Two diamonds formed 700 kilometres below the Earth’s surface reveal a life-giving synchronicity between shifting continents and the cycling of phosphorus, a vital building block of DNA and cell membranes.
For decades, scientists have tracked how phosphorus cycles through the planet’s shallowest layers — to about 100 kilometres — before returning to the surface via volcanoes. Yet a mystery has always remained: why haven’t billions of years of plate tectonics permanently locked phosphorus away in the deepest recesses of the Earth’s mantle?
New research shows that under normal conditions, the descending slabs of oceanic plates that drive plate tectonics are simply too hot to allow the deep Earth to swallow phosphorus, keeping it near the surface and allowing life to thrive. The study was led by former University of Alberta PhD student Qiwei Zhang, now a post-doctoral fellow at the Carnegie Institution for Science, alongside researchers Dr. Graham Pearson and Dr. Thomas Stachel of the Faculty of Science.
“If 90 per cent of phosphorus did get subducted back into the lower mantle, we would have a real phosphorus crisis,” explains Pearson.
“Instead, all of that phosphorus gets torched back off the sinking oceanic plates and stays in the shallow Earth.”
Because the deepest human borehole only reaches 13 kilometres, scientists rely on “super-deep” diamonds — which form at staggering depths between 410 and 700 kilometres — to act as deep-mantle probes and time capsules. Partnering with the mining company De Beers, Zhang analyzed two such diamonds, a 450 million-year-old diamond recovered from Brazil and a diamond from Canada’s Northwest Territories that is thought to be 1.7 billion years old.
Initially mistaking the inclusions inside the gems for more common minerals known as olivine or enstatite, Zhang used Raman spectroscopy to identify their true crystal structures.
“What I found was a spectrum the software could not match to anything in its database,” he says.
After reviewing existing literature and designing a custom identification program, Zhang discovered the samples contained tuite, marking quite possibly the first terrestrial examples of this ultra-rare mineral. Previously only found in highly shocked meteorites, tuite is a high-pressure transformation of apatite, the most common phosphate mineral found in Earth’s crust.
Finding tuite inside these diamonds proves that phosphorus can occasionally travel to the lower mantle, but Zhang’s modelling shows that this deep cycling is incredibly inefficient.
Transporting phosphorus 700 kilometres down requires an extraordinarily rare environmental anomaly, known as a “cool” subduction zone. In geological terms, this means temperatures of roughly 1,100 C, compared to the 1,700 C typical of those depths.
The presence of a second inclusion, stishovite, a very dense version of quartz that is formed only under high pressure normally reserved for the deepest parts of the Earth’s mantle, confirms that both it and the tuite were trapped inside the diamond at temperatures at least 500 C cooler than the surrounding ambient mantle.
“We know that when things become hot, they tend to rise, and when cold, their density increases, dragging the tectonic slab down,” says Zhang.
“Because we found evidence proving this slab was extremely cold, we have discovered a new mechanism for phosphorous cycling.”
The implications stretch far beyond phosphorus.
The researchers realized that when a tectonic slab is cold enough to preserve phosphorus, the extreme environment forces the descending plate to transform into an entirely new, highly dense mantle rock type. This unique density and structure likely dictates how deeply cold slabs can penetrate into the lower mantle.
Beyond insights into planetary evolution, the research carries weight for the diamond industry.
Pearson notes that super-deep diamonds account for 90 per cent of the world’s largest and most valuable gems, including the legendary Cullinan diamonds embedded in the British Crown Jewels. Because these ultra-deep stones are notoriously difficult to find, part of Zhang’s award-winning dissertation focused on creating new “indicator mineral” methods to help geologists locate these lucrative deposits.
“We try to better understand the deep Earth to help us better understand what’s happening on the surface,” says Zhang. “Because we now know why it’s difficult to subduct phosphorus into the deep mantle, we now understand why this process is important for the origin of life.”