Toronto Maple Leafs Auston Matthews (34) is injured by Anaheim Ducks Radko Gudas (7) during the second period of an NHL game in Toronto. (Credit: Getty Images) One of the key NHL news roundup themes has become the controversial hit by Auston Matthews in a recent game between the Toronto Maple Leafs and Anaheim Ducks. It happened during the second period, later in the game, when Ducks defenseman Radko Gudas had knee-on-knee contact with Matthews during a play.Matthews left the ice at once and never came back to the game. Later, a medical examination indicated a Grade 3 MCL tear and a quad contusion, both severe enough to keep the captain of the Maple Leafs out of the rest of the 2025-26 NHL regular season. The hit soon found its way to the list of most discussed NHL updates of the week.
Judd Muldaver reacts after Radko Gudas injures NHL Toronto Maple Leafs captain Auston Matthews
After the review, the NHL Department of Player Safety suspended Gudas for five games. This ruling, however, elicited intense criticism from the agent of Matthews, Judd Muldaver, who doubted the way the league applied the disciplinary process.According to Muldaver, the degree of the hit merited a more dramatic reaction. Since the Ducks defenseman had been given a chance of a phone hearing but not an in-person hearing, the suspension was not allowed to take more than five games according to the rules in the league. The agent said that the decision was disappointing and implied that it raises questions about how dangerous plays are managed.The scandal has also drawn attention to the safety of the players and their responsibilities in the league. Knee collisions have been universally regarded as the most hazardous in hockey, which frequently results in severe ligament damage.In the case of Toronto, the emphasis is now to play without Matthews in the field. The Maple Leafs will be seen to trial various forward line combinations as they gear up for the next games, which will include a match with the Buffalo Sabres. At the same time, there is still discussion throughout the hockey community regarding the necessity of more severe punishment in the disciplinary framework of the NHL to safeguard the players who are stars and establish uniformity in assessing dangerous blows.