Smart & Biggar are most popular:
Increasingly, scientific authors have been including disclaimers
in publications relating to the use of Large Language Models
(LLMs), such as ChatGPT, Grok, DeepSeek and CoPilot.1
These disclaimers generally do not concern the substance of the
paper but rather note assistance in “proofreading” or
“increasing readability.” On its face, having an LLM
improve a paper’s legibility for the public and other
scientists or engineers, particularly in subject areas full of
jargon, appears to be a valuable use of this technology. However,
authors should be wary of the potential legal implications of such
use.
Any disclosure to the public of an invention before the patent
application’s filing date can jeopardize the validity of the
resulting patent.
The terms of use for some of the most popular LLMs often make no
reference to confidentiality and may explicitly state that certain
information resulting from user input will be used to train the LLM
or for the company’s “own business
purposes.”2 Thus, the ability of companies that
provide LLM services to use or disclose user inputs is often
unclear. Even if disclosure to an LLM does not itself constitute
public disclosure, the company behind the LLM may nevertheless have
access to the input and the ability to disclose it. Further, even
if the company behind the LLM may have no intention to access or
disclose the inputted confidential information, a data leak could
still inadvertently reveal this information to malicious actors.
This vulnerability also applies to other non-AI tools, as any
software, website or service which receives confidential
information from an innovator could store that information on their
networked systems.
Some LLM providers attempt to address these risks through paid
“business” and “enterprise” subscriptions,
which typically promise more robust security features. For example,
some premium LLM offerings exclude user inputs, outputs, and
metadata from model training by default, while other offerings
allow users to opt-out of model training for free.3
Although these measures may reduce the risk of data leaks, they do
not eliminate the fact that, if used by an inventor to proofread a
manuscript, pre-publication information about inventions could
still be transmitted to, and stored, on the LLM provider’s
servers. It is questionable, however, whether this would be
considered disclosure to the public.
Other providers offer so-called “air-gapped” LLMs,
which are deployed entirely within a company’s or
government’s own computing environment and disconnected from
outside servers. These solutions appear to provide a stronger
safeguard, but they are generally available only under custom
contracts with government or defense agencies and remain out of
reach for most innovators.
Given the opaque functioning of LLMs, submitting a manuscript
that contains confidential information or details of potential
inventions may amount to a public disclosure of that information or
those inventions.
While the topic of public disclosure may seem self-evident given
that a manuscript is ultimately intended for publication, the
editorial and publication process associated with many journals can
take years. Accordingly, if a manuscript is disclosed to an LLM,
and such disclosure is considered “public disclosure,” it
could be fatal to the novelty of an invention.
Public disclosure rules vary by country
Novelty, as a fundamental requirement for patentability, demands
that an invention not be disclosed to the public anywhere in the
world before the relevant filing date. However, the extent to which
disclosures made by inventors themselves affect an invention’s
novelty varies widely across jurisdictions. For example, Canada and
the United States each provide a relatively permissive twelve-month
grace period, allowing inventor-originated disclosures, such as an
early conference presentation or manuscript circulation, to be
permitted if a patent application is filed within one year. By
contrast, the European Patent Office adopts a strict approach,
where almost any pre-filing disclosure destroys novelty, subject
only to narrow exceptions for unauthorized disclosures or
disclosures at recognized exhibitions. As well, China offers only a
six-month grace period, and only in limited circumstances, such as
government-recognized exhibitions, certain academic conferences, or
unauthorized disclosure.
Until courts around the world address whether using LLMs
constitutes public disclosure of an invention or new legislation
provides clarity, this issue will remain uncertain. Further, as we
have seen with other issues, results may vary across
jurisdictions.
Best practices
Although there is presently no clear judicial or legislative
guidance relating to the use of LLMs and public disclosure of
inventions, inventors and applicants should take care to maintain
strict confidentiality practices regarding potential inventions.
More particularly, users of LLMs should only input information and
data that are:
not bound by a confidentiality agreement or duty from
disclosing; and
unrelated to a potential invention.
For example, applicants and inventors should avoid inputting
invention descriptions, test data, research notes and other data
related to a potential invention into an LLM. Any information that
will be input into an LLM should be scrutinized for any content
related to the potential invention, especially in view of any other
information about the invention that was previously inputted into
the LLM. This will help reduce the risk that the LLM will
accumulate a description of the potential invention over multiple
uses, either by the same or multiple users.
Recognizing the reality of large corporate applicants and
individual inventors, workplace policies regulating the use of LLMs
may also form part of effective confidentiality strategies. These
policies may include documentation requirements, multi-stage review
of LLM input prompts, and auditing of LLM and other AI tool usage.
Some policies may also require the cycling of LLMs and AI tools
used, to avoid providing too much potentially sensitive data to a
single tool. Applicants and inventors should also carefully
consider the data policies of the LLMs and AI tools they use.
In summary, for IP-minded researchers and inventors, the
risk-reward balance of using LLMs in contexts involving potential
public disclosure and patentability appears to favour either
avoiding their use altogether or, more practically, strategically
limiting such use to aspects that could not constitute public
disclosure of potential inventions.
Footnotes
1. For example, see the “Declaration of generative
AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process” in the
paper: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tifs.2024.104562.
2. For example, ChatGPT and OpenAI (see the subheading
“Services for individuals, such as ChatGPT, Codex, and
Sora” in the article here: https://help.openai.com/en/articles/5722486-how-your-data-is-used-to-improve-model-performance.
Also, Anthropic (see the update: https://www.anthropic.com/news/updates-to-our-consumer-terms).
Also, Gemini (see the guidance: https://cloud.google.com/gemini/docs/discover/data-governance).
3. For example, ChatGPT and OpenAI (see the subheading
“Services for businesses, such as ChatGPT Business, ChatGPT
Enterprise, and our API Platform” in the article: https://help.openai.com/en/articles/5722486-how-your-data-is-used-to-improve-model-performance.
The preceding is intended as a timely update on Canadian
intellectual property and technology law. The content is
informational only and does not constitute legal or professional
advice. To obtain such advice, please communicate with our offices
directly.