Neither the player (who has never wielded so much leverage) nor the team (who is suddenly desperate for some goaltending stability) wanted extension talks to drag into the 2025-26 season, after which Stolarz would have become an unrestricted free agent.

So, after weeks of negotiations, Stolarz and general manager Brad Treliving came to an agreement on a four-year, $15-million extension that will keep the giant goaltender in blue and white through 2029-30 at a team-friendly $3.75-million cap hit. 

“Just getting a fair deal for both sides,” Stolarz told Sportsnet at the outset of training camp, was the priority here.

The Maple Leafs are doubling the term of Storlaz’s previous contract while giving him a modest $1.25 million raise. The risk here is that a 31-year-old goaltender with a shaky health record who has never started half the games in a single season can carry a starter’s workload.

The risk on Stolarz’s part is settling for a figure lower than he would be able to command on the open market should he deliver another campaign similar to 2024-25, when he posted the best save percentage in the NHL (.926).

Neither side wanted to mess up a good thing.

The team loves the goalie who backstopped them to a Round 1 victory over Ottawa, complete with a forearm shiver; the goalie loves the team that gave him runway and shot blocks and top-notch medical care.

“I thought it was a huge success,” Stolarz said, reflecting on his first season as a Leaf. “For me personally, just being able to play (a career-high 34) games and get the role as 1A/1B and play stretches of games and to play as well as I did. 

“The most impressive thing for me was my consistency, just being going out there, night in and night out, and taking a lot of pride and really giving the team a chance to win.”

Off the ice, the confident and vocal Stolarz fast became a favourite of his teammates as well as Toronto’s coaching staff and management.

“I want him to stay as long as I stay. Everybody does. He’s a great goaltender, and I wish nothing for the best for him,” forward Steven Lorentz said a couple days before Sunday’s news.

“He truly wants to stay here as well. He’s a great friend of mine. I know he’s going to make the right decision.”

“He’s one of the best goalies in the league, and he showed it last year,” fellow Stanley Cup champ Oliver Ekman-Larsson said recently. “It’s a really good fit for this organization, this city.

“That would mean a lot to lock him up. He’s been proving that he can be a good goalie in this league, and I think he’s gonna take that to the next level this year.”

Stolarz is expected to start Toronto’s opener next week against the Montreal Canadiens.