If Geelong is forced to choose between pursuing Nick Blakey or Rowan Marshall, a goalkicking great believes the Cats should go with the former.
It comes as several clubs, including Geelong, are believed to have interest in contracted Sydney star Blakey.
Watch every match of AFLW LIVE and ad-break free during play on FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports

WHAT’S GAMBLING REALLY COSTING YOU? Set a deposit limit. For Free and confidential support call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au.
The 26-year-old has a deal that runs through the 2031 season, but the prolific rebounding defender reportedly hasn’t given up seeking a trade, and it’s said he prefers a move to Geelong.
It follows reported frustrations stemming from the Pullman Hotel scandal, with Blakey still a subject of an ongoing police investigation — which would complicate any potential trade deal this month.
But the Cats may face a genuine list management conundrum if both Blakey and Marshall — who Geelong has courted since last year — are available to them.
Because even before dealing for ex-Essendon backman Jordan Ridley on Wednesday, the Cats had limited trade capital.
Pick 14 is their earliest selection this year, and they now don’t own their 2027 first-rounder. Therefore, hypothetically trading for Blakey without including players would be nigh-on impossible.
Trading Day’s David Zita put the issue to legendary Bulldog Brad Johnson on Wednesday night.
“The thing I’m interested in — I don’t see how they’re going to get Rowan Marshall and Nick Blakey, given how hard a line the Saints are playing on this,” Zita said on Fox Footy.
TRADES CENTRAL: Blakey to meet with Vic powerhouse; player swap sees Cats land star
Nick Blakey reportedly has an interest in getting to Geelong this trade period. (Photo by Russell Freeman/AFL Photos via Getty Images)Source: Getty Images
“It would have to be (players included). But if it was (a case of) ‘We need to put our chips in on one of these players here, we can’t get them both’, who is more important to what Geelong needs right now?”
Johnson quickly responded: “Oh, it’s Blakey. Blakey’s the player. When you’re comparing the two, Marshall plays a role for them and a significant one. (But) not as big as what Nick Blakey would do.
“He’s a game changer. And the way that they move the ball already, you watch the likes of Jeremy Cameron and Toby Greene start lighting up if they’ve got Nick Blakey kicking the ball to them.”
And in the meantime, Geelong and St Kilda have made little progress on a trade deal sending Marshall down the highway.
It comes amid the Cats’ reluctance to deal their first-rounder this year — and those waters could become murkier if they wanted to send that pick to the Swans for Blakey.
Saints face crucial next 12 months | 04:23
Zita explained the situation and placed a focus on the “moral” side of things from Marshall’s perspective.
“This just seems like it’s a real standoff at the moment in terms of what the Saints want, and it’s nowhere near what the Cats are willing to provide,” Zita said on Trading Day.
“It’s a really interesting one, I think, just morally. We don’t really speak about the morals of things, really.
“Rowan Marshall, he signed a five-year deal at a company because they told him, ‘You’re our guy, we’re going to pay you lots of money for a long time’.
“And then three years into that deal, they go and get someone else to do his job on a lot more money than he’s getting. A lot more money than what he’s getting. So you can understand his frustration.
“It is a considerably difficult thing for him to go through … At what point here is the onus on the club to do right by Rowan Marshall?”
Johnson replied: “He signed the deal. (But) it hasn’t worked out in that facet. So he’s trying to get out.
“And the clubs behind the scenes will be trying to help, because he’s made a stand, obviously a stronger stand again this year compared to last year with it all.
“(He’s) played good football. I personally think this will be done by the end of the trade period.
“(But) all of a sudden, with Blakey’s name being thrown around, that actually changes the dynamics of your thinking within a club and getting them all done. Before that, it’s 100% locked away.”
The 30-year-old Marshall’s deal runs through to the end of 2027.