St Kilda great Leigh Montagna believes there needs to be an “overhaul” of the AFL’s free agency compensation system.
It comes as Port Adelaide and Gold Coast are poised to receive high-end draft picks for not matching rival offers for Zak Butters and Ben King respectively.
Watch every match of AFLW LIVE and ad-break free during play on FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports.

WHAT’S GAMBLING REALLY COSTING YOU? Set a deposit limit. For Free and confidential support call 1800 858 858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au.
The exact compensation herbs and spices aren’t known, but we do know that every player in the AFL aged 25 or older is ranked on a scale of 0-100, based on their guaranteed salary.
A player’s score is then adjusted for age, with 25-year-olds getting maximum points. In 2024, the AFL added bonus points for longer contracts, with deals running five years or longer given the maximum.
Compensation is then determined by the pay band which the player’s contract falls into, with Band One — a first-round pick — awarded for the top five per cent.
Four second-round compensation picks have been dealt out for the unrestricted free agency moves of Toby Greene, Jordon Butts, Joel Amartey and Lachie Neale.
It comes at a time when the national draft is as compromised as it has ever been, with father-son eligibility, Academy ties, and now Tasmania’s inception making for a heavily-trimmed 2027 open pool.
It leaves talent-hungry clubs, particularly in the bottom half of the ladder, desperate to hit the draft hard this year, before the Devils swoop on the best youngsters next November.
Geelong football boss Andrew Mackie suggested in 2024 that the AFL should quarantine the draft’s first round entirely from free agency compensation picks.
But irrespective of the solution to the ongoing conundrum, dual All-Australian and Fox Footy analyst Montagna is “in the camp (that) we need to have an overhaul”.
Merrett pumped to land at stable club | 11:27
“I think there are just way too many complexities with the draft. With academy bids and points deductions, I think there are way too many,” he told the Fox Footy Podcast.
“It feels like every time they find a sort of problem, they then create some other rule to fix the old one.
“They (the AFL) have always had an issue with unintended consequences, and then they react and make another decision off the back of it.
“I’d like for them to strip it back and find a simpler, more effective way … It’s easy for us to sit here and say that, but I think it is starting to get a little bit too convoluted.”
Joel Amartey netted the Swans second-round draft compensation after leaving Sydney as an unrestricted free agent. (Photo by Matt King/AFL Photos/via Getty Images)Source: Getty Images
Foxfooty.com.au’s Max Laughton explained how the AFL could learn a thing or two from America’s leading sporting organisation.
“You think of the NFL — it’s not a clean comparison — but they only give third-round picks compensation,” he explained.
“That doesn’t corrupt the early picks, the superstar players. It’s still helpful if you’re a bottom-five team and getting an extra second-round pick. That’s useful to you.
“And then it would also mean that good teams that are losing good players might be more willing to re-sign a player or trade him, because you know you’re getting an end-of-second-round pick.”
It comes after Sydney list boss Chris Keane expressed disappointment at yielding end-of-second-round compensation for Joel Amartey’s departure to Carlton.
Amartey, 27, signed a five-year deal with the Blues thought to be worth $700,000-750,000.
But the Swans, curiously, were hoping for an end-of-first-round selection for letting Amartey walk to Princes Park.
“We were hopeful that we would (get band two),” Keane told Trade Radio.
“It’s always challenging when the dilution of what a band three represents, a second-round pick, is such that four of five second-round picks are going to come into the start of the second round as we enter round two.
“That really does dilute what the second-round pick looks like.”