Les Kiss might have played down the prospect of “alarm bells” sounding at Ballymore, but the silence in the sheds at half-time during their shock loss to the Western Force was concerning.
A week after being hammered by the table-topping Hurricanes in Wellington, the Reds were left shell-shocked against the Force, who came into the match sitting equal last alongside Moana Pasifika on four points after claiming just one of their opening six matches.
But it was the Reds who barely fired a shot and were out enthused and outplayed by Simon Cron’s men despite having a pancake for a scrum.
The Force not only won the contact zone, but their shape and accuracy, especially at the lineout, exposed the Reds in the six-tries-to-three victory.
Ultimately, it was the Reds who were out of answers, and the silence that followed was deafening.
Their lacklustre performance also backed up pre-season fears, where the Reds looked directionless, according to sources.
Star Wallabies duo Fraser McReight and Harry Wilson also had little influence on the game and were overshadowed by fringe Argentine lock Franco Molina, who finished with a hat-trick, won two lineout steals and was influential in tight around the ruck.
Wilson’s frustration was particularly evident, with the Test skipper’s frustrations clearly on display after being shown a yellow card for a high shot on Molina in the second half.
The Reds now sit in sixth spot after reaching the halfway point in the season with four wins and three defeats. The defending champion Crusaders are next, too.
And if they drop that match it might not just be the Reds’ hopes of hosting a quarter-final that are shot, but a place in the top six finals altogether.
Indeed, the Waratahs, who are four points behind the Reds (18) and will have a bye next weekend, will be hoping to take advantage of their rival’s latest slip-up.
If that occurs, it won’t just be Queensland who are left red-faced but Rugby Australia, given the governing body announced almost a year ago that Kiss will take over from Joe Schmidt as Wallabies coach in late July.
At present, it looks like a car crash waiting to happen.
The first thing Kiss must do to ensure that doesn’t occur is to get his selection right.
Against the Force, Kiss started in-form half-back Louis Werchon on the bench, while Wallaby-in-waiting midfielder Isaac Henry didn’t even make the 23. Influential prop Jeffery Toomaga-Allen also received limited minutes off the bench despite being the standard bearer and front-row physical steel the Reds needed.
Wallabies captain faces fresh test
He won’t have to make a decision yet, but somewhere in the back of Kiss’s mind, the Wallaby-coach-in-waiting will know it’s a big month for incumbent Test captain Wilson.
Midway through the Super Rugby season, Wilson isn’t in the Wallabies’ best XV, let alone 23.
With Tom Hooper making a mark up north in Exeter after a brilliant 2025 campaign for the Brumbies and Wallabies, Rob Valetini back to his physical best, Charlie Cale lighting up Super Rugby after missing last year’s season, Pete Samu back on Australian shores and offering experience and versatility, Nick Champion de Crespigny stepping up last weekend, and Joe Brial knocking on the Test door, Wilson has his work cut out for him.
While the 26-year-old has always been able to do the flashy stuff well and resonates well with the Australian public, the back-rower’s physicality remains his biggest area of improvement.
Wilson was drilled backwards on a couple of occasions against the Force, while his tackle technique was somewhat exposed again as he rushed out of the defence midway through the second half and collected Molina’s jaw on the way through. It wasn’t the first time the number eight was a little reckless in his tackle technique despite the bulk of his attempted tackle making contact with the Argentine’s chest.
And with Will Skelton out for the rest of the year with an Achilles injury, Kiss will be acutely aware that he’ll need to find physicality elsewhere in the pack to ease the blow of the French-based wrecking-ball.
But that won’t be easy and it should have everyone, including Wilson, on notice.
For now, Kiss will be hoping that Wilson returns to his best.
If he does, it won’t just help the Reds’ finals hopes, but also potentially spare Kiss a huge early decision.
Force dilemma rears its head, again
They say if you don’t laugh, you’ll cry. Well, Force coach Cron must have been laughing through tears on Saturday night.
Not just because his team finally delivered an 80-minute performance, but because the sweet victory comes against all the odds.
Take the performance of Pumas lock Molina, for instance: the 28-year-old delivered one of the great performances for the club by scoring a hat-trick and starring across the ground, but in just a few short months, the international lock will be off again.
It comes after the second-rower signed with Newcastle even before he’d pulled on the Force jersey for the first time.
And therein lies the problem for the Force: too often, the club has been viewed as a transit lounge rather than a high-performance, quality, and aspirational club.
With Darcy Swain to join Clermont at season’s end, it’s a double disaster for the club, which finally has a tight five that can challenge some of the better teams in Super Rugby.
Cron, who is in his fourth year at the Force, must be shaking his head.
While the Force have consistently underachieved, it’s no surprise given they’ve never had a strong pathways system, including a flourishing and strong club competition to lean on.
Half-back’s rise helping Wallaby
Ben Donaldson’s injury in South Africa and subsequent lack of form in Super Rugby AUS spared Schmidt some questions around the make up of the Wallabies squad last year, but the playmaker’s strong start to 2026 has once again put his name up in lights 18 months out from the World Cup.
Donaldson outshone his World Cup teammate, Carter Gordon, on Saturday night during the Force’s 42-19 win in Brisbane.
The 27-year-old was understated during the 23-point win, with his forwards, Molina particularly, rolling up their sleeves in the win.
But Donaldson’s role shouldn’t be underestimated.
His cross-field kick for in-form winger Darby Lancaster was inch-perfect, as the one-Test Wallaby dotted down to ensure the Force’s momentum continued in the second-half.
He also freed up his backs superbly, with centres Bayley Kuenzle and George Bridge running direct lines and regularly crossing the advantage line.
Donaldson not only benefitted from the forwards aiming up, but the quick service of another former Waratahs half-back, Henry Robertson, who has now strung a series of top-shelf performances together.
The 26-year-old might have been denied a try from a late TMO intervention, but the half-back’s tempo, quality pass, competent box kick, and elite defence, including at the breakdown, will give Wallabies selectors something to think about.
Front-row issues the Tahs’ biggest challenge
Winter is coming, and so is the squeeze on the Waratahs’ front-row.
Last Saturday’s heavy defeat to the Chiefs was an early reality check for the Waratahs and their finals ambitions.
Even against a mediocre Chiefs front-row, the Waratahs were blown off the park at the scrum by James Doleman and they never recovered.
Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust.
Oppositions won’t have missed the punishment they copped, and you would expect every team to now go after them at the set-piece.
That’s no surprise given the inexperience in the Waratahs’ front-row stocks following the departures of Test duo Angus Bell and Taniela Tupou.
While the Waratahs have several competent options at hooker, they are razor thin at loosehead and tighthead prop and have been heavily reliant on Tom Lambert and Dan Botha.
It’s why this week’s bye comes at the perfect time for the Waratahs.
The time away will also give experienced playmaker Jack Debreczeni and rising outside back Sid Harvey a second to clear their heads after both had shockers against the Chiefs.
Christy Doran’s Australian Super Rugby Team of the Week
15 Mac Grealy, 14 Darby Lancaster, 13 George Bridge, 12 Bayley Kuenzle, 11 Max Jorgensen, 10 Ben Donaldson, 9 Henry Robertson, 8 Nick Champion de Crespigny, 7 Fraser McReight, 6 Joe Brial, 5 Darcy Swain, 4 Franco Molina (player of the round), 3 Nick Bloomfield, 2 Brandon Paenga-Amosa, 1 Aidan Ross
READ MORE: Maori All Blacks and Blues forward forced into retirement due to terminal cancer diagnosis