It’s difficult to find shoes that are truly waterproof. I’ve tested quite a few pairs for my guide to the best walking shoes and many fall short. Just ask my soggy socks.

For the first time in over a year, I have found a new contender for the crown of best waterproof shoe. I’m currently testing the Columbia Peakfreak Rush Outdry walking shoes and am seriously impressed by how good—and waterproof—they are.

I’m testing a low-rise pair, but noticed that the mid-rise (same shoe, slightly higher collar) currently has a great deal on Amazon. This weekend, you can get it for 43% less than RRP, a saving of $55!

The Peakfreak Rush is a comfortable, easy-to-wear shoe. I’ve worn it on hikes and on a trip to the grocery store. It’s comfortable enough for either.

While it ticks all my boxes for a general walking shoe, what it really excels in is waterproofing. Not only did it make short work of a boggy winter walk, but it also kept my feet dry while I sluiced out all of my outdoor planters with a hose on full blast. Despite a flooded garden and plenty of splashing, my socks remained dry.

I wouldn’t take them through a stream or river—if water gets in over the collar, even these shoes can’t fix that, but they are great for heavy rain, muddy trails and wet pavements.