Los Angeles Chargers v New York Giants

Getty Images

Welcome to the Week 4 grades!

The New York Giants‘ decision to bench Russell Wilson is looking like a brilliant one after Sunday’s action. In his first career start, rookie Jaxson Dart went out and led the Giants to one of the biggest upsets of the 2025 season. Dart threw for a touchdown and ran for one as the Giants pulled off a 21-18 win over the Los Angeles Chargers, who were favored by 5.5 points. 

With the win, Dart became just the sixth QB in NFL history to beat a team with a record of 3-0 or better in his first start. Dart also became the first rookie QB to beat Jim Harbaugh’s Chargers. 

And since we’re talking about Dart, why don’t we go ahead and start our Week 4 grades with the Giants’ big win. 

N.Y. Giants 21-18 over L.A. ChargersPhiladelphia 31-25 over Tampa BayAtlanta 34-27 over WashingtonBuffalo 31-19 over New OrleansDetroit 34-10 over ClevelandNew England 42-13 over CarolinaHouston 26-0 over Tennessee Pittsburgh 24-21 over Minnesota (Dublin)Seattle 23-20 over Arizona (Thursday)