The 23XI Racing/Front Row Motorsports feud with NASCAR has been simmering for over a year, and the first day of the antitrust trial on Monday (Dec. 1) delivered fireworks. Denny Hamlin, Joe Gibbs Racing ace and co-owner of 23XI, took the stand to recount his personal sacrifices for the sport, while the teams’ attorneys launched a blistering opening salvo.

Jeffrey Kessler effectively based his offense on the foundation of his earlier “monopoly” argument and fired away with hard-hitting statements. Yet, despite the fierce onslaught from the opposition, NASCAR’s legal team quickly found a crack in their armor, exposing the $205 million demand as “unjust” while putting Hamlin under intense scrutiny in front of the jury.

23XI Racing and Denny Hamlin Under Fire As NASCAR Challenges $205 Million Reparation Claim

Like any high-stakes legal showdown, NASCAR’s fight with its rebel teams has been a numbers game from the very start. From hundreds of explosive exhibits that set the community abuzz, to scathing arguments and counterarguments, the two sides collided over conflicting interests in a lawsuit dating back to October of last year.

While the teams initially succeeded in highlighting Charlotte’s unchallenged authority in stock car racing, earning a nod from the judge, the first day of the trial may not have gone as they had hoped.

Also Read: NASCAR Comes Out Swinging With Three Blistering Claims to Kick Off 23XI Antitrust War

According to senior journalist Adam Stern, NASCAR’s external counsel, Lawrence Buterman, zeroed in on a critical detail and shifted the pressure back onto the teams. Stern tweeted,

“@NASCAR external counsel Lawrence Buterman said 23XI/FRM are asking for $205 million in damages, that this would be a 900% ROI from what 23XI has invested and grilled @DennyHamlin about whether that is a fair ROI.”

Buterman framed it as a staggering “900%” return on investment compared with 23XI’s reported input, instantly casting doubt on the credibility of the claim under antitrust law. As Hamlin recounted his personal and professional struggles, his emotions were evident in his voice.

Yet, Buterman didn’t let up, pressing him over past admissions that he sometimes leaned on “NASCAR talking points,” casting a shadow over his credibility. The veteran responded without hesitation: “nonsense.” In his tweet, Stern also noted that the No. 11 driver’s annual salary at JGR is $14 million.

Earlier that day, the three-time Daytona 500 winner took the witness stand to outline the financial pressures facing teams under NASCAR’s current system. He testified that running a single Cup Series car for a full season costs approximately $20 million, excluding salaries and overhead.

Hamlin’s team entered the series in 2021 with one car, expanding to two full-time entries the following year, and added a third in 2025. According to recently released expert reports, 23XI paid about $28 million for that third Cup Series charter in 2024.

Previously, the team had spent $4.7 million and $13.5 million on its first two charters. The 45-year-old also revealed that roughly $40 million more has been invested in the race shop and technical alliances, bringing the total cost for the three charters to approximately $46.2 million.

FRM, meanwhile, paid between $20 million and $25 million for its third charter, in a deal tied to the now-defunct Stewart-Haas Racing.