email wrong: ABC boss″, 11/2). Google it.
Alan Inchley, Frankston
The Coalition carousel goes round and round, getting nowhere, as MPs fight to ride the horse that goes up and down
Greg Curtin, Nunawading
Why do Americans say they could care less, when they mean they couldn’t care less, or could they?
Maureen Goldie, Blackwood, SA
So being from Mildura High School and living on this side of the Yarra, I’m a shoe-in for my application for Royal Melbourne.
David West, Essendon
Ricky Ponting is just fine he doesn’t have to be a member of that club. Punter will always be lauded wherever he hits off.
Margaret Skeen, Pt Lonsdale
Save
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
From our partners