As the stakes grow with each passing week of the college football season, NFL scouts and general managers no doubt are locked in to see which prospects can rise to the occasion. There was no shortage of standouts Saturday.
Who stood out as we inched closer to setting the College Football Playoff field? Our draft experts Dane Brugler and Nick Baumgardner break it down.
1. Nine players in the Texas-LSU game appeared on Dane’s updated top-50 board. Who did the most to help themself Saturday night?
Dane Brugler, NFL Draft analyst: This was not a strong game by Arch Manning, but that was one heck of a game-winning drive. He found completions, including the final swing pass that was perfectly placed for Raleek Brown to nab for the touchdown. Like the Ohio State game, Saturday night’s performance was problematic for multiple reasons, but Manning made clutch plays at the end.
Did both quarterbacks offer up some gifts otherwise? Sure. But credit two senior safeties for taking advantage. A former high school quarterback, Texas’ Jelani McDonald picked off Sam Leavitt three times (and dropped another), reading the backfield and showing off his range. LSU’s Ty Benefield wasn’t far behind, with a pair of interceptions off two poor Manning decisions.
McDonald is my No. 2 safety (No. 30 on the top 50) because of his athletic versatility. Some NFL scouts have questioned if his ball skills are natural, especially given his smaller hands (8 1/4 inches), but he looked like a wide receiver high-pointing the ball. Benefield (No. 38 on the top 50) also made several plays in the run game — it has been awesome for his NFL evaluation to see the LSU coaches use him across the defense.
It was good to see Texas pass rusher Colin Simmons closer to full health, too. The No. 3 player on my updated board had several impact plays. On a third-and-long to open the fourth quarter, Simmons exploded at the snap on a speed rush and there was nothing left tackle Jordan Seaton (No. 8 on the top 50) could do about it, resulting in a sack. The Simmons-vs.-Seaton matchup was fun to track, and Seaton won his share of the reps.
Nick Baumgardner, NFL senior writer: I had McDonald in my top 20 when the season started — and actually wanted to put him higher, but I was still a bit nervous about how smooth he’d be this year. He has been all over the field, though. He’s a terrific athlete who could blossom into a complete DB capable of wearing any hat.
It’s also been a productive year for Texas LB Rasheem Biles. He’s small but quick and very hard to fool. It’s easy to see a situation in which NFL teams overcomplicate things based on the fact he’s just 6 feet 1 inch tall and 220 pounds. But it’d be a mistake.
Also, every time we watch LSU, wide receiver Jackson Harris seems to get better. He’s a sharp route runner with a terrific feel for space and the ability to make people miss after the catch. He’s been one of the biggest risers in the country this year.
These college QBs earned spots on our Top 50 draft board
Dane Brugler
2. With Ohio State coming off two straight losses and playing its backup QB, Jeremiah Smith put up 11 catches for 117 yards and a touchdown. What are your thoughts on his performance Saturday?
Brugler: Smith remains a cheat code. I counted 17 targets for the draft’s No. 1 prospect, as Ohio State wisely peppered him with passes. The offense is limited with a true freshman quarterback, especially downfield (Smith dusted a corner on one post-corner route, but Luke Fahey’s throw was off target). However, Smith consistently got open in the short-to-intermediate game.
I wouldn’t say it was Smith’s best performance, considering he had two drops and left some yardage on the field. Smith is remarkable, but if I were to nitpick his game, his yards after catch remains more good than great — too many times, a single tackler is able to get him on the ground, and he needs to do a better job setting up open-field moves.
After the Oregon loss last week, some talking heads suggested that Smith might shut things down to prepare for the NFL Draft. That just isn’t how Smith is wired. He cares too much about his teammates and legacy, and that competitiveness fuels his dominance. With his numbers Saturday, he became the Big Ten’s all-time receiving yardage leader and set the FBS record for career receiving yards by a player over his first three years in college.
If Ohio State misses the College Football Playoff, Smith probably won’t play in a meaningless bowl game. But you can bet he will empty the tank in the final two regular-season contests.
Baumgardner: This is just further proof — not that we needed it — that Smith is a different football player. Ohio State’s season isn’t technically lost, but this has been one of the more difficult on-field years the program has seen this century. And Smith has refused to take his foot off the gas.
He put the entire offense on his back again Saturday, especially in the first half, and just refused to let Ohio State’s recent slide continue. He’s had more impressive days as a college player, on bigger stages, against better competition. But this was quintessential Jeremiah Smith.
