If you ask Lyndsey Hamen and Bill Haynes to name their favourite memory from their time working at The Ship Pub, they’ll exchange a glance and Lyndsey will make an inscrutable hand gesture.

Then, Bill will say, “Oh yeah, the thumb-wrestling competition was amazing.”

Of all the live music performances, trivia nights, philosophy discussions, and book launches, their favourite memory is of a fundraiser that pitted local celebrities thumb-to-thumb against each other.

“They had Mark Bragg versus Tim Baker,” Haynes said.

“And Ryan Snodden versus Eddie Sheerr,” Hamen added.

The pub changed hands last month, when Colin Dalton and Terry O’Rourke — its owners since 2002 — transferred the title to Hamen and Haynes. The new owners acquired the pub on Oct. 27, but they have been the face of The Ship for many years.

“Terry and Colin put in 20-plus years of continuing the tradition of The Ship, and now we’re taking up the mantle.” said Hamen.

For Haynes and Hamen, The Ship is both an institution and a workplace they love. Haynes explains that, for several years, the pair had been discussing what might become of the pub in the event that O’Rourke and Dalton should one day decide to sell.

“It got to the point that our bosses were looking towards retirement,” Haynes said. “We didn’t want somebody to turn it into a franchise sports bar.”

A St. John’s institution

Opened in the late 1970s as The Ship Inn, the storied space between Duckworth Street and Water Street has been a gathering place for folks who live and work downtown, especially those engaged in the local arts scene.

“It’s a magical part of the community,” said Hamen. “There’s no room like it anywhere else on the east coast of Canada, or maybe all of Canada.”

By day the kitchen serves elevated pub fare, and by night the bar is a venue for live entertainment, with shows typically booked six nights a week.

A woman and a man sit at a bar.Lyndsey Hamen and Bill Haynes wanted to preserve the spirit of community at the heart of The Ship Pub. (Submitted by Bill Haynes)

A favoured locale for downtown artists and musicians, it has been home to trivia nights, poetry events, book launches, and philosophy discussions.

But, at its core, The Ship is the beating heart of the St. John’s live music scene, its intimate stage space serving as an incubator for emerging local bands and a preferred performance space for established Canadian musicians like Dave Francey, Hawksley Workman, NQ Arbuckle, and — just last month — Barney Bentall.

A sense of community, decades in the making

If you ever go to a packed show at The Ship on a Saturday night, you’re likely to see Haynes and Haman working the bar together. They navigate the tight space like as if choreographed, swiftly shifting from the wall with the glasses to the row of beer taps to the wall with the liquors and liqueurs to the cash register.

It’s an innate rhythm they’ve developed after more than a decade of working together. Haynes has been tending bar at The Ship for 20 years, Lyndsey for 15. In that time, they have become close friends and nurtured a close-knit community of their customers.

Spend an hour or two sitting at the bar on a quiet afternoon, and you can observe their connection with patrons. Well-read and quick-witted, they’ll pitch in with a pun or a Simpson’s reference. Visitors to the city who pop in for a pint may get recommendations for a good feed or a live show.

Occasionally, a newcomer has been known to find someone to help them move into their new place.

An empty bar.The space known locally as The Ship opened in the late 70s as the Ship Inn. It later became The Ship Pub and Kitchen. (Submitted by Bill Haynes)

Their presence behind the bar has created this sense of communal care that runs even deeper than the Ship’s longstanding reputation.

“It’s about community and the musicians we’ve known and the friendships we’ve built,” said Hamen.

“We wanted to continue that on and not see that fade into the past.” 

‘All takeover, no makeover’

But what are the pair’s plans for the future of The Ship? The answer can best be summed up with the theme.

Haynes and Hamen hosted the “All Takeover, No Makeover” event in early November to mark the pub’s official change of hands.

“We’re going to try to keep the business model identical, but we do have some ideas for how we think we can bring in more business,” said Haynes.

“It’s going to be consistently good food, consistently good entertainment, and great service.”

And some things will remain classic, Hamen concluded, summing up what folks should expect.

“Tony Murray always books the music, Wallace Hammond is always on sound, and Bill or Lyndsey is behind the bar.”

Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Sign up for our daily headlines newsletter here. Click here to visit our landing page