Aging manifests itself through a broad diversity of conserved cellular phenotypes, but in most cases, we know little about how these are causally linked to each other (Denoth Lippuner et al., 2014; López-Otín et al., 2023; Janssens and Veenhoff, 2016). In this study, we investigated whether NPC remodelling in old yeast cells contributed to the emergence of other aging phenotypes, using chromosome loss as a case study (Meinema et al., 2022). We showed that NPC remodelling is both necessary and sufficient to drive the age-associated increase in chromosome loss and we identified the mechanisms involved. Specifically, interventions that promoted displacement of the NPC basket, or basket defects more broadly, enhanced non-disjunction and missegregation of sister chromatids to the bud, thereby promoting chromosome loss in old yeast cells. These interventions included mutations that stimulated ERC formation and removed the main yeast TPR isoform, Mlp1. Conversely, interventions that prevented NPC remodelling, such as delaying ERC accumulation or preventing their anchorage and the recruitment of SAGA to NPCs, restored proper chromosome segregation in old cells and suppressed chromosome loss. Thus, NPC remodeling appeared to be the pivotal point for triggering chromosome loss in old cells.

Two potential caveats should be considered. First, the sir2∆ and fob1∆ mutations each have effects beyond influencing ERC formation rates. The sir2∆ mutant cells lose silencing of the hidden mating type loci, genetically behaving as diploids. They fail to silence subtelomeric regions and act through some as-yet unknown mechanism on the maintenance of proteostasis (Haber, 2012; Rine and Herskowitz, 1987; Gottschling et al., 1990; Smith and Boeke, 1997). Likewise, the fob1∆ mutation renders the rDNA locus unstable, which might interfere with rRNA transcription and ribosome biosynthesis (Kobayashi et al., 1998). However, their only clear common denominator is that they both affect ERC formation, and hence NPC remodelling, even if in opposite manners (Kaeberlein et al., 1999; Defossez et al., 1999). Moreover, the sgf73∆ mutation phenocopies the effects of the fob1∆ mutation. Here again, the only known functional overlap between Fob1 and Sgf73 is that they promote ERC accumulation in the mother cell indirectly (Fob1) or directly (Sgf73), ERC anchorage to NPCs, and the consequent displacement of NPC basket (Meinema et al., 2022; Denoth-Lippuner et al., 2014). Finally, introducing another DNA circle in the form of a non-centromeric replicative plasmid, a process that also causes basket displacement (Meinema et al., 2022), promoted chromosome loss as well. Thus, our data establish that DNA circle accumulation and attachment to NPCs trigger chromosome loss. Destabilizing the basket independently of DNA circle accumulation also promotes the premature onset of chromosome loss, indicating that it is the basket displacement from NPCs that triggers chromosome loss upon DNA circle accumulation.

A second possible caveat is that chromosome loss could be linked to aging in some other manner. To address this possibility, we investigated the molecular mechanisms that link basket displacement and chromosome loss. Our data reveal that chromosome loss is due to the non-correction of syntelic chromosome attachments in old cells. In young cells, the kinase aurora B and its accessory factors enforce such corrections (Biggins et al., 1999). Our data also show that the inhibition of error correction in old cells requires the presence of three introns, those of the genes NBL1, MCM21, and GLC7. These three genes are the only chromosome segregation machinery genes that contain an intron. Strikingly, the proteins Nbl1, Mcm21, and Glc7 are all involved in the error correction pathway, together with aurora B/Ipl1 (Pinsky et al., 2006; Poddar et al., 1999; Nakajima et al., 2009). Removing their introns restored proper attachment correction and chromosome segregation in old cells and suppressed the premature chromosome loss phenotype of the ipl1-321 mutant cells grown at semi-permissive temperature. Intron removal delays cell death but does not abrogate aging. Furthermore, removing these introns not only suppresses chromosome missegregation in old wild-type cells, but also in young mlp1∆ mutant cells. Thus, intron removal separates aging and chromosome loss, indicating that these introns are part of the proximal cause of chromosome loss and act independently of age. Therefore, our data indicate that there is a direct, intron-dependent link between basket displacement from NPCs and chromosome loss. Our data indicate that this link involves the leakage of unspliced pre-mRNAs out of the nucleus upon basket removal and affects the basket’s function in mRNA quality control. The fact that another independent set of mutations that also interfere with pre-mRNA retention in the nucleus, such as the gbp2∆ hrb1∆ double mutant cells, also increases the frequency of chromosome loss through the same three introns strengthens this conclusion. Thus, together our data establish that displacement of the nuclear basket from NPCs in old mother cells directly triggers chromosome non-disjunction and loss through causing the leakage of the pre-mRNAs of the intron-containing genes NBL1, MCM21, and GLC7.

