Listen to this article
Estimated 5 minutes
The audio version of this article is generated by AI-based technology. Mispronunciations can occur. We are working with our partners to continually review and improve the results.
Ottawa’s auditor general has released a scathing report into how OC Transpo is planning and scheduling its bus system, blasting “inaccurate run times” and saying last year’s major bus route changes were based on outdated data.
The audit found that scheduled run times do not reflect actual travel times, in part because of delays launching the “New Ways to Bus” changes, which the audit said were primarily driven by a desire to cut costs.
“OC Transpo’s run times were last holistically updated for implementation of New Ways to Bus, based on data collected in 2023,” said the audit, released by Auditor General Nathalie Gougeon’s office on Thursday.
“Due to delays in launching New Ways to Bus in April 2025, run times became inaccurate because of evolving traffic patterns throughout the city.”
She found that 29 per cent of select weekday routes had times that were off by 10 per cent or more, and there weren’t enough resources available to make adjustments and keep them accurate.
The bus schedule that has been developed cannot be achieved consistently with existing resources.- Ottawa Auditor General Nathalie Gougeon
New Ways to Bus altered more than 100 bus routes across the city. While OC Transpo publicly sold it as a way to bring service in line with ridership patterns and the opening of O-Train lines 2 and 4, the audit suggests they had a different motivation.
“While some service improvements were implemented in New Ways to Bus, interviews with management indicate that decisions were mainly driven by budget considerations,” the audit said.
“The redesign focused on achieving an annual bus operating cost reduction of approximately $10 million, equivalent to a reduction of 70,000 bus service hours annually.”
The report also said the redesign suffered from “limited opportunities for meaningful public input” after 2023. Even now, it said OC Transpo isn’t sufficiently tracking the impact of the changes.
“Without sufficient public engagement to inform key decisions, the resulting redesign may not have achieved optimal outcomes and may erode public trust.”
Driver shortages, unrealistic fleet plan
More broadly, the audit pointed to unrealistic schedules, including insufficient recovery time between trips on some routes. Others had too long of a buffer, wasting resources.
It found that buses often started late — especially this January, when about a quarter began their routes 10 minutes late or more during afternoon rush hour.
“Given current operational realities, OC Transpo has not been able to reliably deliver its scheduled bus service,” said the audit.
“While weekend and off-peak service has been approaching reliability targets, weekday peak service has been consistently under-performing.”
OC Transpo grappled with a surge of bus cancellations that began early this year. On the worst week in January, OC Transpo was cancelling six to seven per cent of all trips.
The problem has eased as long-awaited shipments of more reliable electric buses finally arrive, though OC Transpo still hasn’t restored 255 trips it removed from the schedules.
Yet the audit raises concerns that OC Transpo’s fleet replacement plans may not be realistic. The agency is planning to replace 354 diesel buses one-for-one with 354 electric buses, but Gougeon’s audit said that might not take account of the range limitations of the new vehicles.
And the problems with OC Transpo’s bus system go beyond cancelled trips, with the agency consistently falling short of its on-time delivery targets as too many buses show up late.
Gougeon’s audit pointed to some longstanding issues that have come up again and again at transit committee, including the aging bus fleet as well as shortages of mechanics and bus drivers.
It said that a current shortage of bus drivers is not expected to be resolved until January of next year.
“Overall, based on the priorities and targets established, the bus schedule that has been developed cannot be achieved consistently with existing resources,” it said.
The audit also pointed to outdated and unrealistic service standards and policies that guide planning and found that “service planning decisions are not all driven by technical, priority-based analysis.”
For example, the audit found routes that essentially duplicated rail lines at the cost of millions of dollars in operating expenses.
OC Transpo accepts recommendations
Ottawa’s new general manager of transit services, Rick Leary, has made reliability a core commitment in his 10-point action plan. He promised to adjust bus schedules “to reflect real travel times” with a goal of meeting OC Transpo’s service delivery target of 99.5 per cent.
Gougeon’s audit makes 10 recommendations, all of which were accepted by OC Transpo management. They include:
A methodology to monitor and update run times.A more conservative approach to bus and operator resources.Review and update the bus fleet plan to make sure there’s enough spares.A system-wide process to monitor performance against service standards.Evaluating route additions and other service changes based on consistent criteria to show value for money.
The audit will go to city council’s audit committee on Friday, allowing councillors to question Gougeon and OC Transpo management and for that management to respond.
It’s the second time Gougeon’s office has investigated OC Transpo in recent months.
In March, she released a report that found OC Transpo was filling positions with candidates who didn’t meet minimum qualifications, sometimes bypassing formal hiring competitions to appoint hand-picked candidates.