Prime Minister Mark Carney’s own department, the Privy Council Office (PCO), has become the bad boy of freedom of information in Canada.

That’s the clear message of a new report from Information Commissioner Caroline Maynard, the independent officer of Parliament who polices the system.

Maynard’s annual report for 2025-26, released last week, singles out PCO as the next-to-worst of some 265 federal institutions for their compliance with the legal requirements of the Access to Information Act.

She issued 63 orders against PCO last year compelling officials to disclose information they had improperly withheld from requesters, a record for the department and a clear indicator of trouble. That number is a steep rise from 25 orders in 2023-24 and 42 in 2024-25.

Only National Defence scored worse last year, racking up 67 such orders. But Maynard was complimentary in her latest report, arguing National Defence has cleaned up its act and is on track for a much better performance in the next year.

She also applauded Library and Archives Canada for mopping up their access-to-info mess. The agency dramatically reduced the number of orders against it to 16 last year, from 104 just two years ago, when it was by far the worst performer across government.

But Maynard was sharply critical of PCO, whose performance she noted has been in a years-long, steep decline. The bad outcomes have persisted despite her warning letter to Carney shortly after the April election last year, and despite a personal meeting with Michael Sabia, clerk of the Privy Council, on Nov. 12.

“As a Central Agency with the essential role of supporting the Prime Minister and Cabinet … PCO ought to demonstrate a clear and sustained commitment to transparency and the timely processing of access to information requests,” Maynard chided in last week’s report.

Maynard cited other metrics attesting to PCO’s shoddy performance. For example, of all the requester complaints lodged against PCO last year, her investigations concluded that 28 per cent were well-founded – compared with an average of only 8.6 per cent for all other institutions.

So what’s going awry inside Carney’s department?

Maynard says that in the case of historical records requested under the Act, PCO relies heavily on consultations with other departments, which pushes responses well beyond legal deadlines. Excessive consultations are a system-wide flaw with access to information but the problem appears to be more deep-rooted at PCO.

More importantly, PCO does not sufficiently delegate authority to the person in charge of access to information and privacy, that is, ATIP Co-ordinator David Neilson. Rather, Carney has delegated authority broadly to the clerk and other senior officials, largely cutting out Neilson and making the signoff for request releases “cumbersome.”

“This level of control increases the time and complexity of investigations,” said Maynard, who has pressed Sabia to institute proper delegation, apparently to no avail.

The centralization hobbling access-to-information at PCO mirrors a general increase in political power at the centre of government over many years, sidelining ministers and strictly controlling public messaging. So perhaps it’s not surprising to see centralization at work in the administration of access to information, where one embarrassing document can rip holes in a government’s carefully wrought agenda.

Maynard’s efforts to bring PCO into compliance with the Act, including her increasing use of orders, are very much needed – but may be backfiring.

A government discussion paper released in March suggested Maynard has been issuing orders too frequently. “The increase of orders is becoming challenging for institutions to manage,” warns the document. Instead, it argues, the commissioner should be mediating rather than issuing orders so often. In doing so, she should consider whether an institution “did its best to respond to the request,” among other pro-bureaucracy considerations.

In other words, the government could quickly reduce the number of orders slapped against PCO simply by handcuffing the commissioner’s ability to issue them. Presto, chango, problem solved.

Maynard has rebutted, saying that mediation is already integral to her investigations, and orders are “a measure of last resort.” Forcing further mediation or negotiation would only exacerbate delays and “risk eroding trust in both the process and government institutions.”

We’re thus witnessing a power struggle over a government’s ability to control the information that citizens need to hold their leaders to account. With an activist, centralizing government enjoying a parliamentary majority, the odds are stacked against citizens.