Ontario Liberals say ‘Ford government needs to answer for this,’ while local councillor Luke Dufour says both sides should be doing ‘everything possible’ to reach a new deal
The interim leader of the Ontario Liberal Party is questioning why more conditions weren’t attached to the millions of dollars in provincial funding that helped build the Agawa Canyon Tour Train station.
Watco, the Kansas-based railway company that operates the iconic local train, announced last week that it’s suddenly abandoning the Canal District station — a prominent Sault Ste. Marie tourist attraction that was constructed with the help of a $5-million grant from the Ford government.
Watco said the popular tour train will now operate from its rail yard at 429 Carmen’s Way.
Interim Liberal Leader John Fraser told SooToday that when the government spends $5 million of public money, Ontarians have a right to expect something lasting in return.
“An empty station, abandoned in less than five years, is not a return on investment,” Fraser said. “The people of Sault Ste. Marie deserved better, and the Ford government needs to answer for this.”
He said any responsible government would attach real conditions to a grant like the one received by the Canal District, like minimum operating terms, clawback provisions and performance benchmarks.
“Either those conditions existed and nobody enforced them, or they were never there to begin with,” he said. “Either way, that’s a serious problem. Ontarians deserve to know which one it is.”
The train station project — a joint initiative between the Sault Ste. Marie Economic Development Corporation and Tony Porco, who owns The Machine Shop, SIS Group and the Canal District — was officially opened in 2021, complete with a ticket booth, restaurant and micro-brewery, an outfitter gift shop and Indigenous cultural learning spaces.
At the ribbon-cutting ceremony, Ross Romano, the Progressive Conservative MPP at the time, called it an “incredible facility” that will attract tens of thousands of tourists.
“This is such a beautiful spot and beautiful destination centre for our community to really harness the power of our tourism sector and really be able to showcase the beauty of what we have here,” Romano said.
SooToday asked the Ministry of Northern Development and Mines if the $5 million in funding included any conditions on the owner of the property, but we did not receive an answer.
Instead, the ministry said in an emailed statement that the Canal District “site continues to serve as a hub for community use and tourism, hosting events such as Bon Soo, concerts, and other community activities for families to enjoy.”
“The approved project supported the redevelopment of the former St. Marys Paper site into a destination tourism attraction designed to strengthen the downtown core, increase visitation, and encourage new investment,” the statement continued.
“The funding included the redevelopment of several amenity-based features, including the Agawa Canyon Tour Train Station.”
In a news release issued yesterday, the Canal District said it held a three-year lease with Watco, which purchased the tour train in 2022. Porco’s company said the lease, which expires on May 30, was structured with an automatic renewal and increases tied solely to the Consumer Price Index.
“There were no rent increases beyond these agreed terms,” the Canal District said.
The cost of the lease was not disclosed.
“The Canal District was not provided with prior notice, nor were we included in any consultation or negotiation process leading to this outcome,” the release said.
Tom Vair, the city’s chief administrative officer, said Watco reached out to the city to provide a heads-up on its decision to relocate.
“At that point, the city did get involved to see if there was an opportunity to keep the train station at the Canal District,” Vair said. “After further communications, Watco indicated that they had made a business decision to relocate to their property.”
Luke Dufour, city councillor for Ward 2, said he’s disappointed that the Canal District and Watco were not able to come to an agreement.
“I think both parties are worse off with this outcome and should be doing everything possible to reach a reasonable agreement,” Dufour said.
“The Agawa Tour Train is a critical piece of our tourism infrastructure; it is the anchor tenant for the Canal District and rail links will form a critical part of our economic future,” he said.
“Local hotel owners and restaurants depend on the rush of customers that comes from the fall train season.
“We need both rail operators and station owners to maintain stable operations with reasonable and predictable funding models to ensure the continued success of the Agawa Tour Train,” Dufour said.
Wardmate Lisa Vezeau-Allen, who ran for the NDP in last year’s provincial election, said she’s not privy to the funding agreements between the Canal District and the province. But she pointed out that the funding supported other areas in the facility, including the Blockhouse restaurant and brewery operation.
“The Agawa Train Tour attracts tourists regionally and globally,” she said. “I don’t believe the location of the station will influence the numbers of travellers coming to experience the train.
“I am confident that the operators and our tourism agencies (Tourism Sault Ste Marie, Destination Northern Ontario, Algoma Kinniwabi Travel and others) will assist in this adjustment,” she said.
In its April 1 news release, Watco said the move to 429 Carmen’s Way “offers convenient on-site parking and easy highway access, making it simpler for passengers to get here and start their day.”
In a follow-up email to SooToday, Watco spokesperson Tracie VanBecelaere said the train is relocating to ensure its operation remains wholly within railway property.
Ontario NDP Leader Marit Stiles did not respond to an interview request.
SooToday has also reached out to MPP Chris Scott and MPP Bill Rosenberg.