Sixteen years later, film buffs are still fighting over the infamously ambiguous ending of The Romantics – and it’s time for you to weigh in. If you missed this star-studded hidden gem back in 2010, now is the time to decide for yourself.
The film centres on a tight-knit group of seven college friends – the self-dubbed Romantics – who reunite for a wedding in a picturesque coastal town. The central conflict involves a high-stakes love triangle: passionate Laura (Katie Holmes), the maid of honour, must watch the man she has spent years loving, Tom (Josh Duhamel), marry her wealthy and more stable best friend, Lila (Anna Paquin).
Think of it as the serious, grounded antidote to the exuberant comedy of My Best Friend’s Wedding, or Gen X’s The Big Chill. Where those classics leant into slapstick schemes or boisterous singalongs, here director Galt Niederhoffer – who also wrote the 2008 book – opts for raw authenticity. Instead of the hammed-up rivalry of Julia Roberts and Cameron Diaz, we get a heart-rending look at the painful reality of being the one left behind.
The dialogue between Tom and Laura isn’t about grand romantic gestures; it’s about the exhausting weight of shared history. In one devastatingly honest moment, Tom admits he’s choosing the woman who makes things “easier” over the one who makes him “better”.
(The Romantics is now available to stream for free on Tubi)
For Holmes, the movie marked a major creative turning point where she stepped up as both the lead actor and an active executive producer. Adding a delicious layer of real-life irony to the viewing experience, the film captures Holmes’s character lusting after her first love, Tom, at the exact time Holmes herself was living inside the frenzied media circus of her marriage to her childhood crush, Tom Cruise. While promoting the movie at the time, Holmes swooned to Hollywood.com about how the Top Gun legend would organise red roses to greet her wherever in the world they were staying.
Right now, Holmes’ love life is again under the microscope as she promotes her latest film Happy Hours, because it reunites the mother-of-one with her Dawson’s Creek co-star and former real-life boyfriend, Joshua Jackson. Leaning into fans’ nostalgia, Holmes playfully posted a picture of herself with Jackson, remarking that it had been a dream to act with him again.
In an interview with Variety, Holmes reflected on the massive public reaction to working with Jackson after all these years: “To be honest, it was unexpected. I know we were on a show that a lot of people watched, but I guess we never fully realised the impact. It still kind of throws all of us”.
Likewise, the ultimate draw of The Romantics is the electric chemistry between its now-legendary ensemble cast. In addition to Holmes and Paquin, Jeremy Strong (currently generating massive buzz for his upcoming role as Mark Zuckerberg in Aaron Sorkin’s The Social Reckoning) offers a thrilling early glimpse at the dramatic intensity that would later dazzle television audiences in Succession.
Elsewhere, The Hunting Wives’ Malin Akerman shines as a frustrated actor, Nobody Wants This star Adam Brody does his signature neurotic-but-sensible guy schtick, and veteran star Candice Bergen is terrific as a controlling mother-of-the-bride.
The film peaks during a magical rehearsal dinner scene, where each character’s toast becomes a mini soliloquy exposing their own internal crises. It all culminates in a hauntingly ambiguous, storm-swept climax that boldly rejects tidy commercial rom-com tropes.
So does Holmes’ character ultimately get her guy? Or is she left high and dry as he says “I do” to the safer option?
Stream it this week and be the judge.
(The Romantics is now available to stream for free on Tubi)