Former Lord Mayor Sally Capp and City of Melbourne chief executive Alison Leighton are being sued in the Supreme Court over the closure of controversial floating nightclub ATET, with new court filings alleging they unlawfully closed the business to appease developers in Docklands.
The latest action in a long-running legal saga alleges the pair deliberately abused their power to unlawfully cancel the Docklands venue’s licence while council was negotiating a development deal with Lendlease.
Both Ms Capp and Ms Leighton are accused of acting with malice, with ATET owner Jake Hughes claiming they were determined to shut the venue despite internal council records showing ATET complied with planning and noise limits.
Council leadership has previously maintained that its actions were driven only by an unprecedented volume of residential noise complaints and ATET’s loss of social licence, denying that officials acted with improper motives or that viable noise-reduction solutions were available to protect nearby residents.
The new legal action follows Town Hall’s about-face in a previous Supreme Court trial, where it admitted that its June 2023 closure of the nightclub was legally invalid.
The council admitted it failed to give ATET a reasonable opportunity to be heard and failed to properly consider the bar’s compliance submissions before pulling its licence.
The new misfeasance action pushes far beyond that admitted breach, alleging senior leadership intentionally bypassed legal protections to sacrifice the venue to protect commercial interests.
In early 2023, Lendlease was a major developer in Docklands, and at the same time a preferred candidate for the City of Melbourne’s $1.7 billion Gurrowa Place development beside the Queen Victoria Market.
On 7 March 2023, senior Lendlease staff wrote a confidential email to state authority Development Victoria (DV) warning that ATET’s open-air music was driving residents out of its buildings and endangering multimillion-dollar apartment sales.
Lendlease urged DV to step in, stating ATET’s presence “directly impacts our ability to develop Victoria Harbour”.
The writ claims Town Hall subsequently moved to shut down the venue to protect its commercial dealings with the developer.
On 26 April 2023, Ms Leighton informed Mr Hughes that the City of Melbourne would no longer support moving ATET to a new location in Victoria Harbour, distanced from nearby residential towers.
ATET alleges this refusal was made for a “collateral purpose, namely, to mollify Lendlease”
The lawsuit then claims Town Hall engaged in an orchestrated effort to terminate ATET’s licence.
Town Hall initially prepared a confidential Ministerial Briefing Paper on 12 May 2023, asking the state government to cancel the licence “without cause”.
In that brief, Council acknowledged its repeat investigations had confirmed ATET was meeting all planning permit and EPA noise conditions, but argued sustained public opposition justified cancellation.
When the state government did not sign off on the clause 4.2 pathway, Town Hall pivoted, ATET alleged.
Ms Leighton issued a notice of default, citing noise monitoring, before formally executing the terminating the license on 23 June 2023.
Just five days later Town Hall publicly announced Lendlease as its official development partner for the QVM site.
The Herald Sun does not suggest the closure of ATET was linked to the Lendlease-QVM deal, only that the claim is made in documents filed in the Supreme Court.
ATET Owner Jake Hughes said: “Council’s sudden desperation to shut us down never made any sense until we read the Lendlease email — if Council shut us down to appease Lendlease and secure that deal, then that is blatant corruption.”
The pleading alleges Ms Leighton acted with reckless indifference to the unlawfulness of the termination.
Ms Capp is accused in the claim of using the influence of her public office to champion the unlawful termination and making misleading public statements claiming the venue was unwilling to move and that no noise solutions existed.
“It was clear from the outset that Council had shut us down unlawfully, and yet we’ve been left to fight it alone,” Mr Hughes said.
“Nick Reece and Alison Leighton should do the right thing and stand down. Their positions are untenable. How can Melburnians trust them to run the city?”
The Herald Sun tried to approach the City of Melbourne and Ms Capp for comment.