A jurisdictional battle is underway as Algoma Steel and U.S. Steel have each filed lawsuits against each other

Algoma Steel is asking an Ontario court to nullify an iron ore contract it signed with U.S. Steel, one of its suppliers.

Filed by Algoma Steel in Sault Ste. Marie on Sept. 29, 2025, the lawsuit is separate from one filed by U.S. Steel last year against the Canadian steelmaker.

In the Ontario lawsuit, Algoma is seeking a declaration that the two companies are no longer bound by the terms of the pellet contract that went into effect in 2020 and was extended to 2027.

“Broadly speaking, the contract provided that Algoma would purchase from U.S. Steel, during a specified period, a set quantity of iron ore pellets for use in Algoma’s blast furnace operations,” Algoma said in its lawsuit.

The contract stated that Algoma was to receive 2.5 million tons of iron ore from U.S. Steel in the shipping 2025 season, followed by two million tons during the 2026 season.

Algoma said when it entered into the contract, it was understood the pellets provided by U.S. Steel would be used in its blast furnace for hot rolled steel, most of which the company expected to sell to U.S.-based customers.

“The parties also understood that, without access to the U.S. market, Algoma’s blast furnace operations would not be viable,” said Algoma in the lawsuit.

Tariffs put in place by U.S. President Donald Trump totalling 25 per cent went into effect on March 4, 2025, paused two days later on March 6 and reinstated on March 12, 2025.

On June 4, 2025, Trump increased the steel tariffs to 50 per cent.

Algoma said the tariffs have caused ‘unprecedented irreparable damage’ to the steelmaker’s business.

“Having lost access to the U.S. market as a result of the tariffs, and with continued blast furnace operation rendered impracticable as a result, Algoma has had no alternative but to begin winding down its blast furnace operations.

“This is not a voluntary commercial choice, but the direct and unavoidable consequence of the governmental restraints that have foreclosed Algoma’s direct and indirect access to the U.S. market.”

Without continued blast furnace operations, Algoma said they have no use for iron ore pellets, including those supplied under the contract with U.S. Steel.

The company could not have foreseen the damage the tariffs would do at the time the contract was made, Algoma said.

“Continued performance of the Pellet Contract in the face of such an unforeseeable and uncontrollable situation would result in a loss to Algoma that is severe and unjust,” said Algoma.

On April 10, U.S. Steel filed a notice of motion that it will ask for the action to be stayed, claiming the contract was made under Pennsylvania law.

“Pennsylvania is the more appropriate and convenient forum for the hearing of the issues raised in the Ontario proceeding,” said U.S. Steel in the notice.

A Pittsburgh court recently denied Algoma Steel’s bid to void a contract and dismiss a lawsuit made against it by U.S. Steel., sending the matter to arbitration.

Last year on Oct. 6, U.S. Steel sued the Sault Ste. Marie steelmaker, filing a breach-of-contract lawsuit in Pittsburgh, looking to enforce an iron ore purchase agreement and recover more than US$22 million.

— with files from Ian Ross, Northern Ontario Business, and Brandon Walker