Forget property prices and postcode prestige – a new, unexpected metric is dividing Australian suburbs separating the “rich” from the “poor”.
Sydney foodies may have heard of the “Red Rooster line” – an imaginary geographical divide that extends from the city’s airport in Mascot towards the state’s northwest beyond Parramatta.
It’s determined by a cluster of Red Rooster stores that line the border of Western Sydney.
Suburbs west of this fast-food chain’s boundary are identified as lower-income areas, while those to the east are considered more affluent.
The frozen yoghurt train has now jumped on the trend, with the location of Yo-Chi stores in both Sydney and Melbourne painting a similar picture.
In Sydney, the majority of Yo-Chi franchises are located north and east of the Western Motorway with the exception of the Cronulla and Penrith stores.
While in Melbourne, almost all shops are east of the city, aside from the Maribyrnong store which was the first to open in the west.
While Red Rooster stores are concentrated in the west, the “Yo-Chi line” – first noticed by podcaster Josh Fox – reveals a preference for the wealthier eastern and northern suburbs.
For Sydney, this includes Manly, which has a median house price of $5m, and Double Bay where houses are selling for a median $8.4m, according to realestate.com.au.
The same sentiment exists in Melbourne, with stores in Elsternwick, Windsor and Carlton where median house prices range between $1.3m and $2m.
The placement of these stores is no accident, with several factors influencing which locations Yo-Chi and other company owned and franchise brands establish their outlets, experts told news.com.au
A want or a need?
It’s a question many ask themselves each day – do I want this product or do I need this product?
Frozen yoghurt is available everywhere, but it’s the Yo-Chi brand itself that makes it so attractive and with that comes a premium price.
Retail Oasis partner and senior retail strategist Madeline Kulmar told news.com.au Yo-Chi’s core customer is someone with a healthy discretionary income and a habit of paying for “everyday treats” out of choice.
“Sydney’s eastern and northern suburbs over-index on exactly that profile: higher disposable income, dense cafe and retail culture, and a demographic that’s primed to spend on small luxuries regularly,” she said.
“That’s not a comment on the west lacking demand, it’s that the data the brand has used to expand has, so far, pointed east.”
RMIT marketing lecturer Dr Kane Koh supported this sentiment, adding frozen yoghurt from Yo-Chi was usually purchased with disposable income.
“Generally, eastern suburbs have more disposable income than western suburbs due to a higher socio-economic status (SES),” he said.
“So, it makes sense to set up shop in a place where the optional nature of your product caters to the people there.”
“Location, location, location”
It may be a phrase you’d typically hear in a real estate agent’s sales pitch, but Dr Koh said it also rings true for businesses.
“Realistically, frozen yoghurt itself is a common, and arguably homogenous, product. Meaning you can get it pretty much anywhere and should therefore be agnostic to physical locations,” he said.
“So why not just pick one up at your nearest grocery store? Because it’s not just froyo, it’s Yo-Chi.”
The personalised bowl experience makes it easy for customers to become overly ambitious, often resulting in a more costly sale.
Dr Koh said the tendency to overindulge aligns perfectly with Yo-Chi’s target market, being customers who prioritise customisation and experience over strict frugality.
“This is something that aligns with the behaviours of higher SES individuals and neighbourhoods, which is, again, another key aspect of customer segmentation,” he said.
“To sum up, it may seem that there is a preference for eastern suburbs, but it’s more likely that the product offering and branding are just most beneficial for specific locations.
“This is why even the few Yo-Chi locations in the western suburbs perform well.”
Beyond the demographic, Ms Kulmar added that Yo-Chi targeted locations with high foot traffic and a strong concentration of young families, teenagers and nearby schools.
“Layered on top of that is the brand’s positioning as a ‘third place’ hangout, somewhere Gen Z and Gen Alpha customers, many too young for pubs or bars, can spend time with friends,” she said.
“Combined with a highly social media friendly self-serve format and a genuine viral moment culture, Yo-Chi has built something that goes well beyond just selling frozen yoghurt.”
The ‘Yo-Chi line’
So is there a ‘Yo-Chi line’? The answer is yes – with some exceptions.
Instead of mapping where budget chains and retailers cluster, Ms Kulmar said the placement of Yo-Chi stores represent where premium treat categories cluster.
“The two networks rarely overlap,” she said.
“Is it deliberate in the sense of brands consciously avoiding lower income suburbs? Not really.
“It’s more that site selection criteria such as income, lifestyle segment and proximity to other premium retailers naturally exclude those areas as a by-product, rather than a deliberate decision to avoid them.”
While the outcome can look like exclusion, it’s all about marketing and data.
“Where the data shows spend is highest, that’s where the next site goes, which in turn reinforces the divide,” she said.
University of New South Wales professor Chyi Lin Lee, who has researched the Red Rooster line, said different suburbs generally have distinct socio-economic backgrounds which are analysed when brands put together their marketing plans.
“It’s all about strategy,” he said.
“If a company is targeting customers from areas with higher house prices and incomes, it makes sense they are targeting those suburbs,” he said.
While the Yo-Chi line is quite distinct, there are a couple of outlying stores that fall outside the line.
In Sydney, this includes Cronulla, which has a median house price of $3.375m and is situated along the coast, making it the perfect destination for foot traffic, residents who have a more disposable income and is accessible to families.
Penrith is the second outlier in Sydney. While it only has a median house price of $1.1m, it’s city-like personality and tourism opportunities lends to its success.
Meanwhile, Melbourne’s first western suburbs Yo-Chi store in Maribyrnong has become a success story due to it strategically being placed in one of the more wealthier western regions in the city’s third biggest shopping centre.
Can Yo-Chi conquer the west?
For those living out west, having to travel several kilometres to their nearest Yo-Chi store, there may be some bad news.
While there is potential for more Yo-Chi shops to pop up in the regions, Ms Kulmar said expanding it into every suburb would just “dilute” the brand rather than grow it.
“The opportunity in the west and south west is real, it just needs a different catchment lens to the one that’s worked in the east so far,” she said.
Ms Kulmar said the reason stores would be established outside their usual footprint was due to the catchment having strong family foot traffic, an entertainment or retail anchor and a population skewed towards treat-based spending.
Dr Koh added Yo-Chi in the western suburbs may not have the same success as it is in the east due to its business strategy.
“Different neighbourhoods have different customers,” he said.
“However, it’s worth noting that they have already acquired and retained a strong momentum and remain popular, and this popularity will inevitably have a trickledown effect.”
Dr Koh reiterated Yo-Chi tends to be in high traffic, university, or denser residential areas, to cater to its very broad demographic of Gen Z, millennials, parents and their kids.
“Venturing away from this might spell less success, unless of course, the size of the store is reduced in proportion to the expected traffic,” he said.
What is Yo-Chi?
In case you live in the west, hate frozen yoghurt, are not Gen Z or a millennial or have never come across a Yo-Chi store in your life, here’s a quick breakdown.
Yo-Chi has become a cult favourite Australian frozen yoghurt chain after first popping up in Melbourne in 2012.
The brand’s DIY-style dessert bars give customers the freedom to select their choice of frozen yoghurt from a soft-serve machine, before loading up their cups with an extensive range of fresh fruits, chocolates and sauces.
Yo-Chi follows a pay-by-weight model, so before you know it, you could be spending more than $20 for a cup of delicious goodness.
But it’s not just the yoghurt its followers love, it’s the overall atmosphere – or the vibe as they call it – that makes Yo-Chi stores the perfect hangout space.
Not to mention the free self-serve sparkling water!