You could point to some of those big days from Ohio State’s Playoff run during his true freshman year or his 206 yards against Iowa earlier this season. If you had to use one game to describe Smith, though, this one would at least be on the list. It was a tremendous effort when his team really needed it.
3. Counting its 49-7 rout of SMU, Wake Forest has won its last six games by a combined score of 313-38 and is very alive in the Playoff hunt. Are there any NFL prospects to track on that roster?
Brugler: Wake Forest has lost multiple talented players to the portal over the past few years, including WR Deuce Alexander, OT Melvin Siani and DT Mateen Ibirogba. But coach Jake Dickert brought in plenty of talent, including several players he’d previously coached at Washington State.
Wide receiver Carlos Hernandez followed Dickert to Winston-Salem and is in the midst of a career season — he surpassed 1,000 receiving yards for the season during Saturday’s game. As an NFL prospect, he has mediocre size (5-11, 186) and length (shorter than 30-inch arms), and he also doesn’t have elite 40 speed. But Hernandez is a clean route runner with the short-area quickness and know-how to create pockets of separation. He has gone from a free-agent prospect to draftable territory.
Safety Davaughn Patterson and defensive lineman Dallas Afalava are the prospects scouts like the most on Wake’s defense. Patterson (6-0, 214) is well-built, with the drive skills and play strength to ground ball carriers in space. Afalava (who recovered a fumble vs. SMU) is undersized by NFL standards (6-1, 294, 31 1/2-inch arms) but has the talent to fight for a roster spot as a subpackage lineman.
Baumgardner: The Demon Deacons are a bit like some of Curt Cignetti’s early Indiana teams, at least from a talent/depth standpoint. Some of the best college football teams are those loaded with seasoned Day 3 draft talent — that’s what this feels like.
Hernandez, though, is the guy to watch. He doesn’t just get open, he carves up defenders after the catch. He’s forced 18 missed tackles already this season, doesn’t drop the ball and plays physical football at the catch point, despite his size. He’s a player to watch come Shrine Bowl/Senior Bowl season.
Important to note: Wake could be good next year, too. Hernandez, Patterson and Afalava all have another year if they want it. I’d also watch more of Hernandez and QB Gio Lopez.
4. Which other prospects impressed you this week?
Brugler: Another week, another Indiana win that featured the country’s best receiver duo making big plays. With the Hoosiers clinging to a one-score lead, Charlie Becker turned out the lights on USC’s upset chances with a 42-yard touchdown. That play was a great example of Becker’s ability to win with a slick speed release, then immediately accelerate to keep the corner stacked. I have no regrets about having Becker No. 5 on my updated board.
Nick Marsh (ranked No. 17) led the Hoosiers in receiving with four catches for 80 yards. However, his biggest play came on a fourth-quarter deep post that landed in the hands of a USC defensive back. Marsh was able to knock the ball out, turning a potentially game-changing interception into an incomplete pass.
Baumgardner: Ohio State edge Kenyatta Jackson Jr. can still be a bit up and down with his pass-rush consistency, but he was definitely impactful (two sacks). It was the most productive game he’s had in a minute, a positive sign for the 6-foot-6, 260 pounder. On one rep Saturday, Jackson landed his punch dead center and just put an offensive lineman on skates.
It was also a productive day for Oregon edge Matayo Uiagalelei. He can be a little middling against the run at times, but the 6-5, 270-pounder did a nice job setting the edge against Michigan, while also picking up five pressures and two sacks. There are more athletic edge rushers in this class, but Uiagalelei plays with a lot of savvy and feels like a high-floor Day 2 candidate.
Brugler: In a 20-6 road win over Clemson, Georgia Tech senior running back Justice Haynes averaged 8.9 yards per carry (116 yards on 13 attempts). Early in the third quarter, he showed off his vision and speed on a 53-yard touchdown scamper through the heart of the Tigers’ defense. Haynes likely will land somewhere in the middle rounds.
And Georgia’s defense set the tone from the first play from scrimmage against Missouri, thanks to senior linebacker Raylen Wilson. Quarterback Austin Simmons showed some of his inexperience on that play by floating a pass to the boundary, which Wilson picked off and returned to the red zone (Georgia scored two plays later). Simmons settled in and made several positive throws, but you could see why scouts believe he will return to school.
Baumgardner: Miami receiver Cooper Barkate continued to pick up the slack with Malachi Toney injured. He finished with eight catches for 134 yards in a win over Duke. We’ve touched on the Duke/Harvard transfer already this season, but Barkate is a QB-friendly target and an excellent route runner with good ball skills. Drops were a sizable concern for him entering this season, but he’s had just two on 53 targets at Miami.