This conclusion has several consequences and opens new questions. The key question stems from our observation that releasing pre-mRNA from the nucleus relaxes the control that cells impose on chromosome attachment. The question is, how does this work? Does it involve the translation of the pre-mRNAs in the cytoplasm? Does it come about through the correlated loss of properly mature mRNAs and hence, the reduced expression of their products? Two arguments speak against these interpretations. First, if any of these two options were to account for the effect of pre-mRNA leakage, mutations affecting splicing efficiency would lead to the same effects. However, tempering with the spliceosome does not affect the correction of chromosome attachment errors to any extent and specificity close to the effects of pre-mRNA leakage. Second, since Mcm21 and Glc7 have opposite effects on chromosome correction, it is unclear how impairing the expression of both would lead to the synergistic effects that we observe between them. Finally, analysis of RNA-seq data from replicatively aged cells indicates that if aging indeed impairs the splicing of some transcripts, such as those encoding ribosomal proteins, it stimulates that of others (Gómez-Montalvo et al., 2024). This suggests that aging has a non-linear effect on intron-containing transcripts. It will be important to determine whether basket displacement contributes to these effects, how it does so, and whether this could explain the effect it has on the error correction pathway.

Our observation that basket displacement has such profound and highly specific impacts on processes functionally very distant from that of the NPC, such as chromosome segregation, has several consequences as well. First, it means that NPC remodelling could affect many more cellular functions than only chromosome segregation. Interestingly, beyond mRNA quality control, the basket of the NPC is also involved in protein quality control and the activation of environmentally regulated genes, two processes that are impaired in old cells (Denoth Lippuner et al., 2014; López-Otín et al., 2023). Thus, basket displacement might contribute to these phenotypes in aging cells. It is also very likely that the role of the basket in mRNA quality control could affect more than only chromosome segregation. Curiously, while budding yeasts have kept only a subset of the introns of their ancestors, these introns are not distributed randomly and seem to be enriched in very specific processes, such as genes coding for ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes and proteasome subunits, components of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, and ribosomal proteins (Lim et al., 2021). Interestingly, decay of the ubiquitin-mediated protein degradation, mitochondrial membrane potential, and ribosome assembly are classical and ubiquitous hallmarks of aging (Denoth Lippuner et al., 2014; López-Otín et al., 2023; Janssens and Veenhoff, 2016). Thus, it is possible that basket displacement in old cells contributes to the emergence of these aging phenotypes as well.

A second type of consequences emerging from our observations stems from the fact that displacement of the NPCs’ basket is also observed in stressed cells and not solely in the context of aging. For example, heat shock also causes basket displacement in yeast (Carmody et al., 2010). Therefore, it is possible that the downstream effects we observe in old cells also take place during stress response. In this respect, it is interesting to note that heat shock has been associated with a strong rise in aneuploidy in yeast (Yona et al., 2012; Chen et al., 2012; Shen et al., 2020). Furthermore, aneuploidy is a common response to environmental stress and a primary mechanism for the emergence of stress-resistant clones in fungi (Gilchrist and Stelkens, 2019). Therefore, it is tempting to speculate that the chromosome missegregation resulting from basket displacement might be a selected response to stress. It might be selectively advantageous for cells to actively promote karyotype variations when their survival is in question. It is therefore worth considering that a similar process, perhaps using similar mechanisms, underlies the aneuploidy of cancer cells.

Third, the role of basket displacement in the emergence of aging phenotypes is likely not a peculiarity of yeast. Using proteomics, basket displacement has been inferred to take place in aging cells such as the hepatocytes of old mice and humans (Ori et al., 2015; Malik et al., 2023). Little is known about whether the nuclear basket of metazoans plays a similar role in pre-mRNA retention in the nucleus as that of yeast, but it is striking that intron retention is one of the hallmarks of aging on the metazoan transcriptome, and that pre-mRNA processing genes are important for mitotic stability (Mariotti et al., 2022; Adusumalli et al., 2019; Huang et al., 2022; Funk et al., 2022). Intron retention would be expected if some transcripts escaped the nucleus prematurely. More strikingly, perhaps the most ubiquitous effect of the expression of the progeric variant of lamin A, progerin, across cell types is the displacement of the nuclear basket protein TPR from NPCs (Larrieu et al., 2018). We know still very little about the impact of basket displacement in the aetiology of the Gilford-Hutchinson Progeria Syndrome, but our study suggests that it might be relevant. If so, investigating the potential effects of progerin on pre-mRNA leakage might become an essential step towards understanding how progerin expression causes premature aging.

In a broader sense, our findings might bring fundamental insights towards our understanding of aging. For decades, the role of ERCs in aging has been perceived as a yeast peculiarity. However, the effect it has on NPCs may close the gap. On one hand, it seems to illuminate what might be the commonality between ERC-driven aging in yeast and other aging processes in other eukaryotes. Indeed, the basket-centric view of aging that we propose here would explain how ERCs actually cause aging in yeast and indicate that while ERC accumulation might be a yeast idiosyncrasy, its downstream effects are not. On the other hand, this idea opens two corollary questions. (1) What is the biological significance of eccDNAs promoting basket displacement in yeast? (2) What causes basket displacement in other aging systems? We are intrigued by the idea that ERCs and any replicating eccDNA for that matter are the closest mimics that laboratory yeast strain may encounter of pathogenic DNA of exogenous origin. In that perspective, basket displacement and the ensuing effects might have first appeared as a response to infections. In other words, yeast aging might reflect the activity of a death pathway that normally functions in pathogen control. It might represent a fungal version of the inflammatory or auto-immune response in metazoans. Therefore, it will be interesting to investigate whether exogenous or non-chromosomal DNA, such as that of viruses, also triggers the displacement of the nuclear basket from NPCs in yeast and other systems, and whether this contributes to either or both of anti-viral defence and aging. If so, aging might have emerged as an anti-viral defence.